Pep Guardiola - 2024/25

[bondsman]

Sigh

What you sighing for?

 

[decmancity]

For someone apparently so meticulous in planning and understanding of the game. I'd love to know why he keeps doing the same thing in the past several weeks.

 

[kaz7]

What you sighing for?

Am i the only one who knows how injuries work

 

[kaz7]

For someone apparently so meticulous in planning and understanding of the game. I'd love to know why he keeps doing the same thing in the past several weeks.

Because we have so many injuries he has no real choice

 

[maxwellblue]

Because we have so many injuries he has no real choice

It's a bigger mystery why a lot on here are failing to grasp that very simple fact.

 

[CΛL]

For someone apparently so meticulous in planning and understanding of the game. I'd love to know why he keeps doing the same thing in the past several weeks.

I think he’s stubborn, he doesn’t want to change our way of playing for the sake of a few injuries due to the message it would send out.

I think he’s banking on us turning it around with a few faces coming back into the fold from injury so that we can say, ‘we’re back’, rather than becoming more defensive to grind out results. It’s a matter of identity. Big clubs don’t sit back.

 

[Colin Bells Boots]

I think he’s stubborn, he doesn’t want to change our way of playing for the sake of a few injuries due to the message it would send out.

I think he’s banking on us turning it around with a few faces coming back into the fold from injury so that we can say, ‘we’re back’, rather than becoming more defensive to grind out results. It’s a matter of identity. Big clubs don’t sit back.

It's an opinion.

City not a big club ....................really ?

 

[clarion]

Does he cry too much about injuries?
I am asking because when he has all players he makes no subs in the game very often.

 

[CΛL]

It's an opinion.

City not a big club ....................really ?

What are you saying I genuinely don’t understand, did you read my post?

 

[Charlesfarsbar]

If we had a full squad to choose from and they were all fit, then questions could be legitimately asked

But we don’t so they can’t

 

[Colin Bells Boots]

What are you saying I genuinely don’t understand, did you read my post?

You are suggesting it in your " it's a matter of identity ......

What does that mean ?

 

[Colin Bells Boots]

You are suggesting it in your " it's a matter of identity ......

What does that mean ?

If you mean that Pep won't adopt a more defensive approach until the issues are resolved, I don't agree.

Pep is pragmatic and open to doing plenty of things before and during games, so are you saying the opposite ?

 

[decmancity]

Because we have so many injuries he has no real choice

Bollocks.

I'd rather play with 10 men then Walker.

 

[Colin Bells Boots]

If you mean that Pep won't adopt a more defensive approach until the issues are resolved, I don't agree.

Pep is pragmatic and open to doing plenty of things before and during games, so are you saying the opposite ?

His use of substitutes is a niggle however, especially the timing of them sometimes.

 

[kaz7]

Does he cry too much about injuries?
I am asking because when he has all players he makes no subs in the game very often.

No he doesnt cry too much about injuries , he has explained many times why he sometimes makes no subs

 

[Colin Bells Boots]

Bollocks.

I'd rather play with 10 men then Walker.

Sound management, start game with 10 .

 

[CΛL]

You are suggesting it in your " it's a matter of identity ......

What does that mean ?

I’m trying to say that Pep will not relent on his principles and change his style of play as he sees it as his and the clubs identity.

We want to dominate games and he’s going to try and do that until we have the squad to actually do it.

 

[Colin Bells Boots]

I’m trying to say that Pep will not relent on his principles and change his style of play as he sees it as his and the clubs identity.

We want to dominate games and he’s going to try and do that until we have the squad to actually do it.

I don't believe he will stubbornly persist with a plan or formation which is not working. He's changed formations and plans on a number of occasions.

Atm I do not understand his substitution approach /timing or why McAtee not getting a look in. And he is maybe protecting the young players for fear of damaging their confidence .

I believe the real issue is that we clearly do not know the full extent of player fitness/ ability to play with niggles etc. but they cannot be in a great state based upon the performances witnessed and line-ups used.

Player form/confidence isn't factored either as Gundogan looks way off, Gvardiol is making so many unexepected mistakes, Akanji clearly not fit, and Dias apart, the defence is as jumpy as kittens.

The two games per week in the current situation, is adding more pressure on both Pep and the players.

 

[CΛL]

I don't believe he will stubbornly persist with a plan or formation which is not working. He's changed formations and plans on a number of occasions.

Atm I do not understand his substitution approach /timing or why McAtee not getting a look in. And he is maybe protecting the young players for fear of damaging their confidence .

I believe the real issue is that we clearly do not know the full extent of player fitness/ ability to play with niggles etc. but they cannot be in a great state based upon the performances witnessed.

Player form/confidence isn't factored either as Gundogan looks way off, Gvardiol is making so many unexepected mistakes, Akanji clearly not fit, and Dias apart, the defence is as jumpy as kittens.

The two games per week in the current situation, is adding more pressure on both Pep and the players.

I’m not going to pick apart his team sheets because all he’s been able to do is field the only fit 11 players every game. MacAtee should have been given a game ahead of Gundo when he was playing more advanced alongside Kovacic but right now there’s no way I’d start him. He’d be our weakest winger and he isn’t getting in ahead of Kev, Grealish, Foden and Bernardo through the middle.

I agree on the fitness and niggles issue, it isn’t just the players that are out injured, it’s the ones that are fit one game, not the next. We have so many that can’t play twice in a week.

In terms of style of play, what do you expect us to do, sit back and absorb pressure? We haven’t got the players to do it. We haven’t got any tacklers in midfield. If we don’t keep the ball we only lose by more.

I don’t think we can blame very much on Pep to be honest.

 

[sir baconface]

If I visited some of our self-appointed physicians with a headache, I‘d come out with a kidney missing and three nipples.