You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
The decision to loan Barry and keep Garcia.
- Thread starter Ban-jani
- Start date
the originalkippaxman said:Be back shortly going to find a brick wall to head butt for several minutes. He has gone he wanted regular first team football and we could not offer that.
Make sure you give it a strong head butt.
inchy14
Well-Known Member
Ban-jani said:I've been watching Everton a bit this season and in particular Barry, of whom I'm a huge fan.
This isn't a thread cricising Pellegrini, as I really like him and think he's improved things,
but I want to know why the club decided we'd loan Gareth but keep Javi?
Barry's passing is far more varied and he can make penetrative balls through,
whereas Garcia cannot and passes from side to side.
Their pace is similar - next to none, but Barry reads the game much better and
get's into positions early so his pace isn't too much of an issue.
I've been thinking about this a lot recently (I know I should be just enjoying
our form!) and I want to know what other blues think?
I personally think it was a terrible decision, as was selling Suarez. The good news
is the rest of our transfer market, Jovetic aside, was fantastic.
Wages.
Versatility, Garcia has also played at centre half, would Barry?
Less likely to rock the boat due starting games.
And in my view, Everton would have wanted Barry and we may want first option on Barkley and this will help in that aim.
Manchester33
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 12 Sep 2012
- Messages
- 6,837
Garcia is better, has a lot more potential, and I imagine is on a much lower wage!
the originalkippaxman
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 12 Jul 2012
- Messages
- 1,558
Ban-jani said:the originalkippaxman said:Be back shortly going to find a brick wall to head butt for several minutes. He has gone he wanted regular first team football and we could not offer that.
Make sure you give it a strong head butt.
Intend to let me know when you open a we should never have sold De Jong thread so I can stick some 6 inch nails through my boll*cks.
lust overlord
Well-Known Member
BoyBlue_1985 said:World Cup year and Barry wanted a starting role rather than sub and rotation apperances ala Garcia?
Almost certainly correct.
+ only 1 year left on contract.
Shame he couldn't stay but you can't blame him for wanting to play more.
FredTilson
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 25 Apr 2013
- Messages
- 864
Besides the aforementioned points, I believe Garcia is on considerably lower wages as well.
the originalkippaxman said:Ban-jani said:the originalkippaxman said:Be back shortly going to find a brick wall to head butt for several minutes. He has gone he wanted regular first team football and we could not offer that.
Make sure you give it a strong head butt.
Intend to let me know when you open a we should never have sold De Jong thread so I can stick some 6 inch nails through my boll*cks.
We sold De Jong, we have only loaned Barry and can get him back at the end of the season.
Think about it.
In reference to wages, I think we could have got money for Garcia and have his wages off the books so that would have more than covered Barry.
I also think Barry could have stepped in for either Yaya or Fernandinho more effectively.
BoyBlue_1985
Well-Known Member
Thats my thinking him and Pelle obviously had a chat and came to the decision. I think its a nice touch from pelle in all honesty to let him know where he stood and then not stand in his way when he wanted to go out on loan. Barry will get a lovely free transfer at the end of this season as well. I dont think he will have any negative feelings towards pelle or Citylust overlord said:BoyBlue_1985 said:World Cup year and Barry wanted a starting role rather than sub and rotation apperances ala Garcia?
Almost certainly correct.
+ only 1 year left on contract.
Shame he couldn't stay but you can't blame him for wanting to play more.
jimbopm
Well-Known Member
Everton are proving to be a bit of a thorn in the side of those in and around us, they've beaten United and Chelsea whilst holding Tottenham, Arsenal and Liverpool to draws. We have so far managed to beat them at home.
Barry is a key figure in their team, more important than someone like Lukaku because of his experience playing the big teams at the top of the table. He is still effectively doing a job for City because he can't play against us so therefore can't hurt us.
If we can win the fixture at Goodison (a big ask historically) and Everton continue to pinch points off our rivals, it will be a huge boost for out title chances. Would he have been better in our team? Probably, but he's not done us any harm and it actually might turn out to be a good strategic move by City.
Barry is a key figure in their team, more important than someone like Lukaku because of his experience playing the big teams at the top of the table. He is still effectively doing a job for City because he can't play against us so therefore can't hurt us.
If we can win the fixture at Goodison (a big ask historically) and Everton continue to pinch points off our rivals, it will be a huge boost for out title chances. Would he have been better in our team? Probably, but he's not done us any harm and it actually might turn out to be a good strategic move by City.