Re: Yaya Toure
Mister Appointment said:
dan.j.mcfc said:
It's not a race issue, it's maybe a mentality issue, social issue, economical issue, at no point however does he state that it's a "black player issue".....go and find a distasteful joke about Rolf Harris to offend yourself with, there's really nothing here.
Care to explain how the mentality of an African athlete is different from the mentality of say, an English athlete? And where do you draw the line when making this ignorant sweeping generalisation? Is Nasri and African athlete in this context or a French one?
Lets look at social and economic issues next. How is it different growing up in extreme poverty in Africa as opposed to Brazil or Argentina? Do you think Carlos Tevez is descended from Africans because he has moved around so much during his career for money and has shown no loyalty to any club he's been at?
First of all Nasri is quite clearly French, having been born in France and spending the first 21 years of his life there, unless you were referring to a specific point about Nasri that I've missed? To answer your second question I'd be willing to draw the line at ignorant sweeping generalisations (which I'm not doing), when they directly refer to someones skin colour/race. Talking about a general attitude towards football in regards to what part of the world they come from is completely fine, or is it now racist to say that Brazilian children are more dedicated towards football than English children? As I've said previously there are number of factors which contribute to the mentality of people from different parts of the world, NOT THEIR SKIN COLOUR.
Ok lets look at the difference between poverty in Brazil and for arguments sake the Ivory Coast, the fact the under 20% of Brazilians live below the national poverty line and nearly half of Ivorian's live in poverty would give you the idea that it's generally much tougher in Africa than South America, although you probably already know, that Africa is by some distance the poorest continent in the world.
I'm still however failing to see a connection to race anywhere here? I base the mentality of certain people on their social and economic factors, again not on skin colour. If say 100 hundred newborn Somalian children were adopted by British parents, I'm guessing here, but I'd make the claim their attitude, character and life choices would be slightly different than if they stayed in their native homeland. Due to numerous things, including upbringing, education, job prospects, health service etc...most definitely not RACE. You seem adamant that it's somehow offensive to make claims about people from different parts of the world and that it somehow refers to their skin colour, can I ask why?
Major Edit**
People from all continents are twats based on all manner of things; Tevez, Toure, Barton, me, etc....In fact all humans in general are manipulative, lying, greedy, vile creatures, hows that for sweeping generalisation :)