Milner [Merged]

[Ticket For Schalke]

What would you rather have?
A team of flair players like Robhino, Elano that wins fcuk all
or
a team of grafters like Tevez, Bellamy that wins Premiership and Chumps league.

Combination of the two - why should we settle for anything less? Many consider Messi to be among the world's best players but he also works hard and his attitude is beyond reproach. The talk of Robinho going to Barcelona makes me laugh - would you take him if you were Guardiola?

the best have a combination of both, and thats why they are. with just one of these characteristics they will never achieve super star status.

 

[Kinky by name]

What would you rather have?
A team of flair players like Robhino, Elano that wins fcuk all
or
a team of grafters like Tevez, Bellamy that wins Premiership and Chumps league.

We won loads with those grafters this season.

I guarantee if we had had Robinho and Elano this season we would have finished in the top 4.

What do you mean if we had Robinho?

 

[pierod]

I guarantee if we had had Robinho and Elano this season we would have finished in the top 4.

Not sure how you can guarantee an alternate reality, perhaps because you live in one.

 

[robbie brewer]

What would you rather have?
A team of flair players like Robhino, Elano that wins fcuk all
or
a team of grafters like Tevez, Bellamy that wins Premiership and Chumps league.

Combination of the two - why should we settle for anything less? Many consider Messi to be among the world's best players but he also works hard and his attitude is beyond reproach. The talk of Robinho going to Barcelona makes me laugh - would you take him if you were Guardiola?

I agrre but at the moment we are not good enough to carry a lazy cnut like Robhino. It's all very well him being brilliant 1 game then going missing for the next 3. The balance of the current team is not good enough to compensate so we have to make do with grafters like Bellamy.

 

[johnmc]

I think alot of you are really underating milner. He, for me is a Gerrard type of player, tough in the tackle, quick burst of pace, great passing range, great shot and a fookin massive engine, who do we have like that in the squad? I'd pay 30 at the very least.

That great shot of his got 4 goals from open play. He has not got a quick burst of pace either. To compare him to Gerrard is laughable. He is average.<br /><br />-- Fri Jun 11, 2010 2:04 pm --<br /><br />When has a team of grafters ever won anything. Combination of work and guile in every premier league win team thus far.

 

[Fat Chance]

Milners probably better than Fletcher and Fletcher and Carrick whilst not touted to be flair players...were the difference in the CC semi.

 

[johnmc]

Milners probably better than Fletcher and Fletcher and Carrick whilst not touted to be flair players...were the difference in the CC semi.

So £28m gets you a player at Carrick or Fletchers level????

 

[Skip Donoghue]

What would you rather have?
A team of flair players like Robhino, Elano that wins fcuk all
or
a team of grafters like Tevez, Bellamy that wins Premiership and Chumps league.

We won loads with those grafters this season.

I guarantee if we had had Robinho and Elano this season we would have finished in the top 4.

haha if we had robinho why what would he have done sitting on the bench if he was lucky

robinho would and never will be a great player in the EPL period he had a decent 1st season but once he was found out game over
he does not have any other attributes to allow him to change the way he plays he is a one dimensional player simple as that and once teams are able to work him out he becomes ineffective

 

[Fat Chance]

Milners probably better than Fletcher and Fletcher and Carrick whilst not touted to be flair players...were the difference in the CC semi.

So £28m gets you a player at Carrick or Fletchers level????

Well if Carrick cost 18mil 4 year ago and Milners better and Carrick was undoubtably one of the reasons we were beaten in the CC semi (evidenced by him slotting the ball in the back of the net) then errr....how much is Milner worth again....

players values regardless of what you might hear on here....are not determinable by how many keepy-ups they can do.

 

[franksven]

What would you rather have?
A team of flair players like Robhino, Elano that wins fcuk all
or
a team of grafters like Tevez, Bellamy that wins Premiership and Chumps league.

We won loads with those grafters this season.

I guarantee if we had had Robinho and Elano this season we would have finished in the top 4.

With them in the team we never finished higher than tenth, so you can not guarantee anything really.