tomhawley said:
The goal had an element of good fortune but it was fully deserved on the run of play.
I don't know how many times I have to say - I think that coming to us playing for a draw is perfectly acceptable.
What I disagree with is that the draw they almost got wasn't because of a superb game plan - if they game plan was to stop us and stifle us then it never even got a look in - from the first minute they were under pressure.
They almost got the draw from a ball up to nobody which Lescott misjudged - and a quality goal on the counter attach.
The way the game went forced their hand with regards the way they played - they didn't get their rewards for implementing the managers tactics perfectly. Infact in the end they couldn't even hold on to a draw that they could have needed in the end.
I think Hughes is a good manager at the level he is currently at - I am talking about this game in isolation.
I respect that you disagree but that's life and I don't really want to comment on it any more as I have work to do!
Thinking that because we won, Hughes got it wrong, is complacent thinking in the extreme. Hughes got his tactics spot on against City, regardless of whether it was rocket science to simply pick 11 mobile, hard working players and deploy them in a parked bus formation, or not.
Nearly all teams struggle in the face of this tactic, Barcelona (as we have seen) included. In fact nearly the only team that doesn't is the rags, due largely to their attacking speciality - brutal, and extremely accurate, whipped crossing, with 3 forwards running in, front post, middle and back post, needing only the faintest nick to turn the ball into the net. They take away all the defending side's natural advantages (ie time to adjust their positioning) with this tactic, and it's one of the key reasons why they always finish near the top of the heap. Almost a set play like Stoke's long thrown in, but one which happens with 10 times greater frequency per game.
City however, are far easier to frustrate. Napoli (h), Villareal (h), Sunderland (a), Everton (a), West Brom (a), QPR (h), all reduced us to hopeful shots through a thicket of legs by setting themselves up this way, and it's the reason I desperately hope we buy someone like Bale this summer, just to give us another string to our bow.