Search results

As I seem to have started a GK slanging match I thought I would add Given is a very good keeper and not far behind Joe. why he is behind Joe is simple 1. He couldnt catch a cold never mind a cross (never could) 2. He is 10 years older then Joe and passed his best I think Joe is the best...

Im wondering whether you are ever so slightly retarded, Irish or both? Check the Hart thread on the main forum for the mistake that you have never seen Given make! Given is so good that he has never been snapped up by a top 4 club and as soon as we look like becoming a top 4 club Given is...

Sorry mate but you are talking shit! We have the best defensive record in the Prem and that is in large part due to Hart! I said it time and time again last season that Given never makes a glaring mistake because he plays it safe all the time ie never comes off his line to take a cross. Ive...

Yeah.....Hart is a million times better than Given. Yes Hart has the odd mistake in him but he is young and will get better. Hart for me is the best keeper in the Prem and therefore one of the best in Europe and the World. Given has never been anywhere near this good! Yeah .....You are afraid...

Hart will collect that ball 99/100 it happens and AJ will score that 9/10 and then it’s all different. Still in the cup Joe has got away with a horror mistake I think it’s a good day and I am backing NDJ to score the winner and his 1st goal in the final Is Shay Given not a better...

yeah - thats not the first time this has happened. I would have pushed that on to the post or wide myself - it was apoor attempt at a save - very pissed off. Would given have sved it? yes!

We were 2nd a couple of weeks ago. Blimey you don't want much do you mate ? if you're going to make an argument against Mancini this isn't the best way of going about it. Back to the weak players bit. These 4 are the standout weak players. Hopefully with time they will be moved on. I do not...

How can you say that Joe Hart is going to be City's goalkeeper for a very long time??? That's a ridiculous statement. You don't know what's around the corner. Man City with all our money should not be a club to sit and wait on developing talent. We need finished articles if we are to suceed...

Listen everyone. I am not Joe Hart's biggest fan but was overjoyed to see him get his chance this season. His undoubted talent is there for all to see and some of his performances this season have been inspiring. We need a solid keeper for our international team and the position is Joe's to...

Am I the only Man City fan who thinks Given is a far better goalkeeper than Hart? I can't recall a glaring mistake throughout his career - while I love Joe I think he should only play if he is the best keeper at the club. He unfortunetly isn't. Any opinions?

He did put in a world class performance. The opposing fans were clapping him. Defence was shocking.

I agree