You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
KDB or David Silva?
- Thread starter DMA's
- Start date
Johnny Mars Bar
Well-Known Member
Different players so vary tough to answer.
For me though Dave is still the most graceful player I’ve ever seen kick a football apart from Messi.
For me though Dave is still the most graceful player I’ve ever seen kick a football apart from Messi.
Millennium
Well-Known Member
If the young Silva plays in the current City team, he will be better than the old Silva not necessarily better than KDB. Silva came when City was in development and progressing to be a champion. He and the other players achieved the first title in this era. I am not saying Silva is better, but with different times, coaches, and players, all these factors must be considered.
Ali B's Heel
Well-Known Member
Here’s one, which ‘spine’ do you go for:
Hart
Kompany
Yaya
Silva
Aguero
Ederson
Dias
Rodri
KDB
Haaland
That's an even better debate as both Silva and KDB are legends in their own way.
I believe the 2nd is more 'Pep' so emotions aside, that's got to be my answer. They'd control the game better.
Ederson is perfect for how we play as is Rodri, coin toss between Silva and KDB, and Haaland has broken the PL goals record in year 1.
Saddleworth2
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 27 Jan 2014
- Messages
- 21,703
When you look at our midfield over the last 10 years, it shows what class recruitment we have:
David/KDB/Bernie/Gundo/Rodri/Fern/Yaya/Samir/GazBaz/Milner/Nigel
I dont think another team in the world would be able to produce a list like that. Ok. Maybe Barca/Real.
David/KDB/Bernie/Gundo/Rodri/Fern/Yaya/Samir/GazBaz/Milner/Nigel
I dont think another team in the world would be able to produce a list like that. Ok. Maybe Barca/Real.
Not bad 5 aside teams are they.That's an even better debate as both Silva and KDB are legends in their own way.
I believe the 2nd is more 'Pep' so emotions aside, that's got to be my answer. They'd control the game better.
Ederson is perfect for how we play as is Rodri, coin toss between Silva and KDB, and Haaland has broken the PL goals record in year 1.
Think you’re probably right though.
aguero93:20
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 21 Oct 2013
- Messages
- 90,256
- Location
- Hunting Cats.
- Team supported
- Some gobshites in day-glo green and black.
Replace Yaya with Dinho and that would be some 5 a side match up, couldn't have Yaya though, doesn't track back.Not bad 5 aside teams are they.
Think you’re probably right though.
Kippax Street 1880
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 22 Mar 2010
- Messages
- 5,100
Here’s one, which ‘spine’ do you go for:
Hart
Kompany
Yaya
Silva
Aguero
Ederson
Dias
Rodri
KDB
Haaland
Has to be the second one. I never liked Joe Hart and fucking him right off was the absolute best decision Pep ever made. (We won't mention Bravo season).
Fernandinho should replace Yaya in the first one aswell. I remember him never breaking into a jog over 180 minutes of a CL semi-final, throwing his toys out of the pram over no birthday cake and calling our clubs greatest ever Manager a racist, just as much as I remember the good parts. Great player when he could be arsed, not a legend for me, and he was after the first Pellegrini season.