casualdeyna
Well-Known Member
So, I’ve done some ‘analysis’ and decided that a one tiered stand would be hard as **** to pull off.
Basicially if you have standing behind the goal then you have to have it in the corners as well or else the view of some fans in those corners will be partly obstructed by those in the standing section.
This becomes an even bigger issue when you consider that to produce a one tiered stand, the current stand would need to be completely rebuilt at a new angle which would fit within the confines of the original cable net and supports.
If the stand was rebuilt without the corners then some people sat there would also have an angle of the pitch cut off by the new steeper stand.
Due to building a new steeper stand these corners would therefore need to be rebuilt or remodelled, which is where the difficulty comes in as they are also part of the CB and East Stand, running under the third tiers which actually run past the pitch.
This can be seen in the photo below:
See the new Spurs one tier stand which covers the corners. You can see the edges of those corners are also at a higher level than the stands at the sides:
The seats on the sides right next to the small walls of where the steeper one tiered stand begins must be at least parallel to the touchline to avoid having views blocked off by the walls. Easy to do when you build a stadium from scratch, not so much when you’re reworking.
And here’s an example of how the one tiered stand cuts into the side stands:
This is what we would need to happen and why it would be so hard to pull off given the CB and East Stands arent configured with a one tiered stand in mind.
Closer look at the wall divide between the two stands which is there due to the single tier stand being much steeper:
Verdict:
A single tier North Stand would require much of the current North Stand to be demolished. The redevelopment would impact the northern ends of the CB and East Stands as the corners would also need to be completely remodelled. This would be extremely difficult to pull off, requiring full stand closure for a time if they did it over one season and would be very expensive and costly in terms of build and lost ticket revenue. The end result would obviously be a brilliant ‘home end’ stand though.
The easier solutions are to do a copy of the South Stand (the original plan), or expand the current second tier like in the pics below, perhaps having the lower tier (and corners!) as safe standing if there is a change in government legislation.
Cheers for this ManCityX, kinda confirms what I already thought that within the current confines of the stadium and cable net roof we are unlikely to get anything with the NS that isn't pretty much a SS copy, maybe with some safe standing in corners etc.
I do think eventually that the roof will go but it will be over time. I imagine we're looking to integrate the collar site and the stadium long term as they already do in USA, with shops, merchandise etc. being part of the stadium as a whole, Patriots place at Gillette Stadium being an example. It may be at that time we look at doing something different or unique with the stadium.
I'm fine with stadium as is, and with a SS copy, I'm just impatient to see a "finished" Etihad Campus but maybe there won't ever be a "finished" campus as it will continue to evolve over time, keeping up with social trends, technology etc.
