Middle East Conflict

I am really at a loss as to the war aims of Israel, in order to defeat Hamas they are going to have to go in very heavy and be prepared for a long urban conflict, but Hamas is like Hydra it will just pop up again and again as long as the conditions are ripe for it, so they either have to empty Gaza of it's population, which the Americans have told them not to even think about, or occupy it, which is going to be no fun for them and it will further isolate Israel, there is also the risk of further escalation in the north and the West Bank, this might be the reason a ground offensive has not happened, because they don't have a clue what to do after it's finished and also if it kicks off in the north they don't have the resources or man power to fight a war on two fronts
This is going to get really messy.
I think Hamas would have been expecting some kind of ground incursion and will have prepared for the eventuality militarily and politically. They seem pretty well armed, trained and motivated and will be relishing a Stalingrad type battle on their home turf.
We can't know but I don't think this battle will be as one sided as many people expect it to be and the Israelis won't be looking forward to it as much as people might think.
That's even before Hezbollah get involved.
 
Yet in America you lose more more children in mass school shootings than Europe does with Islamic terrorists, again you are mixing up rising populations with cultural change, there is no evidence of that whatsoever,
To suggest large scale population change, albeit lauded as multiculturalism, WITHOUT cultural change is a joke, right?!

Look around…
 
What are the chances that ChicagoBlue is unaware of this crime that happened in Chicago yesterday? 6 year old boy stabbed 26 times because he was Palestinian.

Odd that he didn't mention something that happened so close to home, but it shaken up by something that happened in Brussels. Doesn't fit the narrative he's pushing I suppose.




In a statement on Sunday, Will County Sheriff's Office said they had arrested 71-year-old Joseph Czuba for allegedly stabbing the six-year-old and his mother—who is severely injured but expected to survive—in Plainfield, Illinois on Saturday afternoon.

Czuba was the victims’ landlord, police said.

The police said the victims were attacked “due to them being Muslim and the ongoing Middle Eastern conflict involving Hamas and the Israelis.”
I’m painfully aware of the hate crime committed by a deluded old racist and denounce it unequivocally!

Are you suggesting some kind of equivalency?

I’ll assume you also want to talk about the young kid who slaughtered people inside the Temple a few years ago, too?

It’s all misdirection by deluded individuals acting out of ignorance.

I was hoping to find more nuance and discussion of the underlying causes and sentiments for these issues than the whataboutism for which the internet is famous. My mistake.

- There is no problem with mass migration.
- There is no problem with the ideologies it brings.
- There are no cultural changes in multicultural societies.

Got it! (smh)

Btw, how do we know they’re multicultural societies if there is no evidence of the different cultures?!

Carry on.
 
Don't remember seeing Bush and Blair leading the troops in Iraq, or Nixon and Johnson fighting the Vietcong, or Putin shelling the Ukrainians, or Asquith going over the top at the battle of the Somme, we could go on.
Why a different standard for the Hamas political leadership?
This comment is the epitome of everything that is wrong with the political thread here. It is full of people making what they think are clever political remarks but are actually really stupid. You see no difference between a head of state and the leader of a private army whose sole purpose is to reach a political aim through violence against innocent civilians?
Just brainless.
 
I’m painfully aware of the hate crime committed by a deluded old racist and denounce it unequivocally!

Are you suggesting some kind of equivalency?

I’ll assume you also want to talk about the young kid who slaughtered people inside the Temple a few years ago, too?

It’s all misdirection by deluded individuals acting out of ignorance.

I was hoping to find more nuance and discussion of the underlying causes and sentiments for these issues than the whataboutism for which the internet is famous. My mistake.

- There is no problem with mass migration.
- There is no problem with the ideologies it brings.
- There are no cultural changes in multicultural societies.

Got it! (smh)

Btw, how do we know they’re multicultural societies if there is no evidence of the different cultures?!

Carry on.
Perhaps you can discuss the question of “why there is mass migration” in Europe, maybe the next two statements will be easier to discuss.

1 - mass migration from Afghanistan refugees after the Afghan invasion by US and its allies
2 - mass migration from Iraq refugees after the Iraq invasion by the US and it’s allies
3 - mass migration from Syria - Libya for the same reasons -
4 - mass migration from Egypt due to West interference in local government policy and regime change operations causing security and economic instability locally
5 - a large number of migrants from countries like Pakistan due to US interference in local governments regime changes causing security and economic instability locally
6 - a large number of migrants from countries like India due to labour shortages in UK and Europe and the foreign policy to promote trade with India
7 - education being a large industry in Uk and Europe and Uk and Europe promoting its education to gain billions from international students from poorer countries.
8 - economic and social inequality across regions
9 - the geographical mobility of people today compared to 30 years ago, the language barriers being overcome, the tourism hotspots like Dubai attracting people from the west

I could go on but making an observation like Muslim population in Europe is on the rise is well and good, and factual. But if that observation leads you wonder about the cultural issues or ideological issues it causes, then perhaps look at the root cause of it. And see if the US and the west should have thought of it before pillaging country after country across the aforementioned parts of the world.

If you are going to knock down your neighbours house because you didn’t want to see him happy, don’t be surprised that when it rains or sun is at its hottest that he comes looking for shelter in your house no matter how much you dislike him as he’ll have no where to go and have no resources to build another house of his own.

The west professes that it’s culture is the best, it’s way of living is the most just, it provides the most freedom on how people should live, then don’t be surprised that people want to come and live there. And as it happens with migration, no one side loses its culture completely but a hybrid is created.
 
Last edited:
Isreali polling is vwry bad news for Netanyahu. 4 out of 5 accuse HIM of negligence over the Hamas attack AND for encouraging the spawning of the monster that is HAMAS in the first place.
Absolutely stonishing polling numbers.

Good. He fucking deserves oblivion.
 
Last edited:
I think the bigger question is why did Israel facilitate promote, encourage, finance and nurture an organisation with the stated aims of the destruction of the state of Israel?
I think it's a question more of the Israeli public should be asking.
They are asking, and lots more like the peace without peace talks strategy
 
Isreali polling is vwry bad news for Netanyahu. 4 out of 5 accuse HIM of negligence over the Hamas attack AND for encouraging the spawning of the monster that is HAMAS in Gaza n the first place.
Absolutely stonishing polling numbers.

Good. He fucking deserves oblivion.

No idea what kind of sample they've used in that polling but it's quite clear that his strategy of treating Palestinian people like animals has failed to keep Israeli Jews safe. Let's not forget, he was one of the main ringleaders stirring up opposition to Rabin's peace process nearly 30 years ago. Netanyahu and ultra nationalist Rabbis were warned at the time that their rhetoric was contributing to a hostile atmosphere and that Rabin's life was in danger. Netanyahu has never been interested in finding a route to peace which involved diplomacy or negotiation and the last PM that was was assassinated by one of his own people.
 
A hell of a lot more bloodshed to come, hey ho soon be Christmas peace and goodwill to all men and all that bollocks
 
No idea what kind of sample they've used in that polling but it's quite clear that his strategy of treating Palestinian people like animals has failed to keep Israeli Jews safe. Let's not forget, he was one of the main ringleaders stirring up opposition to Rabin's peace process nearly 30 years ago. Netanyahu and ultra nationalist Rabbis were warned at the time that their rhetoric was contributing to a hostile atmosphere and that Rabin's life was in danger. Netanyahu has never been interested in finding a route to peace which involved diplomacy or negotiation and the last PM that was was assassinated by one of his own people.
As a right wing populist he’s lasted a long time mainly by telling Israelis what they want to hear, not what they needed to hear, it’s a tragedy that it’s ended up like this, the population is divided as never before, with many young Israelis just upping and leaving

As the world sheds itself of the right wing populists, I hope Israel is next
 
No idea what kind of sample they've used in that polling but it's quite clear that his strategy of treating Palestinian people like animals has failed to keep Israeli Jews safe. Let's not forget, he was one of the main ringleaders stirring up opposition to Rabin's peace process nearly 30 years ago. Netanyahu and ultra nationalist Rabbis were warned at the time that their rhetoric was contributing to a hostile atmosphere and that Rabin's life was in danger. Netanyahu has never been interested in finding a route to peace which involved diplomacy or negotiation and the last PM that was was assassinated by one of his own people.
Credit to the Israelis in this sample who have a balanced perspective, in these terrible times. Clearly the Hamas terrorists were responsible for the initial atrocities but when there are terrorist attacks in the U.K. intelligence failures are heavily scrutinised. Something that Netanyahu’s fan boys on here don’t seem able to contemplate.

Turning to the hostages, there has to be some hope that hostages can be saved. The situation is bleak but Israel has spent decades training many of the best special forces troops in the world. There’s also rumours of prisoner swap talks but it’s hard to envisage a swap atm. There’s doesn’t seem a God atm but I’ve said a prayer for the hostages anyway.
 
Last edited:
With POTUS visiting I think this underlines just how much of a precipice the world stands on, I think the threat is clear from Iran, that their axis will join the fight, Israel may beat them but it could be ruinous for it, if America gets involved it’s just another conflict that would be never ending

What this needs is for Israeli vengeance to be satisfied, I prefer justice but here we are, and a serious attempt to solve the root cause of this, a first step would be to stop the right wing nutters in the settlement’s deliberately inflaming things, many Israelis blame them and feel that they were seeking an apocalyptic showdown with the Palestinians, hence all the provocation they were also using the IDF as a private army
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top