Ref Watch City Games - 2023/24

He was shocking. The grealish booking, he was literally pushed by one everton player into another, and gets a card for it. Prick of a ref. I'll give him a mark for booking Pickford for being a tit at the penalty, but he still allowed him a good 60 seconds per goal kick from minute one. I honestly don't know why Pickford got into football, he spends most of his professional career avoiding actually playing the game

The foul on Alvarez was nasty, and there were a few where he either lost control of the game, or decided everton can step it up in terms of physicality, unpunished. It nearly became a cage match at one point. But you just know, if city retaliate, out come the cards. One foul one booking for us, whereas everton were playing tag team wrestling with bookings seemingly done on a tombola system.

Also completely failed to deal with the everton staff member being arsey over returning he ball and winding grealish up, although maybe that's on the 4th official.

Then there is that offside call leading to stone's injury. Ok, I get the instruction is to hold off flagging and that I'm more salty because this time it led to an injury for one of ours, but surely the linesman can see he's clearly offside so has a duty to flag? It's not as if it was a close call..

Plus, did you notice the ref also blew for half time whilst the ball was out of play? I mean, he didn't blow when the ball went out of play, he waited until the ball has been retrieved, but not long enough for play to restart, then blew. I can only assume he got today's job confused with his other job as twatty the clown, available for hire for parties, work events and all PGMOL meetings.

He also suffers from what I'm now calling 'Its city so play on syndrome ', where he's happy to not give a foul for us , but recognises it is a foul and waves play on, even when we have absolutely zero advantage and are under huge pressure headed back towards our own goal being closed down, because city 'like to play football', are known to be hugely creative and might find a way through it, so they probably don't want a free kick. The syndrome is often paired with allowing precisely 0.5 seconds to pull a free kick back for city if the phase of play ends, compared to upwards of 2 minutes for our opponent.

Anyway, he was awful but we overcame. Maybe now they'll change the rule on when you can flag for offside.

I also just rewatched the penalty. Dyche is a douche. Hits his hands, which are raised, and stops a goal bound attempt. It's a penalty under any law and Sean Dyche is a berk playing the 'its not fair' card to deflect from his own teams failings.
 
Last edited:
He was shocking. The grealish booking, he was literally pushed by one everton player into another, and gets a card for it. Prick of a ref. I'll give him a mark for booking Pickford for being a tit at the penalty, but he still allowed him a good 60 seconds per goal kick from minute one. I honestly don't know why Pickford got into football, he spends most of his professional career avoiding actually playing the game

The foul on Alvarez was nasty, and there were a few where he either lost control of the game, or decided everton can step it up in terms of physicality, unpunished. It nearly became a cage match at one point. But you just know, if city retaliate, out come the cards. One foul one booking for us, whereas everton were playing tag team wrestling with bookings seemingly done on a tombola system.

Also completely failed to deal with the everton staff member being arsey over returning he ball and winding grealish up, although maybe that's on the 4th official.

Then there is that offside call leading to stone's injury. Ok, I get the instruction is to hold off flagging and that I'm more salty because this time it led to an injury for one of ours, but surely the linesman can see he's clearly offside so has a duty to flag? It's not as if it was a close call..

Plus, did you notice the ref also blew for half time whilst the ball was out of play? I mean, he didn't blow when the ball went out of play, he waited until the ball has been retrieved, but not long enough for play to restart, then blew. I can only assume he got today's job confused with his other job as twatty the clown, available for hire for parties, work events and all PGMOL meetings.

He also suffers from what I'm now calling 'Its city so play on syndrome ', where he's happy to not give a foul for us , but recognises it is a foul and waves play on, even when we have absolutely zero advantage and are under huge pressure headed back towards our own goal being closed down, because city 'like to play football', are known to be hugely creative and might find a way through it, so they probably don't want a free kick. The syndrome is often paired with allowing precisely 0.5 seconds to pull a free kick back for city if the phase of play ends, compared to upwards of 2 minutes for our opponent.

Anyway, he was awful but we overcame. Maybe now they'll change the rule on when you can flag for offside.

I also just rewatched the penalty. Dyche is a douche. Hits his hands, which are raised, and stops a goal bound attempt. It's a penalty under any law and Sean Dyche is a berk playing the 'its not fair' card to deflect from his own teams failings.
I did laugh as Dyche would normally bring ‘funding’ into play. It must’ve been killing him to not make that the narrative.
 
Stopped a shot on goal with his arm.
Thought this would be considered one of the clearer pens this season

This^. If it hadn’t hit his arm it wouldn’t have hit his body so it’s a clear pen - effectively stopped a shot on goal. I don’t remember this outpouring of anger and questioning the rules after the ridiculous penalty in the Cup Final.
 
Clattenberg is worth £13M net Questions should be asked

Well he was caught blackmailing his business partner but Pigmol could see nothing too much wrong in that…. Dodgy all round is Clattenburg but he’s not alone. There’s some very dark stories re Webb but he got the top job despite the stench of corruption from betting syndicates following him around.
 
Its the inconsistency with handballs that gets to everyone, i think it was a pen last night but also thought the Odegaard one against Liverpool should have been given.
 
Its the inconsistency with handballs that gets to everyone, i think it was a pen last night but also thought the Odegaard one against Liverpool should have been given.
The thing is: handballs have always been subjective and always will be. They can write as many laws and guidelines as they want but it is always going to come down to how the referees see it. So why not keep it simple?

It's another example of trying to make things so clear, they make it worse (with offside, obviously).

By the way, what decade is Dyche living in if he doesn't think that should be given as a penalty these days? Fucking dinosaur.
 
There was about a 10 minute spell in the second half were Everton pushed over City players continually. It was ridicules and it ended up with a bizarre booking for Grealish.
I cant remember the last time I saw a team get away with continually pushing.

He got the penalty right and to be honest I'm not sure why the pundits discussed it. Even in the 'old days' it was clear handball.
 
There was about a 10 minute spell in the second half were Everton pushed over City players continually. It was ridicules and it ended up with a bizarre booking for Grealish.
I cant remember the last time I saw a team get away with continually pushing.

He got the penalty right and to be honest I'm not sure why the pundits discussed it. Even in the 'old days' it was clear handball.
About the physicality, it's one of the ways a referee can manipulate a game. It breaks our rhythm, it increases emotion, it encourages a reaction. Forest anyone? It was noticeable it didn't happen in the first half, it only happened when City were in control and seemingly going to go on and win.

People like Beglin don't help either. "That's what GP wants to see" as Tarkowski clatters into a City player for the third time in 5 minutes. "Tarkowski throwing himself around", "Tarkowski this, Tarkowski that". "Giggle, giggle". Toss off.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.