Pep Guardiola - 2022/23

Status
Not open for further replies.
He is coming under a lot of “friendly fire” atm. The rumblings on a few threads would rather have him replaced. Don’t know the posters and couldn’t be bothered reading their shite
It seems that he is having a bit of a struggle at the moment, I don't know what it is but it reminds me of that period in covid when he said that he didn't like his team. He will sort it out, whatever it is. Anybody that wants him gone is a bit silly in my humble opinion. All a bit knee jerk.
 
I love Pep.

Don't always agree with him, think he sometimes makes mistakes, fully accept that sometimes his tactics deserve criticism...

But I'll never call for him to leave. The positives far outweigh the negatives.

He'll leave when he's ready, and no-one will ever come close to what he's done for us.
 
ya right pep is the only one who can understand football.
To be fair, Pep is likely to be remembered as one of the top ten football managers of all time, and if you took a poll of other managers today, it's likely he'd be voted the best in the world. Your post suggested he always gets his tactics wrong.

I think that might be a slight exaggeration :)
 
ya right pep is the only one who can understand football.
He can understand it far better than any of us and if you can't understand that simple fact then your opinions will be skewed. I don't always agree with him but I do understand the chances are exteremely high over 99% he's right and I'm wrong, and he'd be an idiot if he listened to my opinion. Simple fact is he's the best around and if any of us knew better we wouldn't be sat wasting our time on a football forum.
 
That first half formation/personnel didn't work at all. He changed the personnel at half time and it improved our pressing and got players more into roles they can play. But it was still a formation that didn't work too well.

It's easy for us all to scream at him to go back to the formation we've used for the last couple of years but there hasn't been one, there's been one that varies a lot. Whilst it's nearly always 433, sometimes, the full backs push wide more, sometimes the wingers hug the touchlines, sometimes one attacking midfielder drops alonside the holding midfielder. I would draw them if I could be bothered but there are multiple formations that we have used over the alst few years, not jsut one.

I think what we need to accept with Pep is that he's built a career on trying to be one step ahead of the opposition. He's trying to get something in place where we control games and ping it about like that last two seasons but we have the cutting edge of Haaland in the box. I don't think he's found that yet, and last night was a fucking mess to be honest, but I'm behind him all the way and trust him to get it right.
 
The quote from Pep tells me of a bit of irritation at the whining from fans for the "good old days" of Sane blowing down the wing. Pretty clear Pep thinks people are remembering that through rose-tinted glasses. If he wanted that approach again, he'd be instructing the team to play that way. Grealish and Foden both have plenty of pace if instructed to play differently, but they're clearly both being instructed to focus on ball retention and control. Unfortunately lack of an overlapping LB (which the club failed to buy last summer) therefore makes their job very difficult.
or he is simply facing the reality of not having the pace of sane and sterling available to him.
 
He can understand it far better than any of us and if you can't understand that simple fact then your opinions will be skewed. I don't always agree with him but I do understand the chances are exteremely high over 99% he's right and I'm wrong, and he'd be an idiot if he listened to my opinion. Simple fact is he's the best around and if any of us knew better we wouldn't be sat wasting our time on a football forum.
nah not true disagree. many coaches in grassroot or even some pundits can understand tactics as good as or even better than top most coaches. the difference is managing or coaching a team is not only about tactics. in that sense pep is the best manager/coach in the business. but to say he understands tactics better than anyone at all times is not true. many people on the outside of football can analyze the game better than pep I bet.
 
to say he understands tactics better than anyone at all times is not true. many people on the outside of football can analyze the game better than pep I bet.

You're not sincerely trying to suggest you have a better mind for the tactical side of the game than Pep Guardiola, are you?

Because that would be beyond delusion.
 
What he asked of Rodri last night is up there with his decisions in the CL final for me.

Rodri is a class footballer, but thanks to the poor recruiting of his cover, he’s invaluable and Pep then decides to stretch him to his limits and ask more of him. The first half was such a bizarre tactical approach. Could and should have cost us last night.

Everything about that first half was wrong. Hopefully we never see it again.
 
nah not true disagree. many coaches in grassroot or even some pundits can understand tactics as good as or even better than top most coaches. the difference is managing or coaching a team is not only about tactics. in that sense pep is the best manager/coach in the business. but to say he understands tactics better than anyone at all times is not true. many people on the outside of football can analyze the game better than pep I bet.
hmmmmm.....

he has revolutionised tactics as much as any coach before him.
 
Grealish has plenty of pace, he's just not allowed to use it with the way Pep wants him to play. Pep has moved to wanting his wingers to focus on control above all else.
Grealish has no pace mate. . No one in this team does (except haaland and Alvarez maybe) that's why "good old memories"..
 
What he asked of Rodri last night is up there with his decisions in the CL final for me.

Rodri is a class footballer, but thanks to the poor recruiting of his cover, he’s invaluable and Pep then decides to stretch him to his limits and ask more of him. The first half was such a bizarre tactical approach. Could and should have cost us last night.

Everything about that first half was wrong. Hopefully we never see it again.
The fact it didn't cost us. Shows how poor Chelsea are
 
nah not true disagree. many coaches in grassroot or even some pundits can understand tactics as good as or even better than top most coaches. the difference is managing or coaching a team is not only about tactics. in that sense pep is the best manager/coach in the business. but to say he understands tactics better than anyone at all times is not true. many people on the outside of football can analyze the game better than pep I bet.
No, otherwise they wouldn't be outside the game
 
oh boy, people saying pep isnt all that when it comes to understanding tactics...now ive heard everything.

You can fairly say that his gameplans and abrupt formation changes sometimes dont work but i bet if you hear his thought process and what he set his team out to do you'd probably say "what a genius this guy is" nine times out of ten. Its just that sometimes practice doesnt translate to the matches but if you think you can trot your cute 4-3-3 unchanged for 2 or 3 years and dont get figured out you are wrong. Nevermind 7 years
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top