I'm in the "Boateng should stay" camp.
I said on September 1st. that our transfer "team" had cocked up in signing Boateng as a full-back... he was never going to cut it in the Premiership in that position at our club.
But for all that he's a quality defender that we shouldn't just jettison on the basis of an less than impressive first season... when he has been injured for most of that time.
From the day we signed Lescott right up until about 2 months before the end of the season he was universally slaughtered on this site. According to many we should have got rid long before... we should have even given him a free to get him of the books!
Now he's top notch. As I always suspected he was.
Give players a chance. Don't judge on one season. You wouldn't expect a manager to be judged on one season, so why a player?
He's the perfect cover for Kompany, can slot in anywhere along the back four. He's our new Bobby Brightwell!
I said on September 1st. that our transfer "team" had cocked up in signing Boateng as a full-back... he was never going to cut it in the Premiership in that position at our club.
But for all that he's a quality defender that we shouldn't just jettison on the basis of an less than impressive first season... when he has been injured for most of that time.
From the day we signed Lescott right up until about 2 months before the end of the season he was universally slaughtered on this site. According to many we should have got rid long before... we should have even given him a free to get him of the books!
Now he's top notch. As I always suspected he was.
Give players a chance. Don't judge on one season. You wouldn't expect a manager to be judged on one season, so why a player?
He's the perfect cover for Kompany, can slot in anywhere along the back four. He's our new Bobby Brightwell!