plongo said:
When do you ever see Nasty go to ground? Very rare, sign of a very good defender. His reading of the game is 1st class, reminds me very much of Bobby M.
Apart from the fact that Bobby M constantly made killer interceptions & won crucial 1v1 challenges & difficult headers etc, which Nastasic hardly ever does.
His performance v the rags was one of the most overhyped in City history. I can see why people think he may become a quality player, but at the moment, if you had two Nastasics at the heart of our defence rather than having Vinny, Lescott or Kolo next to him, we would get mullered beyond belief in just about every game.
In the Derby we had Vinny winning 90% of everything, with Nastasic stood about making the occasional interception or giving away free kicks, & rags had Phil Jones winning 90% of everything with Camelgob stood around watching him.
The performances of Wio & Nasti were very similar, in the fact that they both did pretty much nothing of note.
Nasti got 8/10 for it.
Download the game & just watch him, alone, & try to justify the 8/10.
Anyone who gives him an 8 has to give Phil Jones 11.
Nastasic is a promising young player & that's it. The rest of the hype is ridiculous.