VAR thread 2022/23

[TonyColemansbagofapples]

Can anyone give me examples of where we have benefited from referees against these. In over fifty years I can only recall a wrong decision against Sterling (playing for dippers against us at the Etihad) where he was wrongly flagged offside.
I can recall many, MANY wrong ones for us.
Can't ever see them evening themselves out.

 

[Trevor Morley's Tache]

Can anyone give me examples of where we have benefited from referees against these. In over fifty years I can only recall a wrong decision against Sterling (playing for dippers against us at the Etihad) where he was wrongly flagged offside.
I can recall many, MANY wrong ones for us.
Can't ever see them evening themselves out.

Milner could have been sent off three times over, TAA handball, Sterling offside... and loads more.

Can't remember a single contentious decision going our way.

 

[Gazza]

Milner could have been sent off three times over, TAA handball, Sterling offside... and loads more.

Can't remember a single contentious decision going our way.

Robertson foul on Sterling, Sane goal not offside in the same CL match, Jesus goal not offside in return leg.

 

[Blue Mist]

Can anyone give me examples of where we have benefited from referees against these. In over fifty years I can only recall a wrong decision against Sterling (playing for dippers against us at the Etihad) where he was wrongly flagged offside.
I can recall many, MANY wrong ones for us.
Can't ever see them evening themselves out.

Yes, can't remember which season but the ball went out for a throw in off Tommy Smith and it was given City's way.

 

[GaudinoMotors]

soooooo

Haaland's tug was a foul and Salah didn't handball it. There, I said it.

Haaland's tug was 50/50 and too early in the build up (for Var to go back to) and Salah did handball it. There, I replied

 

[BlueHammer85]

Haaland's tug was 50/50 and too early in the build up (for Var to go back to) and Salah did handball it. There, I replied

also Salah was well offside for that goal

 

[Trevor Morley's Tache]

also Salah was well offside for that goal

Was he?

 

[Stephen230]

Can't remember a single contentious decision going our way.

That’s because you are City fan and human nature dictates that perceived injustices will stick in your mind for ever more. Whilst lucky breaks are forgotten about almost as soon as they happen.

 

[remember arthur mann]

soooooo

Haaland's tug was a foul and Salah didn't handball it. There, I said it.

 

[Trevor Morley's Tache]

That’s because you are City fan and human nature dictates that perceived injustices will stick in your mind for ever more. Whilst lucky breaks are forgotten about almost as soon as they happen.

I think I'd remember the Dipper's (and the media) outrage if their had been.