Claudio Bravo - 2016/2017 performances (continued)

Status
Not open for further replies.
karen7 said:
Compare the saves the other 19 are making v juliet then we can discuss the difference
Click to expand...

it doesn't matter what they do, you've told me before that you're only concerned about what happens in a City shirt, are you changing that stance now?
 
B\connellblue said:
Cant wait to see the back of him. Would be nice for once after a game to say. Wow our keeper kept us in it or better still won it for us.never happen with this guy. Watched lots of el classico reruns last week and guess what never made a save in Them either. If pep keeps him expect no better from him next season
Click to expand...

Lots eh? How many would you say and why would you even watch full reruns?
 
Rolee said:
it doesn't matter what they do, you've told me before that you're only concerned about what happens in a City shirt, are you changing that stance now?
Click to expand...
Why are you bending this out of shape? what he did before he came to city doesn't matter to me because i judge him and the others how they perform in blue,watching the others will give you a comparison on shot stopping ability and show you where he is failing,if you don't want to put in the time to watch other games then thats up to you but i do,he is the worst in the league easily
 
karen7 said:
Why are you bending this out of shape? what he did before he came to city doesn't matter to me because i judge him and the others how they perform in blue,watching the others will give you a comparison on shot stopping ability and show you where he is failing,if you don't want to put in the time to watch other games then thats up to you but i do,he is the worst in the league easily
Click to expand...

I'm bending nothing out of shape, I just find it amusing how keepers playing elsewhere is relevant now when Bravo's performances for Barca were irrelevant.

I watch plenty of games btw so quit assuming you know anything about my football watching habits.
 
karen7 said:
So have you never compared one of our players to others you see when you watch other games?
You are being dense with the first bit of your post
Click to expand...

Thanks for the personal abuse.

Of course I've compared players elsewhere, I compared Bravo to Hart last season as an example.
 
Rolee said:
We'll leave it there Karen, you're either purposely dodging my point or you're completely missing it.
Click to expand...
What am i dodging? our players are judged by our fans in our shirts,comparing our players to others players in the same position is what ALL fans do,2 completely different things
Dense wasn't meant to be personal abuse so sorry for that
 
karen7 said:
What am i dodging? our players are judged by our fans in our shirts,comparing our players to others players in the same position is what ALL fans do,2 completely different things
Dense wasn't meant to be personal abuse so sorry for that
Click to expand...

Dismissing what Bravo did elsewhere in our appraisals of him is unfair, particularly if you're going to now use other keepers' performance elsewhere as a stick to beat him with.
 
Rolee said:
Dismissing what Bravo did elsewhere in our appraisals of him is unfair, particularly if you're going to now use other keepers' performance elsewhere as a stick to beat him with.
Click to expand...
He has been here nearly a whole season so we can appraise him,like i say comparing players we all do it
We are apprasing him on his current performance,Playing for barca is not the same as playing for us,he got a lot of protection in that barca team and is exposed to more shots here and it has shown his shot stopping skills are poor,We can't see into the future and the past has gone so we judge all players on this seasons form,all the players are getting it so i don't know what the problem is including him in it,he is no more immune to critism than the others and the manager
Lets leave it here as neither is going to give any ground as we disagree on the fundermentals
 
Rolee said:
Dismissing what Bravo did elsewhere in our appraisals of him is unfair, particularly if you're going to now use other keepers' performance elsewhere as a stick to beat him with.
Click to expand...
images
 
karen7 said:
He has been here nearly a whole season so we can appraise him,like i say comparing players we all do it
We are apprasing him on his current performance,Playing for barca is not the same as playing for us,he got a lot of protection in that barca team and is exposed to more shots here and it has shown his shot stopping skills are poor,We can't see into the future and the past has gone so we judge all players on this seasons form,all the players are getting it so i don't know what the problem is including him in it,he is no more immune to critism than the others and the manager
Lets leave it here as neither is going to give any ground as we disagree on the fundermentals
Click to expand...

Dodging the point again.

His shot stopping skills aren't poor, based on this season his form is, probably as Zaba has said through lack of confidence, may in part be owing to his struggles to settle which aren't really surprising given that he's been treated like a pariah from day one and he's also had the seriously poor health of his baby daughter to contend with.

He's not exposed to more shots here btw.

Here's a comparison from last season

Bravo played 32 games in Liga last season and faced 104 shots on target of which he saved 84

Hart played 35 games in PL last season and faced 106 shots on target of which he saved 71

We don't disagree on the fundamentals btw, I fully accept he hasn't been up to scratch in terms of shot stopping, what I do disagree with is when this criticism becomes absurd, for example putting any blame whatsoever on him for Sunday or suggesting that he did anything wrong.
 
Rolee said:
Dodging the point again.

His shot stopping skills aren't poor, based on this season his form is, probably as Zaba has said through lack of confidence, may in part be owing to his struggles to settle which aren't really surprising given that he's been treated like a pariah from day one and he's also had the seriously poor health of his baby daughter to contend with.

He's not exposed to more shots here btw.

Here's a comparison from last season

Bravo played 32 games in Liga last season and faced 104 shots on target of which he saved 84

Hart played 35 games in PL last season and faced 106 shots on target of which he saved 71

We don't disagree on the fundamentals btw, I fully accept he hasn't been up to scratch in terms of shot stopping, what I do disagree with is when this criticism becomes absurd, for example putting any blame whatsoever on him for Sunday or suggesting that he did anything wrong.
Click to expand...
How many shots has he faced and saved here? comparing to joe and the different styles of play between us and barca is neither here or there,if yo want to take his barca form into account then give his stats here and there
I haven't said he did anything wrong as such but again someone like de gea would have got his foot to the first one imo
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top