Otamendi is a fine player and has been a great servant to this club.
Just one red card in his City career (compare with VK). He's good in the air, good on his feet, a good tackler, fearless, a goal threat, no slouch, dependable, is rarely injured. He combines well with other players. He never complains about anything, and he maintains a low media profile. He's a proper team player, and appears to be popular amongst the staff.
Really, what's not to like?
Short sleeves and gloves?
Agree with every word by the way.