robin van persie (continued)

Status
Not open for further replies.
I was only flying a kite about balotelli and AC Milan.

AC Milan have sold their best 2 players, and they need something to lift their fans. They are backed by a very wealthy owner who will at some point try and sign Balotelli. Imagine the impact Balotelli had on Italian football over the Summer. He might conclude that now would be the right time.

Up to now all the focus has been on whether it will be Dzeko or Tevez to make way for any incoming transfer of RVP. Hust speculating on a small chance that the Italians might look at Balotelli

RVP to City wont happen unless City sell a forward.....that's not speculative
 
To sell Dzeko for RVP is really stupid idea imo.

In term of business, to let Dzeko goes and buy RVP would be the most stupid transfer mistake in the club history imo. Dzeko cost 25+ m. while RVP will cost 20+- m. as well. Dzeko is younger, fitter, and has higher resale value while RVP is injury prone, reaching 30+, has very low resale value, and will come with higher wages demand as well.

For footballing reason, I can't see what 1 season wonder like RVP will improve what we already have in the squad atm as well (note: another injury prone 1 season wonder like RSC is still at the club too.).

We already have 4 top strikers in the squad and everyone seems so happy enough to stay to fight for their places as well. I really can't see the logic that someone at the club so desperate to bring another top striker to the club while the positions that we obviously lacked, as we learned from last season, were those in midfield and centre back though.
 
bluethai said:
to let Dzeko goes and buy RVP would be the most stupid transfer mistake in the club history imo.
Click to expand...

i don't post on here much, but that is one of the most ridiculous things i've ever read.
 
bluethai said:
To sell Dzeko for RVP is really stupid idea imo.

In term of business, to let Dzeko goes and buy RVP would be the most stupid transfer mistake in the club history imo. Dzeko cost 25+ m. while RVP will cost 20+- m. as well. Dzeko is younger, fitter, and has higher resale value while RVP is injury prone, reaching 30+, has very low resale value, and will come with higher wages demand as well.

For footballing reason, I can't see what 1 season wonder like RVP will improve what we already have in the squad atm as well (note: another injury prone 1 season wonder like RSC is still at the club too.).

We already have 4 top strikers in the squad and everyone seems so happy enough to stay to fight for their places as well. I really can't see the logic that someone at the club so desperate to bring another top striker to the club while the positions that we obviously lacked, as we learned from last season, were those in midfield and centre back though.
Click to expand...
One season wonder lool. Please watch this video from the season before where he had 19 league starts and 18 goals and 7 assists. Truth is he is the best striker in the league and easily the most creative striker. Van persie creates and assist more than any other striker in the league. Watch this video from the season before....he's great player to watch

<a class="postlink" href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j9L94EO9PZw" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;">http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j9L94EO9PZw</a>
 
bluethai said:
To sell Dzeko for RVP is really stupid idea imo.

In term of business, to let Dzeko goes and buy RVP would be the most stupid transfer mistake in the club history imo. Dzeko cost 25+ m. while RVP will cost 20+- m. as well. Dzeko is younger, fitter, and has higher resale value while RVP is injury prone, reaching 30+, has very low resale value, and will come with higher wages demand as well.

For footballing reason, I can't see what 1 season wonder like RVP will improve what we already have in the squad atm as well (note: another injury prone 1 season wonder like RSC is still at the club too.).

We already have 4 top strikers in the squad and everyone seems so happy enough to stay to fight for their places as well. I really can't see the logic that someone at the club so desperate to bring another top striker to the club while the positions that we obviously lacked, as we learned from last season, were those in midfield and centre back though.
Click to expand...
I get what your saying, but if we bring in RvP and don't sell Edin his stock value will decrease due to the fact he will feature in even less games than the season just gone.
So decision needs to be made now or in the next window to maintain some value for him.
 
Tony101 said:
bluethai said:
To sell Dzeko for RVP is really stupid idea imo.

In term of business, to let Dzeko goes and buy RVP would be the most stupid transfer mistake in the club history imo. Dzeko cost 25+ m. while RVP will cost 20+- m. as well. Dzeko is younger, fitter, and has higher resale value while RVP is injury prone, reaching 30+, has very low resale value, and will come with higher wages demand as well.

For footballing reason, I can't see what 1 season wonder like RVP will improve what we already have in the squad atm as well (note: another injury prone 1 season wonder like RSC is still at the club too.).

We already have 4 top strikers in the squad and everyone seems so happy enough to stay to fight for their places as well. I really can't see the logic that someone at the club so desperate to bring another top striker to the club while the positions that we obviously lacked, as we learned from last season, were those in midfield and centre back though.
Click to expand...
One season wonder lool. Please watch this video from the season before where he had 19 league starts and 18 goals and 7 assists. Truth is he is the best striker in the league and easily the most creative striker. Van persie creates and assist more than any other striker in the league. Watch this video from the season before....he's great player to watch

<a class="postlink" href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j9L94EO9PZw" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;">http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j9L94EO9PZw</a>
Click to expand...

Why did he only start 19 games?
 
The Fat el Hombre said:
Tony101 said:
bluethai said:
To sell Dzeko for RVP is really stupid idea imo.

In term of business, to let Dzeko goes and buy RVP would be the most stupid transfer mistake in the club history imo. Dzeko cost 25+ m. while RVP will cost 20+- m. as well. Dzeko is younger, fitter, and has higher resale value while RVP is injury prone, reaching 30+, has very low resale value, and will come with higher wages demand as well.

For footballing reason, I can't see what 1 season wonder like RVP will improve what we already have in the squad atm as well (note: another injury prone 1 season wonder like RSC is still at the club too.).

We already have 4 top strikers in the squad and everyone seems so happy enough to stay to fight for their places as well. I really can't see the logic that someone at the club so desperate to bring another top striker to the club while the positions that we obviously lacked, as we learned from last season, were those in midfield and centre back though.
Click to expand...
One season wonder lool. Please watch this video from the season before where he had 19 league starts and 18 goals and 7 assists. Truth is he is the best striker in the league and easily the most creative striker. Van persie creates and assist more than any other striker in the league. Watch this video from the season before....he's great player to watch

<a class="postlink" href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j9L94EO9PZw" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;">http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j9L94EO9PZw</a>
Click to expand...

Why did he only start 19 games?
Click to expand...
cause he's an injury prone cvnt
 
The Fat el Hombre said:
Tony101 said:
bluethai said:
To sell Dzeko for RVP is really stupid idea imo.

In term of business, to let Dzeko goes and buy RVP would be the most stupid transfer mistake in the club history imo. Dzeko cost 25+ m. while RVP will cost 20+- m. as well. Dzeko is younger, fitter, and has higher resale value while RVP is injury prone, reaching 30+, has very low resale value, and will come with higher wages demand as well.

For footballing reason, I can't see what 1 season wonder like RVP will improve what we already have in the squad atm as well (note: another injury prone 1 season wonder like RSC is still at the club too.).

We already have 4 top strikers in the squad and everyone seems so happy enough to stay to fight for their places as well. I really can't see the logic that someone at the club so desperate to bring another top striker to the club while the positions that we obviously lacked, as we learned from last season, were those in midfield and centre back though.
Click to expand...
One season wonder lool. Please watch this video from the season before where he had 19 league starts and 18 goals and 7 assists. Truth is he is the best striker in the league and easily the most creative striker. Van persie creates and assist more than any other striker in the league. Watch this video from the season before....he's great player to watch

<a class="postlink" href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j9L94EO9PZw" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;">http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j9L94EO9PZw</a>
Click to expand...

Why did he only start 19 games?
Click to expand...
He was saving himself for the following season.
 
joe123 said:
bluethai said:
to let Dzeko goes and buy RVP would be the most stupid transfer mistake in the club history imo.
Click to expand...

i don't post on here much, but that is one of the most ridiculous things i've ever read.
Click to expand...


my mind goes back to a time of walshy for creaney plus cash,ahhhhh happy days.
 
The strikers we have are good enough to win the league, they just did it.

They did it last season with Tevez missing for most of it, Dzeko in and out of form and Balotelli getting sent off, banned, benched etc.

To give them all another season together makes perfect sense. Imagine how good we could be with full season availability from all 4, plus they are all a year older, a year better. Balotelli could "do an Aguero" next season quite easily.

If we sold any of Tevez, Dzeko or Balotelli for Van Perise, we risk unsettling whoever is left, plus we have to let RvP bed in, learn his role, let him have his tantrums and try to over power Mancini in the dressing room.

All for what? maybe 1 or 2 good seasons.

Its a no brainer for me. NO THANKS.

All we need is a Barry/Pizzaro type but better/younger (unless Milner can step up). A Mr Midfield dependable and MAYBE a winger, even though we dont really even play with wingers and we have AJohnson.
 
city have to look to the short term as well as the long term,yes RVP may only give us 2 seasons,but he is world class!! City have to improve on last season,our objectives are the prem and the champions league this time around,we have improved year on year since mancinis tenure,Is RVP a improvement on dzeko? hell yes!!! we have balotelli and sergio as our long term investments!! As for he's injury prone!!! he's played all 38 games in the most physical league in the world last season,u can't do that if your a croc!! it really is a no brainer if possible!!
 
<a class="postlink" href="http://www.football365.com/manchester-united/7933807/Mancini-silent-on-RvP-move" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;">http://www.football365.com/manchester-u ... n-RvP-move</a>?

Sorry if posted.
 
sir peace frog said:
joe123 said:
bluethai said:
to let Dzeko goes and buy RVP would be the most stupid transfer mistake in the club history imo.
Click to expand...

i don't post on here much, but that is one of the most ridiculous things i've ever read.
Click to expand...


my mind goes back to a time of walshy for creaney plus cash,ahhhhh happy days.
Click to expand...

exactly! people can, and will, argue the merits of rvp vs dzeko, but whichever way it works out we're not exactly going to end up with another lee bradbury.
 
Del_Bosque said:
Doesn't soubd happy with Marwood there
Click to expand...

He was supposedly at loggerheads with Marwood (and Cook) last summer too but it didn't do us much harm on the pitch in the end so I wouldn't worry about it too much. The fact that Mancini signed a 5 year contract only the other week should tell us all we need to know about where he sees his long-term future.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top