joe hart

Status
Not open for further replies.
Good to see him acknowledge his faults by hanging his head and looking on in disbelief. That will be the kick up the arse he needed, the press are on his back. Time for him to show club and country he is still as good as we all know he can be!
 
ell said:
Could really do with giving him a few songs on saturday

Look, STOP, STOP STOP the ridiculous facade!

For the sake of our club, our fans, Joe himself and my bloody health, Joe must not be selected for that Everton game.

No amount of bloody singing is going to make him a better keeper otherwise we would hired both Adele and Aretha Franklin to sit in the seats behind his goal and serenade him fucking months ago!

His time is up, just accept it!
 
MaineRoadBlue said:
ell said:
Could really do with giving him a few songs on saturday

Look, STOP, STOP STOP the ridiculous facade!

For the sake of our club, our fans, Joe himself and my bloody health, Joe must not be selected for that Everton game.

No amount of bloody singing is going to make him a better keeper otherwise we would hired both Adele and Aretha Franklin to sit in the seats behind his goal and serenade him fucking months ago!

His time is up, just accept it!

I hardly think his time is up mate but I have to agree with you that its time to stop pussyfooting around the lad and drop him for a few games, as we would have done for any other player out of form
 
MaineRoadBlue said:
ell said:
Could really do with giving him a few songs on saturday

Look, STOP, STOP STOP the ridiculous facade!

For the sake of our club, our fans, Joe himself and my bloody health, Joe must not be selected for that Everton game.

No amount of bloody singing is going to make him a better keeper otherwise we would hired both Adele and Aretha Franklin to sit in the seats behind his goal and serenade him fucking months ago!

His time is up, just accept it!

Sorry mate hes been shit but he hasnt been that shit. Dropping him will wreck his confidence and not solve anything in my opinion.

I think its cool to say hes been worse than he has because its what the media like to do (he was jesus, mohammed and ghandi just over 12months ago)
 
You've got to be on a wind up mate :)

MaineRoadBlue said:
No amount of bloody singing is going to make him a better keeper........

I know what you mean, golden gloves for the last 3 seasons on the trot, he's clearly shit!

His time is up, just accept it!

9 games into the season of which we've lost 3 of which 1 was against the Champions of Europe, the other 2 we should have won but were missing key players.

I'm not saying he's having a great season, but some comments are here make me laugh.
 
Just brought myself round to watch the goals again.

Joe needs to get specsavers, sharpish. How the f*ck he managed to miss the first one completely then get next to nothing on the third is inexplicable.

For the second goal you'd expect him to be shafting Cliche who, after checking his run forward allowing the German to be onside, decided to run away from the ball! Joe took it like a lamb.

I've said it before, his mind is not on football, he's been turned by the excesses that come with being a well paid sportsman. Wine, women , gambling, shampoo, whatever.

That's my opinion.

It's got to be Pants on Saturday for everybody's sake.
 
ell said:
MaineRoadBlue said:
ell said:
Could really do with giving him a few songs on saturday

Look, STOP, STOP STOP the ridiculous facade!

For the sake of our club, our fans, Joe himself and my bloody health, Joe must not be selected for that Everton game.

No amount of bloody singing is going to make him a better keeper otherwise we would hired both Adele and Aretha Franklin to sit in the seats behind his goal and serenade him fucking months ago!

His time is up, just accept it!

Sorry mate hes been shit but he hasnt been that shit. Dropping him will wreck his confidence and not solve anything in my opinion.

I think its cool to say hes been worse than he has because its what the media like to do (he was jesus, mohammed and ghandi just over 12months ago)


His confidence is wrecked - it's like the ball is a dirty bomb!
A niggly injury needs to be invented that will keep him out for a few matches.

Singling him out for a moonlight serenade will just magnify the focus upon him.
 
That's it. The M.E.U.N have spoken.

According to their latest article it's been all downhill for Hart for the last 18 months!

<a class="postlink" href="http://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/timeline-ups-downs-joe-hart-6133274" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;">http://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/ ... rt-6133274</a>
 
Simply put, he's cost us more points than saved so far this season and a player in any other position would have been dropped by now. Pantilimon is a decent enough keeper, he might not make world class saves but right now Joe Hart isn't making the easy ones.
 
MC ID said:
Simply put, he's cost us more points than saved so far this season and a player in any other position would have been dropped by now. Pantilimon is a decent enough keeper, he might not make world class saves but right now Joe Hart isn't making the easy ones.

In the Premiership so far we've won 3 conceding a massive 1 goal along the way and we've drawn a game 0-0. We've lost 2, both 3-2. So are we saying that Hart is solely responsible for the 2 loses. Clearly the other 4 games he's helped us win or at least not lose?!?!

As to cup competitions. Panty playing obviously meant we won 5-0 against Wigan. Hart played the 2 Chumpions league games, he kept a clean sheet against Plzen but was one of 11 players and a manager who didn't perform against last years Champions of Europe.

Is it really that bad?
 
bennyboy said:
Sadly if Joe plays on Saturday there is something really wrong with our manager.No brainer of a decision.
Not really. many things to consider including his mental state, you cant just drop a keeper, would need to chat to him an explain that you feel he needs time out of the firing line. Easy to drop an outfield player and claim rotation. Hart was absolutely fine until that **** Roy Keane said something and Hart obviously listens to the media. He needs to see a sports psychiatrist I feel so that he doesn't fall in to Fernando Torres land
 
I'm a joe hart fan and believe he's capable of being one of the best in the world but something's not right with him ???

Goals 1 & 3 last night he should've and would've saved if he performed how he has in the past.

I don't think pantilimon is the answer either, we need another keeper capable of pushing joe .......... Someone who's been there and done it at the highest level but coming towards the later stages of their career .......
 
MaineRoadBlue said:
smeeagain said:
that shot of ribery,s was really fierce tho ! and right on target in the corner
if it was saved it would of been described as top class

Deary me! I suspect you are winding us up; If not I fear for your mental health!

In short Hart incompetence was the root cause of ALL 3 goals!

For the 2nd goal and when under no pressure, he booted the ball away into the midfield and never City never touched it again until we picked it out of our net after an equally pathetic effort to deal with Muller one on one.

The importance of Hart's position cannot be over emphasised in quelling opposition pressure by selective and controlled distribution. In short the opposition find it damn hard to score if they don't have the ball. Last night we were losing the ball cheaply and not seeing it again for 2-3 minutes. A good proportion of those turnovers back to Bayern were down to his complete lack of composure and his stupidity in just booting the ball away in blind panic.

Put bluntly, his core level of ability (and I am not talking about whether he is in form or not) is way below what we need as a goalkeeper at this level of football. He simply cannot control, compose and then distribute by either his hands nor feet to anything like what is required. This coupled with his flawed ability to save shots or come for crosses is simply not tenable.

Furthermore, anyone who continues to defend his selection is doing so out of blind loyalty rather than what is best for our club. He must be dropped and considering his fundamental flaws, I for one would not be remotely concerned if he never wore a City shirt again.

i'll defend the lad from over blown drivel like this post.

You say that it was his fault because no other outfield player touiched the ball after a Hart clearance then blame him for that. What where the other 10 players doing whilst Bayern had the ball?
What was the full-back doing letting his marker run unchallenged into the box and where were the centre halfs?

I for one would be cock-a-hoop if you never pretended to be a City supporter again.
 
stonerblue said:
MaineRoadBlue said:
smeeagain said:
that shot of ribery,s was really fierce tho ! and right on target in the corner
if it was saved it would of been described as top class

Deary me! I suspect you are winding us up; If not I fear for your mental health!

In short Hart incompetence was the root cause of ALL 3 goals!

For the 2nd goal and when under no pressure, he booted the ball away into the midfield and never City never touched it again until we picked it out of our net after an equally pathetic effort to deal with Muller one on one.

The importance of Hart's position cannot be over emphasised in quelling opposition pressure by selective and controlled distribution. In short the opposition find it damn hard to score if they don't have the ball. Last night we were losing the ball cheaply and not seeing it again for 2-3 minutes. A good proportion of those turnovers back to Bayern were down to his complete lack of composure and his stupidity in just booting the ball away in blind panic.

Put bluntly, his core level of ability (and I am not talking about whether he is in form or not) is way below what we need as a goalkeeper at this level of football. He simply cannot control, compose and then distribute by either his hands nor feet to anything like what is required. This coupled with his flawed ability to save shots or come for crosses is simply not tenable.

Furthermore, anyone who continues to defend his selection is doing so out of blind loyalty rather than what is best for our club. He must be dropped and considering his fundamental flaws, I for one would not be remotely concerned if he never wore a City shirt again.

i'll defend the lad from over blown drivel like this post.

You say that it was his fault because no other outfield player touiched the ball after a Hart clearance then blame him for that. What where the other 10 players doing whilst Bayern had the ball?
What was the full-back doing letting his marker run unchallenged into the box and where were the centre halfs?

I for one would be cock-a-hoop if you never pretended to be a City supporter again.

I concur with the final statement

post-9764-Grumpy-Cat-clapping-gif-P16l.gif
 
I thought this after the villa game . I actually wish he'd come out and taken wieman down . He would have taken one for the team, we may have got a point or even pushed on to win but it would have been a good chance for him to take a few games out and let pantillimon have a go . I'd rather that then the pointless run out he done .

I like hart, be he hasn't been right for a while. He's been poor compared to what we have seen from him in the past .
 
stonerblue said:
MaineRoadBlue said:
smeeagain said:
that shot of ribery,s was really fierce tho ! and right on target in the corner
if it was saved it would of been described as top class

Deary me! I suspect you are winding us up; If not I fear for your mental health!

In short Hart incompetence was the root cause of ALL 3 goals!

For the 2nd goal and when under no pressure, he booted the ball away into the midfield and never City never touched it again until we picked it out of our net after an equally pathetic effort to deal with Muller one on one.

The importance of Hart's position cannot be over emphasised in quelling opposition pressure by selective and controlled distribution. In short the opposition find it damn hard to score if they don't have the ball. Last night we were losing the ball cheaply and not seeing it again for 2-3 minutes. A good proportion of those turnovers back to Bayern were down to his complete lack of composure and his stupidity in just booting the ball away in blind panic.

Put bluntly, his core level of ability (and I am not talking about whether he is in form or not) is way below what we need as a goalkeeper at this level of football. He simply cannot control, compose and then distribute by either his hands nor feet to anything like what is required. This coupled with his flawed ability to save shots or come for crosses is simply not tenable.

Furthermore, anyone who continues to defend his selection is doing so out of blind loyalty rather than what is best for our club. He must be dropped and considering his fundamental flaws, I for one would not be remotely concerned if he never wore a City shirt again.

i'll defend the lad from over blown drivel like this post.

You say that it was his fault because no other outfield player touiched the ball after a Hart clearance then blame him for that. What where the other 10 players doing whilst Bayern had the ball?
What was the full-back doing letting his marker run unchallenged into the box and where were the centre halfs?

I for one would be cock-a-hoop if you never pretended to be a City supporter again.
I'm also sure Fernandinho was the 'root' cause of one of their goals, trying to take on too many players and losing posession. He should have done better, but they were not howlers of epic proportions. We did not do enough to win the game outfield.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top