The record against the top 10 this year , the bottom three , the fact he spouted time and again we had two players of equal ability for most if not all positions and the best squad and that he never uses injuries as an excuse for under performing suggests that by his own standards he has come well short of what he expected in the premiership this year.
By any measure we have under achieved in the premiership over the past two seasons and MP is a major factor as to why this has occurred.
He doesn't have the skill set to get the best out of a team that is seeking to be a real force and significant player in the premiership or any of the top leagues for that matter.
He wasn't the best choice to replace RM but he was someone well known to the DOF and co as someone who could ensure the press wouldn't make a meal out of the next bust up between RM and his employers and or the playing team because he would limit if not eliminate the opportunity for it to happen which he did.
On top of that he would do as he was told and if so would suffer zero interference for above in terms of what he did with the squad during the week and on match days and have any players he wanted some of which he had managed before chased.
He has not got the best out of the squad from the time he joined and we play less as a team in terms of what we do on and off the ball than we did when he first joined.
Our urgency has diminished when its needed , our basic skills have deteriorated under his watch.
Individual players have lost the will to take on players and take the easy option under his watch. ( Sterling and Navas to name but two )
Sides are no longer concerned about playing at COMS and if they press they know they have our measure.
His appointment will be viewed in history as an average one as we have regressed and in some cases significantly like basic skills ( crossing , corners , throw ins , set piece defending and attakcing to name but a few ) in almost all of the key performance indicators under his watch.
The players do not respect him or his coaching abilities and for some his complacent attitude on match days has been there to see in the players approach to games many of which a better manager would have ensured we got a better result with the same group of players.