NipHolmes
Well-Known Member
Seosa said:Said it before and I'll say it again; I wouldn't be disappointed if he didn't come. He may have talent, but from what I've seen he isn't the savour some of the mugs in this part of the forum make him out to be. Both Bayern and Barca have dropped clangers in the past, simply because a big club is linked with a player, doesn't make him World Class. If he does come however, he has my utmost support as he would from any Blue.
Spot on this.
He's a good player who's main attribute is flexibility. CB, CDM and CM. However he's not world class in any particular role. I like him because he saves the need for a CB and a CDM as he covers both and he oozes potential but he's most certainly not as good as De Rossi or Mascherano. Both are superior to him. I will be honest and say I want him but for reasons stated, he is also a marked upgrade on Herrera who wad touted.
If it was all my money and I had incoming fees plus 50mill I'd go all out for Mascherano (not used correctly at Barca as he's behind Busquets and plays a CB cos they don't have adequate cover) or Alonso (whom isn't inline for another contract at Real apparently and they have Khedira and Diarra). Both can pass, both can tackle and both are very competent at the highest level whist playing for teams that don't value them as highly as they should. I'd go for a quality wideman like Pedro, Bale or Navas and then a RVP to replace Dzeko. Few young kids signed to bring through in the hope one or more becomes a player to save us sheckles down the line.
But yeah, Martinez isn't the second coming of Makelele and nor is he Alonso. He's potentially world class but he's isnt there yet.