Stoke post match

It's not a case of a measuring stick. It's a case of deciding whether everyone (frank apart) that disagrees with you are doing so as they are biased towards City.

When that number includes 20 odd rags, I'd guess not.

Not my fault you can't understand the logic in that.
@malg too.

Yes, I do believe had that been Shawcross on say Stones, then people on here would be a lot more understanding of it being given.

But that's not something I can say for certain so I won't generalise like yourself.

4-1 though, great result.
 
Their penalty was 100% right under the new rules referees have been given. Sterling done fuck all but block Shawcross' run, and they've been told you can't do that. Anyone arguing that it wasn't a penalty is wrong. There is no opinion here, it's clear that Sterling impeded him - would never have been given last season, but we've moved on.
So you think that will be constantly applied in every game this season? No penalties all afternoon since, do you think there has not been equivalent contacts in the box, wise up bad decision end of.
 
I'm really not sure how many people realise just how structured Pep wants the team to be. The movement of Pep's teams can be a bit deceptive.

The crazy thing is the more you read about it, the more logical it becomes. I think there was one point Sterling was breaking and I was furious because I knew he would become isolated and positionally we would not be in the right place defensively or offensively. A year ago I would have been roaring him on.

Interesting Callabero shouting at the defenders, when they split to the edge of the box, that he was going to go long. Not sure what Pep would have made of that.
 
Great result. Good first half and end of second half performance. Average and slipped into old ways for half an hour in the second half.

Stones and Fernandinho were fantastic. Kun took his goals well but faded. Silva was involved in everything but faded.

Kolarov and Sterling struggled on the ball up the left today. Loads of times Kolarov didn't have the self esteem to play the ball forward to free men in midfield and took the easy option to go back to Stones/Fernandinho. Sterling was so predictable cutting inside, the only time he did well was when he took it up the line and crossed with his left across the six yard box but Kun didn't read it. But Sterling stuck at it and didn't give up - he was the best presser on the team today and when he went on the right he looked good.

de Bruyne was involved loads but was well average to be honest. Navas gave the ball away loads.

Zaba and Otamnedi worked hard and were fine.

Tough game though. Windy day too.

I thought they should have had a penalty first half but the one they did get should have been an indirect free kick for obstruction - Sterling didn't foul him, he blocked/shielded his path. That's not a foul/penalty, it's a free kick.

I thought too often today our players were too far away from each other. Last week and midweek we picked the ball up and had close options, today at times we slipped into Pellegrini mistakes again and had huge gaps between players. We also didn't press well (bar Sterling and Fernandinho), Stoke's pressing was miles better than ours.

But great result. And they're still learning Guardiola's ways. Though place to go for us usually so we've got it out of the way and we can think about next week now.
Hi Niall....
 
Very happy with the result, was good to go up against a physical Joke City on a wet / windy afternoon and win convincingly.

Loved Natcho's / Nolito's cameo.

Hate to critise City players but Navas dosnt help himself..
 
Just read Stones had a 93% pass completion % today! class signing! Now thats what you call a Pep CB!;)

ManCityPhotos ‏@ManCityPhotos 2h2 hours ago
John Stones' vs Stoke: 93% pass acc. 7 clearances 3 aerial duels won 1 man of the match award

CqTp48qWIAAYmlR.jpg

115 retweets144 likes
 
I don't watch Sky, but Bein said it was the worst decision of the afternoon. I also notice no other 3pm games have had penalties for similar.

Seems the rules only counted for that one corner. Bein even showed Kolarov being manhandled far worse ten mins after their pen.

Ps "experts that have played the game", now I know you're taking the piss.

Like I say you can argue about the consistency and if Kolorov was manhandled much worse ten minutes later that should also have been a penalty.

Yes there experts, impartial, and more familiar with the new directive than probably me or you.
 
No objection to penalties being given for pulling etc in the box but its no use if one ref applies it and another doesn't. Had too many years of rags getting away with murder with their defending, because refs were cowards, to now have to watch their defenders rugby tackle people in the box and get away with it whilst the rest of the league conceed penalties. Chelsea have just been denied a penalty for an offence by Watford that was much worse that Sterlings offence.
 
I agree with you that it's a good idea, just a case of how it's implemented. Of course after having one against us like that our fans will make a fuss at not getting the same treatment.

Not sure how it will affect us in Champs' League when we have to adjust to different rules. UEFA playing catch up again.

To be honest we may not have got ours last season. It was like a free for all at times. Like Pep said it should affect us less as we zonally mark so may prove a positive over the course of the season.
 
I'm not arguing whether they were penalties or not, but it's good to see that they are trying to stop
all the wrestling that goes on at corners. But wait, no, it's looks like Mr Dean is the only one, on this
crusade. Watching other games it's still happening, as usual.
 
Like I say you can argue about the consistency and if Kolorov was manhandled much worse ten minutes later that should also have been a penalty.

Yes there experts, impartial, and more familiar with the new directive than probably me or you.
Well it seems they are more familiar with the new directive than 15 other refs then as well.
 
All I keep reading on Twitter is how ibrahimovic has already scored 3 in 2 for the scum. But nothing apart from on City accounts about how Aguero has got 6 in 3. Fucking rag arse sucking media twats.
 
No objection to penalties being given for pulling etc in the box but its no use if one ref applies it and another doesn't. Had too many years of rags getting away with murder with their defending, because refs were cowards, to now have to watch their defenders rugby tackle people in the box and get away with it whilst the rest of the league conceed penalties. Chelsea have just been denied a penalty for an offence by Watford that was much worse that Sterlings offence.

Not just the penalties, but near the end of the match today there was a rugby tackle right in front on the right sided lino and right under the refs nose.
Nothing. Not even a flag from the lino.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top