I had not seen this. As I write events have moved on this afternoon as you will know and Starmer has realised he will not be able to simply hold the fort on this one. Looks like window dressing to me but we will see. So as to your first point government said no - well now they say yes ( kind of)
We would probably disagree on who "people who know what they are talking about" are, that said given its limitations it does appear the Telford inquiry was a good example of its type. Cooper referenced it today in her statement as the model for the five more she will fund. However, I would refer you to the questions Sarah Champion asked Cooper in the House today, this type of enquiry does not have the power to compel anyone to give evidence . It simply isn't good enough. Sarah Champion as the MP for Rotherham is a person I would believe knows what she is talking about on these matters and she clearly believes this Telford style enquiry will not suffice. The victims deserve to see those who have let them down be held to account . This will only happen with a full Government led enquiry.
As for Mr Afzal, I think he does know what he is talking about but only chooses to tell us what he thinks we should hear. In regard to the article, I agree with him that race is not the issue, it is ethnicity. He has a point about night time economy workers but that cannot be an excuse. He says that this issue is nothing to do with religion, it is about Male power over women - yes, but what religion promotes male power over women like Islam ? I could go on.
Here is an article from an interview with him the year before yours where he met Muslim community leaders in Bradford, he explicitly references the over representation of Pakistani men in grooming gangs and criticises the community and its leaders for not doing more to prevent this ( as he does to a lesser degree in you article)
Crown Prosecution Service’s lead on child sexual abuse urges community to report suspected cases of child sexual exploitation by Asian and Pakistani men and says ‘don’t walk by’
www.theguardian.com
As Afzal says this is a minority of the Muslim community and that is of course true but as he says if they want to be able to hold up their heads they must do much more to call this out.
I think this guy, Taj Hargey is much closer to the truth. He has his own agenda in regard to promoting his modernist , liberal interpretation of Islam but I believe he fully understands what is happening in Britains Mosques and the messages that certain Imam's deliver. He said this in 2013.
View attachment 143355
View attachment 143356View attachment 143357