My issue was with hitchcliffe. But I must point out you said you agreed with him.
I'm just saying the hitchcliffe point was false. And just for kicks, Sterling was undroppable until Pelegrini started dropping him. And so was Yaya until Pelegrini benched him.last game. Silva too was benched a few games before that. And DeBryune was in a cup game ( which carries les s weight I know) but he will be benched soon too. And if we lose again, the same "Pelegrini never changes anything" diatribe will continue in absolute opposition to reality.
Mate, Hinchcliffe's point (if this is what he meant) was we played with Silva, KDB and Yaya away to a high tempo, high pressing team like WHU, when in my book I'd have started with Delph and Fernandinho with one from Silva, Yaya or KDB behind Aguero, with Sterling left and Navas right.
It was obvious from the get go that we didn't have the high energy tempo to compete. Hinchcliffe was also right in saying that based on what he could see, the only way he could see us getting control of the match was if WHU began to tire as the tempo they set would be hard to maintain over 90 minutes.
You're nitpicking over which player is better than who when its obvious that Hinchcliffe's overall point was about the team being unbalanaced with having Yaya in a midfield two and a powder puff KDB on the left. Both KDB and Silva were way below par Silva especially and its an interesting point that many times under Manuel some of our most telling performances have come when we've had an injury crisis and he's been forced to play the players available in their strongest positions.
Bayern, Roma and Sevilla all spring to mind as does the festive period of 2014. Ok in 2014, Milner ended up playing as an emergency striker because we didn't have any other options, but the point is everyone else was played in their strongest position.
Last week Yaya was 'rested' and we looked stronger in Midfield, then his agent starts making noises and Yaya's back in a midfield two away to WHU. I still maintain that we should have started with Sterling on the left and Fernandinho partnering Delph with one from KDB/Silva/Yaya behind Aguero. Its seems to be a choice between keeping the biggest stars happy or picking the most balanced team.
Thank fuck Nasri's out of the equation as that would only make the situation worse.