I wouldn't say I'm an expert, I did a physics degree which did touch on environmental science, and I have a healthy enough interest in geology/archaeology etc.
On the Silurian Hypothesis, I think it's fun to think about, and as with most things in science it's certainly not impossible. However, I do think there's a cap on how advanced any civilisation that came before us could be without us noticing. I don't think, for example, they could have become space faring, we would see evidence if they had been on the moon in any significant sense - our lunar lander and equipment will easily last up there for millions of years because there's nothing to erode it away save for small impacts from meteorites. I also don't think they could have been mining particularly deeply or extracting fossil fuels. Geologists would cotton on pretty quickly to the fact there were deposits missing that should be there. The scarring that deep mining causes in some areas is impossible to reverse.
So I think the cap for how advanced they could be was probably something like us circa the 1700s. If you want to hold onto some hope that it might be true, there is this thing in the geological record called the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum, which is a period when the planet warmed 5-8 degrees in a span of just few hundred thousand years, it's pretty weird and scientists aren't all agreed on the cause - though most think it is likely from a chain of volcanic eruptions.
Thanks for the reply.
I find it very interesting, I really like the idea that it might have happened....
As you say, if any previous version(s) of us had done significant damage underground there would be telltale signs of it,
and if they had fucked about like we have creating things like artificial radiation then we would be aware of it.
But what if?
What if they, unlike us, were a peace-loving cooperative society who respected nature from day one.
What if there had been no reasons for wars.
What if they had only ever burned trees and built things from natural stone.
What if they learned to harness the wind and water as a way to create power instead of trashing the planet.
There would probably be no trace of them.
No nitrogen spikes.
What if they didn't value gold or anything we see as worthy of deep mining.
What if they were so at one with each other and their surroundings that multinational corporations never evolved into convincing them that all the things we are consumers of today, that will leave a footprint, had no reason to come into existence.
They could have built great structures,
but over tens of millions of years later nothing would remain.
Tectonics, weather, gravity, would have completely wiped out any evidence of them above ground
We truly began scarring the earth 11,000 years ago but,
like you say, 1700 ish is a good baseline intuitive guess, because it sits at the start of the industrial revolution, and may leave some traces in 10 million years,
but what about 100 million years?
It could be argued that it is not until maybe 1950 when humanity's permanent global fingerprint really kicked in and will possibly still be noticeable in 100 million years.
Before that, pollution was mostly local.
I think I just want it to be true, that's all. haha. I'm a dreamer.
What it is useful for is when we explore exoplanets, as a way of checking if they too had destructive inhabitants like us in the past.