31 | Ederson - 2024/25

Status
Not open for further replies.
super_city_si said:
Agree. His kicking wasnt good but he had no out ball and when it was passed back it was a shitty pass to his right foot with an attacker closing him down. Made a great save from the header and was commanding on aerial balls.

I do think he wants to leave but I also think he's far from the problem right now.

Why are Ortega and Ederson conceding the same goals? Same goalie errors or a shit midfield and backline that doesn't press and is slow as shit? Our goalies are facing one on ones every fucking week
Click to expand...
I think they are all part of the problem. No one is playing well. Even Dias who was given MOTM on Sunday wasn’t flawless.
 
samuelyeboah said:
I went to recount, i have to apologize. It's actually 1 in the last 35. Of the last 35 penalties he's faced, 34 penalties went in, 1 was saved

www.transfermarkt.us

Ederson - Penalty statistics

This is the penalty statistic of Ederson of Fenerbahce Istanbul. The page shows how many penalties a player has taken and how many of those were scored.
www.transfermarkt.us www.transfermarkt.us
Click to expand...
I have sympathy for keepers saving pens. They have to decide which way to move as the player is running to kick it. It’s very fortunate if you go the right way more often than not.

I would always rather be the keeper than the taker
 
Still our first choice for the rest of the season. Ortega hasn't convinced me he is, even with Ederson's patchy form. Next season is a different situation but that is not down to his ability.
 
kaz7 said:
He has fitted us perfectly for years , everyone has lost confidence but he has been making saves this season but the defence woes is stopping him from playing as usual

He is not the problem
Click to expand...
What his is usual apart from the end of the 2023 season he’s never really been a consistent good shot stopper he’s always average or below in save percentage even in situations where we was much stronger side and teams was only having 1 or 2 shots on target a game
 
He's been that good of a goalkeeper over the years that he's changed how goalkeepers play.

He's changed the role of what a goalkeeper can be. Not just a shot stopper.

They all want to be like him now. All trying to be good passers of the ball and cool under pressure.

And if you think that's easy, look how many fuck things up often.

Doesn't get anywhere near the credit he deserves. He's been bloody brilliant!
 
dhruvblue said:
Donut thief showed how GK with saving prowess can actually affect team positively.You still need saves to save you in critical moments and saves still is critical part of game. few here don’t want to accept that making saves is part of GK games always has been always will be.You can be elite passer but if you are average shot stopper it will hurt
Click to expand...

De Gea was so good....that the rags got rid of him for a keeper who they wanted to play like Ederson.
 
RayCTID said:
Still our first choice for the rest of the season. Ortega hasn't convinced me he is, even with Ederson's patchy form. Next season is a different situation but that is not down to his ability.
Click to expand...
If he is then we are dropping a clanger because sure as hell he is going in the summer and then we are fuck Ortega about so he will leave and then we are in a position where we have to buy 2 top keepers .
 
argyle said:
He's been that good of a goalkeeper over the years that he's changed how goalkeepers play.

He's changed the role of what a goalkeeper can be. Not just a shot stopper.

They all want to be like him now. All trying to be good passers of the ball and cool under pressure.

And if you think that's easy, look how many fuck things up often.

Doesn't get anywhere near the credit he deserves. He's been bloody brilliant!
Click to expand...
Eddie will not be sold through us wanting him out but he won’t stay either .
 
Looks like a player who has lost the fire and isn't really that bothered..... and he's in such an important role we can't afford him to be like this

Maybe the Saudi money turned his head, maybe it's because he's won it all, or maybe its because those infront are so out of form they are offering him no outlets

Either way, his passing has been wayward & predictable and when his passing is like that his shot stopping/decision making gets exposed

The club need to plan for his departure, whether its this summer or in a future summer because I can't see him staying TOO long
 
argyle said:
He's been that good of a goalkeeper over the years that he's changed how goalkeepers play.

He's changed the role of what a goalkeeper can be. Not just a shot stopper.

They all want to be like him now. All trying to be good passers of the ball and cool under pressure.

And if you think that's easy, look how many fuck things up often.

Doesn't get anywhere near the credit he deserves. He's been bloody brilliant!
Click to expand...

Yes. Eddie’s been revolutionary and very much part of what Pep’s about: innovative, attractive football. Average shot stopping plus world class distribution plus a touch of madness and a decent defence in front of him = entertaining footballer who’s pretty effective on balance.

Against that, his penalty saving record is dire. You just know they will score.

He was actually playing quite well earlier this season but has indeed looked a bit shit recently, like everyone else. We are no longer playing attractive football and are committing howlers all over the pitch. He isn’t covering himself with glory but neither is he the main cause of our woes.
 
sir baconface said:
Yes. Eddie’s been revolutionary and very much part of what Pep’s about: innovative, attractive football. Average shot stopping plus world class distribution plus a touch of madness and a decent defence in front of him = entertaining footballer who’s pretty effective on balance.

Against that, his penalty saving record is dire. You just know they will score.

He was actually playing quite well earlier this season but has indeed looked a bit shit recently, like everyone else. We are no longer playing attractive football and are committing howlers all over the pitch. He isn’t covering himself with glory but neither is he the main cause of our woes.
Click to expand...

How many penalty kicks is a goalkeeper expected to make ?
 
argyle said:
He's been that good of a goalkeeper over the years that he's changed how goalkeepers play.

He's changed the role of what a goalkeeper can be. Not just a shot stopper.

They all want to be like him now. All trying to be good passers of the ball and cool under pressure.

And if you think that's easy, look how many fuck things up often.

Doesn't get anywhere near the credit he deserves. He's been bloody brilliant!
Click to expand...
No, im pretty sure that Neuer was the one who started that change.Ederson maybe got his passing to a higher lvl than him , but overall he isnt close to Neuers abilitys as a goalkeeper.
 
ken tali said:
No, im pretty sure that Neuer was the one who started that change.Ederson maybe got his passing to a higher lvl than him , but overall he isnt close to Neuers abilitys as a goalkeeper.
Click to expand...
it was klinsmann. choosing lehmann over kahn because of his "football" ability.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top