Mate, I had a feeling of foreboding from when I saw the team sheet. I had the same feeling with the Derby against ManUre, our matches against Leeds in the Prem, Chelsea in the FA Cup Semis & again against Chelsea in the CL Final.
I've no idea where you were hiding, but SEVERAL City fans & many pundits were crapping themselves that Pep would have a brainfart in the CL Final, overthink it & contribute massively to us losing, which is exactly what happened.
Pep has form for trying to pull off the spectacularly unexpected, which in recent times has tended to blow up in his face. It's simple. With three subs allowed we should have started our strongest available team & rotated when necessary.
It's about opinions. I respect yours, but I also respectfully disagree with it. This is the second season running that we've heard the same excuses about us being too tired & not being ready for the season.
Pep talked about it so much, it's as if we talked ourselves into last year's early season malaise. As they say, if you repeat something often enough, people begin to believe, so how about looking at Pep's constant downer on our preparedness for last season as a reason for our early season form?
Like I said, I don't want any other manager apart from Pep, but he's made some really strange & baffling decisions in his time here, so therefore in my opinion he shouldn't be above our criticism. This is why I don't get why you've intimated that none of us are qualified enough to analyse & criticise Pep's decisions.
He's Josep Guardiola, NOT God Almighty.... :-|