Scottish independence

Ifwecouldjust....... said:
M18CTID said:
Wilf Wild 1937 said:
The truth is both countries really are "better together". Administering a small but split island would be highly costly
compared to what we have now especially in terms of defence spending. Imo Scotland would be hit worse but
rUK wouldn't do well out of the breakup. The countries united in 1707 because it was in both their best interests.
It still is.

I agree. It's worked pretty well for over 300 years and I don't see any need to change things now. This isn't the same as giving Hong Kong back to the Chinese or Ireland getting independence. Despite all the banter, England and Scotland have been allies for over 3 centuries and the alliance has been a largely successful one.


Worked well for who though? Not the Scots and thats the problem from their perspective couple of examples

8.9% of the UK population paying 9.9% of the UK tax take
uk government wants to spend £52 billion on a high speed train link whereas there are still a large number of train lines in Scotland running on diesel
A UK Government (Not voted for by Scotland) introduced University fees which Scotland managed to resist for their own population.
UK government wants to renew Trident missile which will cost between £15 and £20 billion. The scots don't even want it and want the subs removing from their country.........

Good luck to the Scots today 'cos whatever way the vote turns out it looks as though they will be independent soon enough

We've all got our bugbears though, regardless of where in the UK we live. You're never going to please everyone. I just feel that, in spite of the things you mention above, Scotland will be even worse off if they go it alone. I could be wrong of course and Scotland may well flourish as an independent country but I don't think they have a strong and diverse enough economy to succeed.
 
johnmc said:
willy eckerslike said:
johnmc said:
A little bit surprised Andy Murray went public with his choice. Not surprised with his choice but could come back to bite him.

What's he declared?

Claims only to have been swayed in the last couple of days but it's obviously a yes from him.

Guess if he'd declared No, he'd be asking for new balls before long.
 
willy eckerslike said:
johnmc said:
willy eckerslike said:
What's he declared?

Claims only to have been swayed in the last couple of days but it's obviously a yes from him.

Guess if he'd declared No, he'd be asking for new balls before long.

Indeed. I expected him to be a yes vote, but didn't expect him to nail his colours to the mast. Fair play to him for doing so.

I was watching the channel 4 programme last night and there was a Scottish actor, don't know his name but his face was familiar, he was telling everyone how Scotland need to be independent and how much they would all benefit if the yes vote won. A woman in the audience said you are a great actor but can I ask do you have a vote tomorrow. He didn't. Some people have no shame.
 
johnmc said:
willy eckerslike said:
johnmc said:
Claims only to have been swayed in the last couple of days but it's obviously a yes from him.

Guess if he'd declared No, he'd be asking for new balls before long.

Indeed. I expected him to be a yes vote, but didn't expect him to nail his colours to the mast. Fair play to him for doing so.

I was watching the channel 4 programme last night and there was a Scottish actor, don't know his name but his face was familiar, he was telling everyone how Scotland need to be independent and how much they would all benefit if the yes vote won. A woman in the audience said you are a great actor but can I ask do you have a vote tomorrow. He didn't. Some people have no shame.

Brian Cox has been about a lot recently. Think he's pro-Independence and lives in the States.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.