Newcastle (A) | Wed 27th Sept | EFL Cup | Post Match Thread

[TheBlueCat]

Didn’t see enough from Phillips! He made 112 passes and had a very respectable 91% pass completion.

He couldn’t control his bowel movements. Strolling around making no impact in the game at all. What a one paced pony. If you think he’s ok then fine. He was overrun by a shite Newcastle 2nd string. Unfortunately he’s a dud and we need to work around him

 

[lazerblue]

Thought Phillips had a good game. Bobb and Lewis went awol in midfield when Newcastle doubled up on Phillips.

wtf!!

 

[levets]

Credit where it's due, that 10 min spell after halftime was brilliant from Newcastle, they drowned us.The ref was overawed by the home crowd once they scored though. Joelinton made Fernandinho look like a choirboy in comparison tonight, and got off scot free again.

It's poor decision making from Lewis for the goal, a very inexperienced decision. I think the lad's future will be in midfield long-term. I felt Gvardiol got caught on the turn a bit tonight, still adapting to the fastest league in the world but he's got so much potential.

Grealish and Phillips need to get some weight off. They move like men down the pub. Shouldn't be drinking.

Doku game changer once again, must be given a chance as a starter in big games. Alvarez plays better when Haaland is also on the pitch.

Never went tonight as something came up at home, unfortunately. Glad I'm not walking back to the car now past all them squealing Geordies. If we were to drop out of one tournament it would be this one, plenty of positives to take and more minutes in the legs. God knows how we are gonna cope without Rodri at Arsenal, it's over to the genius of Pep.

Fair assessment. Rico still has a lot to learn and miles off holding down a place. Alvarez works like a Trojan, but needs to improve his first touch and his close control. It costs us at times when it’s turned over and we’re on the attack. Akanji isn’t a dominant centre back, needs Dias or Stones with him.
This was a predominantly 2nd string. On to Wolves!

 

[Len Rum]

The reality is it’s probably for the best. Those two semi‘s in January are always a killer. Newcastle are a horrible bunch of dirty bastards with a snidey shithouse of a manager and that’s why I wanted us to smash them, but that’s my emotions getting in the way.

Safe journey back all you blue boys.

This.
The two semis can be brutal.
It's not worth it, particularly with the World Club championship this year.

 

[Revolver]

Hate City losing any game and this trophy brings a lot of happy memories.

But this defeat doesn’t hurt. We have a lot of
Injuries and our main midfielder suspended. We are unbeaten in the league, won the Super Cup and have the world club championship which must be a priority to come. Our players are not machines.

No lack of effort tonight from a team that has never played together before , some of whom were not match fit

Don’t like their boring tactics and I think they will win nothing with their current manager but good luck Newcastle in the next round.

 

[wattle]

Proof that 64% of statistics are just made up.

I think you are 110% right

 

[normskih]

You’d think Newcastle were a league one side the way the sky commentators were talking. Ridiculously bias commentatory!

We weren’t at it, but no shame in losing to them

I think they’re Conference by their ‘lap of honour celebration’, they‘re bringing their families out next;)

 

[bobbyowenquiff]

I got up at 3am to watch that.
Hard for the fringe players to get a game now where out.

Not too late to pour a cold one.

 

[stablemcfc]

Always want to win of course, but from a season preservation point of view if we are going to be out of a competition, this one at this stage is probably ideal.

Good to get minutes into the legs of some squad players.

 

[its a Barm]

I think we'll be better when Stones, Rodri, KDB, Haaland, Bernardo, Walker, Dias & Ederson return

Really never thought of that.

 

[Tolmie scores]

Not sure what Gomez did wrong ? Thought he was fine first half, then he was put at LB again (didn't do a lot wrong there either for me), but he really isn't a LB.

Played better tonight, but always looks uncomfortable...kovacic was poor i thought no drive.. Arsenal without Rodri!!! Fu ck

 

[lazerblue]

I assume you haven’t seen Phillips in the flesh then? Far from overweight and if he was he wouldn’t be in the squad.

so he's just shit then?

 

[melrose40yarder]

I dont like to slag off our players,Phillips is not good enough for us.He joins Bony and Mangala in the waste of money stakes.
Pep was not bothered otherwise he would have bought the viking on.

 

[chaddblue]

The commentary, especially the co commentary, was appalling

It was like they were commentating on a championship team playing city’s full strength team

 

[TheBlueCat]

After 50 years you’d want it more as well. Not sure how many more Inter-City Fairs Cup DVDs they can shift.

I have no idea what this means. Thanks though

 

[RG_mcfc]

I dont like to slag off our players,Phillips is not good enough for us.He joins Bony and Mangala in the waste of money stakes.
Pep was not bothered otherwise he would have bought the viking on.

probbaly because of the club world cup

 

[LangleyBlue1970]

Fair fucks from Howe. Praised us. Said result was right. Can’t argue. He wants this and this could be the cup like we won in 2011.

I’ve never seen a person talk like he does though, where the teeth don’t separate. It’s like his top and bottom teeth are joined, and he just moves his lips. Weird.

 

[ali benarbia's studs]

one look at the line ups and you could see 1 goal would win the match. like last year we have bigger and better comps to focus on, even more!

 

[OB1]

Impossible to win the quadruple , and we have gone out of the least important one , would have taken a slender defeat before the game and we got it , we move on to bigger challenges.We need to get our squad full fit over the next few weeks and stay at the top of the league and qualiify in the Champs league and that has to be our target for the New Year and we can kick-on and engage overdrive and mop up more trophies next year.

Tonight demonstrated just why the Quad is unrealistic. Forget all the bluster from commentators, Newcastle had a good attacking moment and scored but in no small part thanks to a mistake by a young player.

I’d rather lose in this competition at this stage than later on. Hate losing of course especially to what has become a shithouse team.

 

[Blue Mist]

I remember where I was when I heard that Elvis had died.
I also remember the night when Princess 'The Queen of Hearts' died and now I will be able to tell my grand child that I can remember exactly what I was doing the night of that famous Newcastle victory of Manchester City.