Mourinho or Mancini

[Lancet Fluke]

Mourinho.

 

[Pam]

Mourinho does the same thing over and over. Wherever he goes, the situation deteriorates in his third season. This happened with Chelsea and then Milan and now Madrid. Not Manchester though. Don't want him!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Hate this shit thread. Why can't the mods put it out of its misery.

 

[Any1aBlue]

I've never made any secret of the fact I don't like or rate Mancini. I believe we won the League inspite of him. I dont like or rate Platt for that matter either. Mancini has no history in Europe and the hash he made for two Seasons will hasten his departure.

Mancini's tactics and selections have always baffled me - pretty much every game. His 'loyalty' and pigheadedness over the idiot Balotelli is merely another example of his bemusing thought process. Surely he is THE only person in the world who still thinks Balotelli is very good - he isnt.

Mourinho on the other hand is a genius and, being crackers, he is perfectly suited to us (City). He used Mancini's team at Inter to win the CL the Season after Mancini had failed and has proven pedigree here too.
Players and fans love him and, in my opinion - its a marriage made in heaven.......................

 

[NipHolmes]

Ive said he has to be accountable for madrids poor showing in the league,which you agreed on,others on here are not having it and are blaming casilas,ramos etc etc
Where have i said bobby shouldnt be blamed for some of our poor showings,he,s the manager he should take the flack when things dont go to plan..

Ok I'm gonna use some examples of player power.

AVB, he inherited a squad he was told to lower the age of and bring in fresh faces who are younger and will lower wage bill. He dod what owner asked but wad undermined by key players and was subsequently sacked. That team miraculously regrouped and won a double. The reason is because the new manager was accepted and played for.

Real battered Barca last year and set new records. Now the team has gone to shit because players are revolting and the camps in diasarray.

You say trailing Athletico like its some substandard outfit. Please see what they have done for last few years. That teams playing for manager and Real aren't. Simple as that.

If Mancini had Kompany asking like Casillas I'd be equally as sympathetic and would chastise Kompany. It's a sad sight to see, no matter what team.

We got there in the end nipholmes
Its the players fault,not jose's

Just out of curiosity do you think its Mancinis fault we are 7 behind or the players?

Yes.

I think our lack of width is alarming. 'Mancini doesnt use wingers', why the fuck not, other top teams do. And before someone says Barca, we don't have their midfield or Messi. Pedro and Sanchez are better options than Silva and Nasri. I like both pur players as CAM not wide.

I don't see any partnerships forming attacking wise. I genuinely belive Dzeko and Aguero is best we have.

After the CL campaign we needed to lighten up and cheer up I believe. Man management is vital ebb the chips are down, we can take stock and learn and go again. I instead believe Mancini was too busy finding personal fault rather than putting the arm around needy individuals.

He said he knew the problem and didn't show that, for this reason he had no excuse.

What hurts most is lack of progress this season. I fail to see what's being built too. No way of playing (too many strategies and formations lead to confusion imo).

I'm being quite harsh but when you manage the team and squad we have, when you're paid as much as he is then its only fair.

Others have done with less. Look no further than Klopp and look at quality of Bayern.

 

[Anonymous]

Yes.

I think our lack of width is alarming. 'Mancini doesnt use wingers', why the fuck not, other top teams do. And before someone says Barca, we don't have their midfield or Messi. Pedro and Sanchez are better options than Silva and Nasri. I like both pur players as CAM not wide.

I don't see any partnerships forming attacking wise. I genuinely belive Dzeko and Aguero is best we have.

After the CL campaign we needed to lighten up and cheer up I believe. Man management is vital ebb the chips are down, we can take stock and learn and go again. I instead believe Mancini was too busy finding personal fault rather than putting the arm around needy individuals.

He said he knew the problem and didn't show that, for this reason he had no excuse.

What hurts most is lack of progress this season. I fail to see what's being built too. No way of playing (too many strategies and formations lead to confusion imo).

I'm being quite harsh but when you manage the team and squad we have, when you're paid as much as he is then its only fair.

Others have done with less. Look no further than Klopp and look at quality of Bayern.

Ouch. Cookie isn't going to like that post!

 

[NipHolmes]

Mourinho does the same thing over and over. Wherever he goes, the situation deteriorates in his third season. This happened with Chelsea and then Milan and now Madrid. Not Manchester though. Don't want him!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Hate this shit thread. Why can't the mods put it out of its misery.

No. This is bollocks.

Terry cost Jose, read Makeleles book. Didn't do bad with them either did he?

He didn't do anything bad at Inter. He left on a high of a treble.

He set records at Real.

It's being spoke of because it has legs, wouldn't be so many pages otherwise.

I find you one dimensional too.

 

[johnny crossan]

Mourinho does the same thing over and over. Wherever he goes, the situation deteriorates in his third season. This happened with Chelsea and then Milan and now Madrid. Not Manchester though. Don't want him!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Hate this shit thread. Why can't the mods put it out of its misery.

No. This is bollocks.
Terry cost Jose, read Makeleles book. Didn't do bad with them either did he?
He didn't do anything bad at Inter. He left on a high of a treble.
He set records at Real.
It's being spoke of because it has legs, wouldn't be so many pages otherwise.
I find you one dimensional too.

it's just a dress rehearsal for Sunday night in case we go double figures behind.

 

[dancity19]

Mourinho does the same thing over and over. Wherever he goes, the situation deteriorates in his third season. This happened with Chelsea and then Milan and now Madrid. Not Manchester though. Don't want him!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Hate this shit thread. Why can't the mods put it out of its misery.

Why is it a 'shit thread'?

Do you actually believe Mancini is a better manager than Mourinho?

Forget the fact that Mancini is our manager at the moment, and forget loyalty, do you think Mancini is a better manager than Mourinho?

Oh and as for the same thing he does over and over again- wins the league, wins the domestic cup, and invariably wins the Champions League. Not such a bad thing to do over and over again.

 

[bernabias home shirt]

I knew what was coming billy it was predictable
As has been said many times on this and other threads

Jose cant lose
Madrid win he is a genius
If they lose players fault and anarchy at the club

Mancini wins
Players were brilliant and dug bobby out of a hole
If we lose,he's a clown and all his fault..

 

[MSP]

If Mancini had Kompany asking like Casillas I'd be equally as sympathetic and would chastise Kompany. It's a sad sight to see, no matter what team.

I'm not Mancini big fan in any way or form and I can't like football player more than I do Kompany but if Kompany would start to play "Saint Vince" games like Casillas is playing "Saint Iker" ones, I'd support Mancini to send him to reserves to rot there. Same with Sergio Ramos.

The fact that Iker Casillas voted Sergio Ramos for Ballon d'Or says all about these two and what are they doing inside Madrid.