B
B
bluemc1
Guest
Ric said:
^ sorry mate but that is lame
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Javi Garcia
- Thread starter kunaguero10
- Start date
^ sorry mate but that is lame
bluemc1 said:Ric said:de niro said:bang on the money, crazy starting 11.
Garcia played well at Arsenal, and Nasri nearly cost us three points with his indiscipline at Norwich, so it wasn't a crazy starting XI for me. We won comfortably today.
^ sorry mate but that is lame
In what way?
Ric said:FantasyIreland said:Ric said:So no player deserves credit for their performance against Arsenal because of their red card?!
I suspect you've made up your mind about Garcia, and won't change it regardless.
Do you not think it would have been a slightly different proposal with Oxy Chamberlain running at us and him? Sidwell made him look second best today,make of that what you will.
I have made my mind up,he's not good enough.If he played in Red we'd be rolling on the floor!
That's hypothetical about Oxlade-Chamberlain, and doesn't really vindicate you. The fact you admit you've made your mind up is fairly narrow minded; players can adapt and improve, you know.
what was it 3 appearances in 5 years at madrid or barca.
not much improvement since then.
MCFC BOB
Well-Known Member
We've seen that Garcia plays well after a run of games, so taking him out of the team today would have been a silly decision - especially considering that he's going to be partnering Barry for the next few games.
Don't fix what ain't broke.
Don't fix what ain't broke.
mscenterh750
Well-Known Member
There will always be a boo boy. Edghill, Bradbury, Brannan, Dabo and many many more and now we have Garcia and Mario. Why they get this sort of treatment, I don't know but what I do know is that nobody is perfect and players have poor games and players take time to settle in to new systems, cultures and lifestyles (which can have an adverse effect on form), as can constant barracking from the stands. Christ almighty why can't players that play for MANCHESTER CITY be supported by the fans of MANCHESTER CITY, we are all in this together and these players wear our shirts, so they deserve our support regardless.
B
B
bluemc1
Guest
Ric said:bluemc1 said:Ric said:Garcia played well at Arsenal, and Nasri nearly cost us three points with his indiscipline at Norwich, so it wasn't a crazy starting XI for me. We won comfortably today.
^ sorry mate but that is lame
In what way?
well you are stating one split second flash of temper from Nasri as the reason he shouldnt start over Garcia who played well (for me did ok) v 10 man Arsenal, does that flash of anger rule out match winning performances v Spurs Chelsea ....... and mean we shouldnt play him at home when we always have more possession and it would benifit us to have the more creative players on the pitch
bluemc1 said:Ric said:bluemc1 said:^ sorry mate but that is lame
In what way?
well you are stating one split second flash of temper from Nasri as the reason he shouldnt start over Garcia who played well (for me did ok) v 10 man Arsenal, does that flash of anger rule out match winning performances v Spurs Chelsea ....... and mean we shouldnt play him at home when we always have more possession and it would benifit us to have the more creative players on the pitch
Not at all, but I don't think Nasri should walk back into the side when Garcia hasn't done anything wrong. He should pay the price for his indiscipline. If we were up against tougher opposition today then I could understand putting him straight back in, but it was Fulham at home so I can see where Mancini was coming from. It certainly wasn't a "crazy" decision. Garcia has done OK lately, and needs games to adapt. Nasri irresponsibly got sent off and has hardly been setting the world alight. Mancini got to make a point and it didn't affect the outcome of the game.
wolfie1988
Well-Known Member
Difference between Garcia and De Jong is Garcia doesn't make as many spectacular sliding tackles. Not really a bad thing.
Thing he does do is helps us to compete better against some teams. Newcastle, Stoke etc where everything is in the air. He also offers 100 times the goal scoring threat De Jong ever did.
Thought he was ok today nothing more nothing less. Did nothing wrong and certainly nothing worse than what De Jong would have done.
Think some of our fans are blinded by De Jongs slide tackling. Automatically assume that's what all good holding midfielders do. I mean look at Barry. Never ever makes a sliding tackle
Javi will be big for us. Just needs to settle a bit more, realise we need him for the basics and for threat at set pieces.
Thing he does do is helps us to compete better against some teams. Newcastle, Stoke etc where everything is in the air. He also offers 100 times the goal scoring threat De Jong ever did.
Thought he was ok today nothing more nothing less. Did nothing wrong and certainly nothing worse than what De Jong would have done.
Think some of our fans are blinded by De Jongs slide tackling. Automatically assume that's what all good holding midfielders do. I mean look at Barry. Never ever makes a sliding tackle
Javi will be big for us. Just needs to settle a bit more, realise we need him for the basics and for threat at set pieces.
wolfie1988 said:Difference between Garcia and De Jong is Garcia doesn't make as many spectacular sliding tackles. Not really a bad thing.
Thing he does do is helps us to compete better against some teams. Newcastle, Stoke etc where everything is in the air. He also offers 100 times the goal scoring threat De Jong ever did.
Thought he was ok today nothing more nothing less. Did nothing wrong and certainly nothing worse than what De Jong would have done.
Think some of our fans are blinded by De Jongs slide tackling. Automatically assume that's what all good holding midfielders do. I mean look at Barry. Never ever makes a sliding tackle
Javi will be big for us. Just needs to settle a bit more, realise we need him for the basics and for threat at set pieces.
does make a bit of sense what your saying.
hope your right.
We play a system.
Mancini picks players to play that system.
Whether its Real Madrid or Fulham, we play the system.
We adjust ONLY when we aren't winning and need a result.
So we will ALWAYS play 4-2-3-1 (or 4-5-1) from the start of matches.
Stop being so arrogant and retarded to think that because it's Fulham, we're good enough to just suddenly play a different way so we score a million goals. The team are drilled in the system, week in week out. It would be ludicrous of Mancini to then NOT use that system.
It's not Fifa for fuck's sake.
Mancini picks players to play that system.
Whether its Real Madrid or Fulham, we play the system.
We adjust ONLY when we aren't winning and need a result.
So we will ALWAYS play 4-2-3-1 (or 4-5-1) from the start of matches.
Stop being so arrogant and retarded to think that because it's Fulham, we're good enough to just suddenly play a different way so we score a million goals. The team are drilled in the system, week in week out. It would be ludicrous of Mancini to then NOT use that system.
It's not Fifa for fuck's sake.