Milner [Merged]

[Inzi]

Re: Milner

i'd love for someone to make a pole and actually see if the majority want him or not.

i can say fo'sho lol that he is an overrated purely for the fact that he is english

tbh i think we're trying to copy chelsea and have an english spine in our starting 11

who is out english spine tho?

hart - not guaranteed though
richards - i see him going tbh (boateng)
barry - yeah he'll stay
bridge - not too sure, he's the definition of average
johnson - brilliant

so only barry and johnson guaranteed - so 2 english men in out first 11 as opposed to chealsea's 3? i don't know lol

 

[Pam]

Re: Milner

Wayne Wooney is English. Sign him.

 

[johnmc]

Re: Milner Will Cost 30 million

Is Milner actually any better than what we have already?? Would he significantly improve us?

If someone gave me the choice of SWP or Milner I'd choose SWP and I'm not SWP's biggest fan. So what if he is versatile? That doesnt hold much weight with me anyway as we should have specialists for each position. Being English is neither here nor there either.

If we pay anything over £8m I'd consider it over paying so £30m is just ridiculous. Robinho cost £30m - fair enough he hasnt done as well as we would hope but it has done far more on and off the pitch then Milner would do for us.

People are quoting the £30m bracket for the likes of Ibra and Ribery - not Milner. £30m is the going rate there or thereabouts for matchwinners. Is Milner a matchwinner - not really. I have yet to see a bit of magic to win a game from him.

 

[Seosa]

Re: Milner Will Cost 30 million

22m and Ireland and Onuoha. I think this'd do it.

 

[Anonymous]

Re: Milner Will Cost 30 million

22m and Ireland and Onuoha. I think this'd do it.

Ireland and Onuoha together are worth 20 million plus. So you're valuing Milner at Over 40 million pounds...

 

[johnmc]

Re: Milner Will Cost 30 million

22m and Ireland and Onuoha. I think this'd do it.

Therefore about £37m in total!!!!

Id want £8-10m for Ireland - well if we are using Milner as a yardstick a lot more actualy

And £5-8 for Onuha - worth more but taking injuries into account

 

[richards30]

Re: Milner Will Cost 30 million

22m and Ireland and Onuoha. I think this'd do it.

absolutely no deal!!!!!!!!! that deal would work out at least £40million!!!! maybe £15m & ireland OR £18m & ned but defo not the deal you reckon fella!!

 

[Ticket For Schalke]

Re: Milner Will Cost 30 million

20 m wouldnt get you a wank these days.

 

[johnmc]

Re: Milner Will Cost 30 million

20 m wouldnt get you a wnk these days.

Yep, it would seem they are going for £30m at Villa

 

[AntonDonJuan]

Re: Milner Will Cost 30 million

Is Milner actually any better than what we have already?? Would he significantly improve us?

If someone gave me the choice of SWP or Milner I'd choose SWP and I'm not SWP's biggest fan. So what if he is versatile? That doesnt hold much weight with me anyway as we should have specialists for each position. Being English is neither here nor there either.

If we pay anything over £8m I'd consider it over paying so £30m is just ridiculous. Robinho cost £30m - fair enough he hasnt done as well as we would hope but it has done far more on and off the pitch then Milner would do for us.

People are quoting the £30m bracket for the likes of Ibra and Ribery - not Milner. £30m is the going rate there or thereabouts for matchwinners. Is Milner a matchwinner - not really. I have yet to see a bit of magic to win a game from him.

Good post

Milner underwhelms me, people see his engine and work rate and suddenly it puts another £10m on his price