manchester blue said:lasereyes said:I agree completely that the ref was awful last night:
- Clear penalty when Bentaleb virtually caught the ball (juggled it like an England slip fielder) => not given
- Zabaletta completely up-ended on the edge of the box - NO CALL
- Adebayor lunges his body in front of Demichelis and sticks his foot on his body => Demichelis gets booked
- Aguero clouted in the face by Dawson => NO CALL
- Capoue stamps violently on David Silva's foot => No card of any colour.
About the only correct decision was ruling out the offside goal. The penalty we got was borderline. The defender did catch Dzeko's left leg slightly before the ball - question is whether that impeded or up-ended Dzeko. I wouldn't have been upset if that wasn't given. But assuming the other calls above had been correct, my bet is the score would have ended up little different.
Does it really matter if he touched the ball? Had he knocked it out of play and brought the player down fair enough but the ball remained less than a metre away from Dzeko, as he got the faintest of touches, and had he not been brought down he still would have got to it. Correct decision but still a harsh red card. I expected a yellow and would have been happy with that.
Actually after seeing it again, I agree with you. It was still a goal-scoring opportunity for Dzeko. Actually, in hindsight, the ref prob did do us a favour cos can visualize Dzeko blasting that ball way over the bar, lol.