VAR Discussion Thread - 2023/24 | PL clubs to vote on whether to scrap VAR (pg413)

[urban genie]

That audio is a right shit show, bit bacls up it was a fuck up, so now the matter should rest

 

[bluenova]

What I took from that is how chaotic and rushed it is. It was all over the show, too many people talking and far too rushed. No wonder it’s a fuck up.

That was a dream compared to the Akanji one, where they seemed to be shouting over the top of each other in a right panic.

 

[Betterdeedthan red]

Bloody hell.this will go on 20 years.
They will sue var when they don't win tge league.
It will be the sun new papers fault.
They will light candles about this for year.
Victim bastards

 

[Manchester_lalala]

Now that that fuck up has been cleared up. Can we have the audio for why Rashford was allowed to cheat against us now?

We won’t hear that for particular reasons.

 

[dark 'n stormy]

VAR need to be using clear concise language when communicating, almost akin to air traffic control rooms. Not having a ‘conversation’ something like
We say Offside
We say Onside
We say Handball
We say Red card

 

[TinFoilHat]

Bloody hell.this will go on 20 years.
They will sue var when they don't win tge league.
It will be the sun new papers fault.
They will light candles about this for year.
Victim bastards

Well win it by 12 points. They'll have no case.

:)

 

[willipp]

That was a dream compared to the Akanji one, where they seemed to be shouting over the top of each other in a right panic.

They are under so pressure to make a quick decision that they all just talk over each other and rush to a decision. Recipe for disaster.

 

[TinFoilHat]

VAR need to be using clear concise language when communicating, almost akin to air traffic control rooms. Not having a ‘conversation’ something like
We say Offside
We say Onside
We say Handball
We say Red card

I agree.

Listening to refs when their altogether it sounds like a group of Ladz in a bar.

Simple question like; "What was the onfield decision?" would have saved a lot of stress. Although the candle industry profits would have suffered.

 

[BlueHammer85]

I don't think they come out of it that badly.

What you do see is that the mistake was spotted by the assistant as soon as the game restarted, but it shows how fast they're having to do things, because by the time they've literally exchanged a couple of sentences, the ball has been down one end and up the other and out for a throw.

It's clear that it's a fuck up, and I assume the protocol will change, so that it's no longer an ambiguous "check complete", but frankly you can see how it happened.

Well said.
It was a screw up. No sign of ‘agenda’ and corruption etc

They just need to tweak that rule that even after kick off they can go back to correct a decision.

 

[dadnlad]

Bloody hell.this will go on 20 years.
They will sue var when they don't win tge league.
It will be the sun new papers fault.
They will light candles about this for year.
Victim bastards

atleast a day of remembrance every year

 

[dronefromsector7G]

What an absolute clusterfuck. How can they get something seemingly simple so wrong?

 

[plattlanebenches]

Any death threats from the ferals yet?

 

[Manchester_lalala]

I’m actually going to stick up for them (a bit). It’s an honest mistake, a mistake they shouldn’t make but they have. Hopefully they all learn from this, I’m pro VAR so I want it to improve.

Fuck the scouse cunts anyway.

 

[TinFoilHat]

Any death threats from the ferals yet?

Is water wet?

 

[The Stockport Iniesta]

Well said.
It was a screw up. No sign of ‘agenda’ and corruption etc

They just need to tweak that rule that even after kick off they can go back to correct a decision.

Can't wait for someone to get sent off ten minutes after a foul, with the player scoring a goal in-between the foul and the sending off.

 

[Stephen230]

That was a dream compared to the Akanji one, where they seemed to be shouting over the top of each other in a right panic.

That was misleading. There were two independent conversations going on simultaneously, one between the onfiejd officials, the other what was being said in the VAR.

They played them both over each other, presumably to give a real time feel to it, regarding what was happening on the field. But just ended up sounding like a load of people talking over each other.

 

[citizen_maine]

I agree.

Listening to refs when their altogether it sounds like a group of Ladz in a bar.

Simple question like; "What was the onfield decision?" would have saved a lot of stress. Although the candle industry profits would have suffered.

Shouldn't even need to ask what the on field decision was

Ref: "Check required"
VAR/AVAR review it
VAR: "Check complete. Decision: Goal"

 

[BlueMoonday]

I’m actually going to stick up for them (a bit). It’s an honest mistake, a mistake they shouldn’t make but they have. Hopefully they all learn from this, I’m pro VAR so I want it to improve.

Fuck the scouse cunts anyway.

I wonder if they would have bowed down to any other club and release audio footage? Probably not, as there's no threat of enquiries and victimhood from any other club.

 

[BlueHammer85]

What an absolute clusterfuck. How can they get something seemingly simple so wrong?

It’s rare. Happens all lines of work. It happens.

 

[dadnlad]

That was misleading. There were two independent conversations going on simultaneously, one between the onfiejd officials, the other what was being said in the VAR.

They played them both over each other, presumably to give a real time feel to it, regarding what was happening on the field. But just ended up sounding like a load of people talking over each other.

thats clearer than akanji one the ref was that unfit all you can here is him trying to catch his breath after what appears to of run a marathon