Eric Garcia to Barcelona

[Neville Kneville]

Whoever is performing best in training, plays. If it's Garcia, Stones, Otamendi, Fernandinho or Harwood-Bellis, who cares.

Me tbh.

I think we should have been playing proper cb pairings & THB in the dead games rather than farting around with Garcia.

For me, he would only play from now on if everyone else was injured.

 

[ctid1894]

I'm sure if Garcia plays he will want to knock Real out.

However, we now know for sure the rumours are true and Barca have well a truly tapped him up so I'd generally sideline him and focus on guys who intend to stay. Ideally, we'll do a deal with Barca this summer.

I'm already on record as saying that I'd rather keep Stones so not too concerned over Garcia's decision. Just hope we get another top quality CB signed and have whoever that is, Stones, LaPorte and Ake as our main guys.

Yeah I can understand that, ideally I wanted both to stay. Now it gives us the opportunity to really look at Adaradiayo and Harwood-Bellis, someone leaving always creates an opportunity for another player. I could understand us bringing in another CB now as well, although I don't think it's entirely necessary, there's definitely a stronger case for it.

 

[ninjamonkey]

No issues with him wanting to leave, not every single player is going to want to stay here for life, we’ve been spoiled in the last decade but we have to accept players don’t always want the same as what the club wants.

At least he’s not dicking us around stalling on an answer. Been saying since his breakthrough his pace and physique isn’t suited for CB, particularly not in this league, he was exposed numerous times post lockdown and unless he finds a growth spurt, a new level of speed and a year in the gym bulking up that’s going to remain an issue. could have developed into a very useful squad player for us but I don’t see him as future starter for us or Barca so the loss isn’t overly difficult to take.

No more special treatment getting games because we want to encourage him to stay, he’s currently not good enough to be playing for us, he’s not currently better than stones, Otamendi or Fernandinho and with no future benefit of tying him down to a long contract there’s no reason to play him against Madrid. THB to step ahead of him for next season if he isn’t sold, just a shame this 5subs rule isn’t sticking around, his opportunities for minutes could have been far greater.

Barca surely aren’t going to come in for him this summer, I said this last week, he’s not ready to play for them regularly right now so as long as they’re confident he’ll sign for them on a free it makes no sense not to wait for a year given their financial issues.

 

[Neville Kneville]

He’s obviously not up for the fight with Ake and potentially Koulibally, which is fine, but surely he had more chance of game time for us than at Barca who are definitely going to need a defensive overhaul soon

Hopefully he is it.

Would be hilarious when the fans actually see him.

 

[Benarbia’s Backheel]

phewwwww..... the guy thinks hes the next best thing since slice bread. Bollocks, no loss from our sides. Bang average and he wont be an exceptional defender mark my words. He will be another Puyol. Energy. Passion but no skill.

I’d actually say he’s the complete opposite of Puyol. Not energetic or aggressive, but has skill and a great brain. Again, the opposite of Puyol

 

[Neville Kneville]

I'm sure if Garcia plays he will want to knock Real out.

However, we now know for sure the rumours are true and Barca have well a truly tapped him up so I'd generally sideline him and focus on guys who intend to stay. Ideally, we'll do a deal with Barca this summer.

I'm already on record as saying that I'd rather keep Stones so not too concerned over Garcia's decision. Just hope we get another top quality CB signed and have whoever that is, Stones, LaPorte and Ake as our main guys.

Pep will know if Stones is viable or not.

 

[ManCitizens.]

I believe kids refer to this as 'negotiating'. Barca leaked they intend to offer 10M + variables and City come back to leak they value him much higher

There was something about the tenor of Pep's responses and not actually mentioning Barca that made me wonder. Now, makes more sense that they don't intend to be steamrolled by just any offer.

Of course, I can also confirm without any sources needed that there's no way Barca will pay more than 10-15M for a player that is seen as left via the backdoor. Now that Pep confirmed the player will leave, it means it frees the player to respond to questions and if City take a strong stance then Barca will pressure to play things out in the media along with influencing the player to apply pressure too. There's already bad blood there despite professionalism. If you're City you also don't want to alienate potential cantera kids from coming if they sense they will be punished when looking for an exit. No one will want it to drag on until winter when he can sign for free. It's delicate so I do think the messaging reflects that too.

But if it gets played out in the media, well it won't be pretty or good for anyone. A big reason why I still believe it will ultimately go smoothly considering those involved (Puyol, Eric, Pep & Txiki) - City will not want to look foolish and Barca will ultimately let them save some face. Perhaps then 10M will become 15M as a compromise (Along with bonuses) to get it done sooner

We’re a far better run club than you are and will decide the price that is acceptable to us. Either way, you have more than enough money with the brand spanking new 800m loan.

 

[Gabriel]

If you don't rate him, you're entitled to your opinion. My post was in response to questioning the lads integrity and professionalism which is completely different.

I do rate him, actually, though as a prospect and certainly not the player I’d trust in our most important game. I agree that it’s not a question of integrity but business, which was the closing point being made by the poster to whom you were responding.

 

[Neville Kneville]

I’d actually say he’s the complete opposite of Puyol. Not energetic or aggressive, but has skill and a great brain. Again, the opposite of Puyol

I agree.

If he had some of what Puyol had, he wouldn't be so easy to beat.

 

[Mr Ed (The Stables)]

If Garcia stays until next season and then leaves, would we not get a fee set by a tribunal. Similar to the dippers having to pay £6.5m for Danny Ings from Burnley in 2015. Or am I barking up the wrong tree.

 

[Carlos- the- jackal]

But I dont think they have played recently. Stones had a run out of the bench a few weeks back but that was it.

Think it will be Lapote and Fernandinho personally, Pep only wants players who are 100% committed to the club, saying that if Garcia does play i’m sure he’ll give his all, seems a good profesional.

 

[ctid1894]

Me tbh.

I think we should have been playing proper cb pairings & THB in the dead games rather than farting around with Garcia.

For me, he would only play from now on if everyone else was injured.

Unless someone comes out and refuses to play, I see no reason to push them away. Ake must have known he was leaving Bournemouth whether they stayed up or went down and you only have to glance at their fan forum to see how much commitment he showed, the desperate lunge he made which got himself injured says everything. There's no reason to think Garcia wouldn't do the same.

If people don't rate him or think he's not the best from a footballing perspective, I have no problems. It's the idiots questioning players commitment which frustrate me, when there's no justification at all.

 

[Maly]

Then he will just leave on a free? we will sell this summer like we did with sane it doesnt make sense to let him go on a free, barca dont need him right now

He won’t go on a free as he’s under 23

 

[Keeper!]

phewwwww..... the guy thinks hes the next best thing since slice bread. Bollocks, no loss from our sides. Bang average and he wont be an exceptional defender mark my words. He will be another Puyol. Energy. Passion but no skill.

LOL Puyol was an outstanding player and captain for Barca.

 

[WestGorton]

Rubbish. A player wanting to leave doesn't mean he isn't committed to performing as well as he can for his current club, especially against his boyhood clubs arch rivals. Honestly some people on here are crackers, over emotional and must have zero personal pride or professionalism in their own life to think everybody behaves in such a way. It really is quite pathetic from grown adults.

Calm down Mother Theresa. He isn't good enough anyway in my view. He is no longer committed by his actions. That 50 50 tackle.......

 

[SiMCFC]

I believe kids refer to this as 'negotiating'. Barca leaked they intend to offer 10M + variables and City come back to leak they value him much higher

There was something about the tenor of Pep's responses and not actually mentioning Barca that made me wonder. Now, makes more sense that they don't intend to be steamrolled by just any offer.

Of course, I can also confirm without any sources needed that there's no way Barca will pay more than 10-15M for a player that is seen as left via the backdoor. Now that Pep confirmed the player will leave, it means it frees the player to respond to questions and if City take a strong stance then Barca will pressure to play things out in the media along with influencing the player to apply pressure too. There's already bad blood there despite professionalism. If you're City you also don't want to alienate potential cantera kids from coming if they sense they will be punished when looking for an exit. No one will want it to drag on until winter when he can sign for free. It's delicate so I do think the messaging reflects that too.

But if it gets played out in the media, well it won't be pretty or good for anyone. A big reason why I still believe it will ultimately go smoothly considering those involved (Puyol, Eric, Pep & Txiki) - City will not want to look foolish and Barca will ultimately let them save some face. Perhaps then 10M will become 15M as a compromise (Along with bonuses) to get it done sooner

Almost as arrogant as the resident Bayern 'fan' not being funny mate but who the fuck do you think you are? "City won't want to look foolish" pay up then! "Barca will ultimately let them save some face" how nice of them...

Condescending prick.

 

[BigOscar]

If Garcia stays until next season and then leaves, would we not get a fee set by a tribunal. Similar to the dippers having to pay £6.5m for Danny Ings from Burnley in 2015. Or am I barking up the wrong tree.

PRetty sure that only works in England. Hence why you get some dubious transfers of English youth players on frees to never heard of foreign sides, who then sell them to other English sides on the cheap as a way around. Leicester bought George Hirst off Sheffield Wednesday that way iirc

 

[FromPollockToSilva]

Neat and tidy player with definite potential but put it this way, I would love to see him line up at centre back for Barça if we were playing against them

 

[Neville Kneville]

Unless someone comes out and refuses to play, I see no reason to push them away. Ake must have known he was leaving Bournemouth whether they stayed up or went down and you only have to glance at their fan forum to see how much commitment he showed, the desperate lunge he made which got himself injured says everything. There's no reason to think Garcia wouldn't do the same.

If people don't rate him or think he's not the best from a footballing perspective, I have no problems. It's the idiots questioning players commitment which frustrate me, when there's no justification at all.

Ake has pulled his guts out for Bournrmouth though. Garcia has done nothing.
Even if you are happy to give your best, you are doing it as an outsider & taking someones shirt.

Leroy was bottom of the pile before he went.

 

[ctid1894]

I do rate him, actually, though as a prospect and certainly not the player I’d trust in our most important game. I agree that it’s not a question of integrity but business, which was the closing point being made by the poster to whom you were responding.

Our business is winning football matches, if Garcia can help us do so, he plays.