chinley blues
Well-Known Member
JasminBosnia said:
This list shows we should have sold Dzeko and kept Tevez
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Edin Dzeko (continued)
- Thread starter Madric
- Start date
- Status
- Not open for further replies.
This list shows we should have sold Dzeko and kept Tevez
blablabla7
Member
- Joined
- 1 Jan 2014
- Messages
- 15
As a Bosnian i have to write a few lines. I love Edin and he is a good player and he can play in a good Club(Arsenal, Inter, Dortmund, Atletico) but not in one of 10 best Clubs in the world and i think City is in that ten with the full squad. And this thread is annoying but i can't help it and i keep coming back. I think most of the criticism he gets is OK but some people are defending him with stupid statistics and "he is not playing enough or this and thaat" and now the critics are even worse and most of the time too much because of some Bosnians. Fans should be able to just comment normally about a player but in Edins case it is really really hard because now those defending him are really annoying and the others are just making fun of them.
All that said I think Edin is a great guy and a good player and I hope he will leave City with one more Premier League won. And one more thing about supporting Edin, from what I have heard by watching games on television the support for him is really great, the fans are always singing his song and I think the fans will remember him for the good things he has done for the club.
Hope you could understand everything because my English is not that good.
P.s Dont hate all the Bosnians because some of us are writing stupid posts :)
All that said I think Edin is a great guy and a good player and I hope he will leave City with one more Premier League won. And one more thing about supporting Edin, from what I have heard by watching games on television the support for him is really great, the fans are always singing his song and I think the fans will remember him for the good things he has done for the club.
Hope you could understand everything because my English is not that good.
P.s Dont hate all the Bosnians because some of us are writing stupid posts :)
@BluePhil8 said:This thread is still on going? Amazing.
It looks like nothing has changed from 4 months ago.
A City fan from Manchester/UK will talk about how poor Edin’s general play is, how his touch is bad, how selfish he is, how he misses too many sitters and can’t pass a ball.
Then after playing shit for 89 minutes, Dzeko will score a goal.
Cue the Dzeko fans from Bosnia who will come on and start talking about “important goals” and how these obscure statistics prove beyond any reasonable doubt that Dzeko is in fact better than Tevez, Aguero and Negredo. You also have to discard these statistics because they don’t show Dzeko in a favourable light and they were influenced because Navas/ Nasri/ Silva/ Aguero wouldn’t pass the ball to him. Also Mancini and Pellegrini have mismanaged him. Also you have to factor that in the build up to that important goal scored by someone else; Dzeko played a pivotal role by sneezing and distracting an opposition defender momentarily. You're all just haters anyway.
To be honest, it’s all a bit boring now. I’m all for freedom of speech but there comes a time when this thread is just detrimental to the forum and no headway will be made. Lock it, ban the Bosnians and we can all ride off in to the sunset.
4 month's, More like since Dzeko arrived to City.
Puppet Master Silva
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 30 Oct 2011
- Messages
- 2,787
CaliforniaBlue said:Message to those who rate Dzeko: Chill - it doesn't matter what someone on a forum thinks, right now Pellegrini thinks he's our number 1 healthy striker.
Message to those who don't rate Dzeko: Maybe you should be sending all your reasons why he's not good enough to Pellegrini, rather than posting on a forum. I'm sure if you all got together and let Pellegrini know the level of your football knowledge and your standing on Bluemoon, he's bound to have a rethink.
Of course, if either side just enjoys winding up the other, then carry on, because that's pretty much all that's being achieved here (as entertaining as that can be at times).
Don't quite think you're being impartial with the messages to both sides there. City fans are trolls and Bosnians shouldn't care what City fans think, is what I took from that post. If you're going to adress both sides and try to come across as neutral, you really have to do better than that, come on!
NorCalBlue
Well-Known Member
Puppet Master Silva said:CaliforniaBlue said:Message to those who rate Dzeko: Chill - it doesn't matter what someone on a forum thinks, right now Pellegrini thinks he's our number 1 healthy striker.
Message to those who don't rate Dzeko: Maybe you should be sending all your reasons why he's not good enough to Pellegrini, rather than posting on a forum. I'm sure if you all got together and let Pellegrini know the level of your football knowledge and your standing on Bluemoon, he's bound to have a rethink.
Of course, if either side just enjoys winding up the other, then carry on, because that's pretty much all that's being achieved here (as entertaining as that can be at times).
Don't quite think you're being impartial with the messages to both sides there. City fans are trolls and Bosnians shouldn't care what City fans think, is what I took from that post. If you're going to adress both sides and try to come across as neutral, you really have to do better than that, come on!
Who said I was trying to come across as neutral? I was just stating the situation as it currently is. In terms of 'winners' and 'losers', those who rate Dzeko are currently 'winning', as the manager seems to agree more with their view. For a while earlier on this season, and most of the last couple of seasons, those who don't rate him were 'winning' because the manager appeared to agree more with their views. Actually that's not quite true - if any manager agreed with the average view of those who don't rate Dzeko, he'd never get a game at all and would have been sold by now (perhaps they tried and it's a financial thing - I don't know).
And in terms of being impartial, you're language isn't exactly impartial is it?: "City fans" on one side and "Bosnians" on the other - not very original nor accurate, I'd hazard to guess.
Puppet Master Silva
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 30 Oct 2011
- Messages
- 2,787
CaliforniaBlue said:Puppet Master Silva said:CaliforniaBlue said:Message to those who rate Dzeko: Chill - it doesn't matter what someone on a forum thinks, right now Pellegrini thinks he's our number 1 healthy striker.
Message to those who don't rate Dzeko: Maybe you should be sending all your reasons why he's not good enough to Pellegrini, rather than posting on a forum. I'm sure if you all got together and let Pellegrini know the level of your football knowledge and your standing on Bluemoon, he's bound to have a rethink.
Of course, if either side just enjoys winding up the other, then carry on, because that's pretty much all that's being achieved here (as entertaining as that can be at times).
Don't quite think you're being impartial with the messages to both sides there. City fans are trolls and Bosnians shouldn't care what City fans think, is what I took from that post. If you're going to adress both sides and try to come across as neutral, you really have to do better than that, come on!
Who said I was trying to come across as neutral? I was just stating the situation as it currently is. In terms of 'winners' and 'losers', those who rate Dzeko are currently 'winning', as the manager seems to agree more with their view. For a while earlier on this season, and most of the last couple of seasons, those who don't rate him were 'winning' because the manager appeared to agree more with their views. Actually that's not quite true - if any manager agreed with the average view of those who don't rate Dzeko, he'd never get a game at all and would have been sold by now (perhaps they tried and it's a financial thing - I don't know).
And in terms of being impartial, you're language isn't exactly impartial is it?: "City fans" on one side and "Bosnians" on the other - not very original nor accurate, I'd hazard to guess.
What a strange, petty way to view the thread. Dzeko is playing bad so City fans are "winning".
Also I'm not impartial and didn't attempt to come across so with the initial condescending post.
mancity111
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 28 Dec 2013
- Messages
- 1,025
chinley blues said:JasminBosnia said:Donkey :D
Top Manchester City goal scorers
Below are Manchester City's top Premier League scorers and the totals they have scored.
Totals are updated after each game and occasionally amended in the light of decisions of the Dubious Goal Committee.
Player Goals First Latest
Carlos Tevez 58 28 Sep 2009 17 Apr 2013
Sergio Aguero 50 15 Aug 2011 29 Jan 2014
Edin Dzeko 38 25 Apr 2011 15 Mar 2014
Nicolas Anelka 37 31 Aug 2002 28 Dec 2004
Yaya Toure 34 19 Sep 2010 22 Feb 2014
Niall Quinn 29 29 Aug 1992 30 Mar 1996
Uwe Rosler 29 29 Mar 1994 05 May 1996
Shaun Wright-Phillips 27 29 Jan 2003 09 May 2010
Robbie Fowler 21 16 Mar 2003 14 Jan 2006
Mario Balotelli 20 07 Nov 2010 28 Nov 2012
David Silva 19 17 Oct 2010 15 Mar 2014
Mike Sheron 17 24 Oct 1992 04 Dec 1993
David White 17 17 Aug 1992 23 Oct 1993
Darius Vassell 17 23 Aug 2005 20 Apr 2008
Paul Walsh 16 29 Mar 1994 17 Apr 1995
Stephen Ireland 16 26 Dec 2006 21 Nov 2009
Paulo Wanchope 15 23 Aug 2000 15 May 2004
Joey Barton 15 18 Apr 2003 09 Apr 2007
Emmanuel Adebayor 15 15 Aug 2009 30 Oct 2010
Elano 14 29 Sep 2007 02 May 2009
Robinho 14 13 Sep 2008 02 May 2009
Shaun Goater 13 09 Dec 2000 09 Feb 2003
Garry Flitcroft 13 12 Dec 1992 04 Feb 1995
Craig Bellamy 13 28 Jan 2009 01 May 2010
Adam Johnson 11 14 Mar 2010 14 Apr 2012
Samir Nasri 11 01 Oct 2011 01 Dec 2013
Antoine Sibierski 10 17 Aug 2003 26 Dec 2005
Vincent Kompany 10 28 Sep 2008 29 Jan 2014
Marc-Vivien Foe 9 09 Dec 2002 21 Apr 2003
Andrew Cole 9 20 Aug 2005 01 Feb 2006
Martin Petrov 9 22 Sep 2007 26 Dec 2009
Alvaro Negredo 9 25 Aug 2013 12 Jan 2014
Steve Howey 8 05 Sep 2000 23 Dec 2002
Georgios Samaras 8 12 Feb 2006 01 Jan 2007
James Milner 8 24 Sep 2011 21 Dec 2013
Richard Dunne
7 02 Apr 2005 21 Sep 2008
Micah Richards
7 30 Sep 2006 19 Nov 2011
Joleon Lescott
7 25 Oct 2009 23 Sep 2012
Keith Curle
6 21 Nov 1992 14 May 1995
Pablo Zabaleta
6 17 Jan 2009 01 Jan 2013
Gareth Barry
6 20 Sep 2009 22 Dec 2012
David Sommeil
5 18 Apr 2003 04 May 2006
Sylvain Distin
5 18 Oct 2003 17 Mar 2007
Trevor Sinclair
5 14 Mar 2004 14 Jan 2006
Steve Lomas
5 08 Oct 1994 27 Apr 1996
Emile Mpenza
5 17 Mar 2007 29 Sep 2007
Daniel Sturridge
5 30 Jan 2008 19 Apr 2009
Felipe Caicedo
5 21 Dec 2008 24 May 2009
Aleksandar Kolarov
5 02 Feb 2011 01 Jan 2014
Paul Dickov
4 14 Oct 2000 09 Dec 2000
Claudio Reyna
4 18 Oct 2003 27 Aug 2005
Georgi Kinkladze
4 25 Nov 1995 16 Mar 1996
Fitzroy Simpson
4 03 Oct 1992 04 Mar 1995
Carl Griffiths
4 04 Dec 1993 05 Feb 1994
Michel Vonk
4 29 Aug 1992 01 Sep 1993
Rolando Bianchi
4 11 Aug 2007 22 Dec 2007
Benjani
4 10 Feb 2008 06 Dec 2008
Jesus Navas
4 24 Nov 2013 18 Jan 2014
Alfe-Inge Haaland
3 23 Aug 2000 16 Dec 2000
Sun Jihai
3 26 Oct 2002 17 Aug 2003
Ali Benarbia
3 23 Dec 2002 29 Jan 2003
Michael Tarnat
3 25 Aug 2003 24 Apr 2004
Gerry Creaney
3 16 Sep 1995 05 Mar 1996
Maurizio Gaudino
3 08 Mar 1995 14 Apr 1995
Peter Beagrie
3 02 Apr 1994 05 Nov 1994
Rick Holden
3 03 Oct 1992 21 Apr 1993
Kiki Musampa
3 09 Apr 2005 15 May 2005
Bernardo Corradi
3 18 Nov 2006 10 Feb 2007
DaMarcus Beasley
3 30 Dec 2006 17 Apr 2007
Geovanni
3 11 Aug 2007 01 Dec 2007
Gelson Fernandes
3 02 Jan 2008 21 Sep 2008
Nedum Onuoha
3 16 Mar 2008 11 Apr 2010
Roque Santa Cruz
3 19 Dec 2009 21 Mar 2010
Patrick Vieira
3 03 Apr 2010 03 Apr 2011
Fernandinho
3 14 Dec 2013 01 Jan 2014
Kevin Horlock
2 26 Aug 2000 09 Sep 2000
Gerard Wiekens
2 05 Sep 2000 17 Mar 2001
Danny Tiatto
2 23 Oct 2000 31 Jan 2001
Darren Huckerby
2 30 Dec 2000 24 Aug 2002
Jon Macken
2 14 Mar 2004 27 Nov 2004
Paul Bosvelt
2 20 Nov 2004 01 Jan 2005
Nigel Clough
2 03 Feb 1996 12 Mar 1996
Bradley Wright-Phillips
2 06 Dec 2004 17 Dec 2005
Nicky Summerbee
2 14 Apr 1995 04 Nov 1995
Kit Symons
2 03 Feb 1996 05 May 1996
David Rocastle
2 26 Feb 1994 05 Mar 1994
Michael Johnson
2 15 Aug 2007 16 Sep 2007
Javier Garrido
2 05 Oct 2008 28 Dec 2009
Kolo Toure
2 07 Nov 2009 15 Jan 2011
Javi Garcia
2 15 Sep 2012 15 Dec 2012
Jack Rodwell
2 19 May 2013 19 May 2013
Spencer Prior
1 11 Nov 2000 11 Nov 2000
Jeff Whitley
1 08 Apr 2001 08 Apr 2001
George Weah
1 09 Sep 2000 09 Sep 2000
Eyal Berkovic
1 30 Nov 2002 30 Nov 2002
Niclas Jensen
1 11 Jan 2003 11 Jan 2003
Willo Flood
1 01 Nov 2004 01 Nov 2004
Mikhail Kavelashvili
1 06 Apr 1996 06 Apr 1996
Alan Kernaghan
1 04 Feb 1995 04 Feb 1995
Terry Phelan
1 28 Dec 1993 28 Dec 1993
This list shows we should have sold Dzeko and kept Tevez
It doesn't show anything of the sort.
Wonky Vonky
Active Member
- Joined
- 7 Aug 2010
- Messages
- 44
Nothing to do with Edin but I'm guessing that the top premier league scorers list doesn't include own goals as Richard Dunn would be much higher up on the list. How many OGs did he score?
Tim of the Oak
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 29 Dec 2012
- Messages
- 18,666
chinley blues said:JasminBosnia said:Donkey :D
Top Manchester City goal scorers
Below are Manchester City's top Premier League scorers and the totals they have scored.
Totals are updated after each game and occasionally amended in the light of decisions of the Dubious Goal Committee.
Player Goals First Latest
Carlos Tevez 58 28 Sep 2009 17 Apr 2013
Sergio Aguero 50 15 Aug 2011 29 Jan 2014
Edin Dzeko 38 25 Apr 2011 15 Mar 2014
Mario Balotelli 20 07 Nov 2010 28 Nov 2012
Alvaro Negredo 9 25 Aug 2013 12
This list shows we should have sold Dzeko and kept Tevez
If anything, your list suggests we should have kept arrives instead of signing Jovetic
- Status
- Not open for further replies.