Post Match Thread - City vs Palace

Nope unlike some here I can actually discuss a game without blinkers. I said clearly you should have had a pen. Cabaye took Nasri's legs. I never said we had more possession or more of the game. I said the opposite. I said CITY had more possession and more of the game. I said until the goal we had the better chances. How can I claim that we had more possession when this is a FACT that we didn't. It seems you have a problem reading.

Too many people here want to put on blue tinged glasses when they are talking about football.

Time will tell how right I am, but I will say this.

I have been correct more times than I have been wrong about football and players and my post history shows this.

Pray tell me how this will happen. We won 1 - 0 and that's the end of it. You think you deserved a draw and that's your opinion.
But how you can say previous posts prove you are often right, well that's bollox. Previous posts just prove that you have an opinion
and there is nothing to back up whether you are right or wrong. You obviously think a lot of your opinion and that somehow it
counts more than anyone else's. Well not for me. It's just an OPINION.
 
I watched the game and felt anxious for alot of it. I think even now, and this is just my opinion. When we are playing and the opposition has 11 men behind the ball, we still don't look like we have a plan b. I know I'm gonna get slated for this opinion but I think when we play teams who want to play football our plan a is great, when we play teams who want to play ultra defensive plan a doesn't work and plan b is non existent.

What I'd like to see in these type of games is gave spells where kompany plays as a lone defender and the rest (excluding Hart obviously) push forward make runs and ultimately over run them in areas.

I think the plan B is Sterling and now De bruyne.

I was at the game and didn't feel anxious at all except for the first 5 mins when they got off to a flyer. After that, I could not see us losing and whilst from 75 mins on I couldn't see us winning either, I am seeing a much more focused and determined side this season. They seem like they really want to make an impression this year and so far so good.
 
I think the plan B is Sterling and now De bruyne.

I was at the game and didn't feel anxious at all except for the first 5 mins when they got off to a flyer. After that, I could not see us losing and whilst from 75 mins on I couldn't see us winning either, I am seeing a much more focused and determined side this season. They seem like they really want to make an impression this year and so far so good.

I was watching it on a choppy stream and my 3 and 4 year old were being little sods, so maybe that was the anxiousness lol.

Yeah I thought it was going to be a draw, glad nacho man did the buisness, hopefully he will get some extended chances this season and be the first of the modernised academy to break through.
 
Glad the motm hoodoo has been broken ......whomever mentioned it on a thread on here is a ****....it was running through my mind last 30 mins of the game
 
I don't think he was flagged offside, perhaps just flagging for a goal kick has people confused.

Looking at replays I also don't think he was offside.
My mistake then. Perhaps I was thinking of another passage of play.
 
TV didn't show the linesman so I can't comment on that, although Joe took the kick out from inside the 6 yard box whereas if he was flagged offside it would have been just inside the 18 yard box.

I believe it was Ray Houghton on my stream who commented that the flag didn't go up. Sagna's visible frustration and gestures would indicate it didn't get flagged as well.

He touched the ball on the edge of the six yard box so surely that would have been when and where he would have been penalised for offside?

Houghton did say that but my reaction on hearing him was you've got that wrong because at the game I made a point of looking at the assistant ref.
 
I watched the game and felt anxious for alot of it. I think even now, and this is just my opinion. When we are playing and the opposition has 11 men behind the ball, we still don't look like we have a plan b. I know I'm gonna get slated for this opinion but I think when we play teams who want to play football our plan a is great, when we play teams who want to play ultra defensive plan a doesn't work and plan b is non existent.

What I'd like to see in these type of games is gave spells where kompany plays as a lone defender and the rest (excluding Hart obviously) push forward make runs and ultimately over run them in areas.
I'm guessing you missed the Watford game then! Mainly because it makes your criticism seem errrm completely wrong I'd say!
You want us to play 1 7 2 do you? Okaaaaaay then. Is that you Louis?
 
He touched the ball on the edge of the six yard box so surely that would have been when and where he would have been penalised for offside?

Houghton did say that but my reaction on hearing him was you've got that wrong because at the game I made a point of looking at the assistant ref.

He still touched it outside the 6 yard box yet Hart took the resulting kick within the 6 yard box, which would more likely indicate a goal kick

http://www.footballorgin.net/2015/09/premier-league-2015-2016-bbc-match-of.html

42:50

I'll go by Sagna's furious reaction (otherwise why would he react as he did?), the commentator and Hart taking his kick within the 6 yard box, perhaps like I said previously people were confused by the outstretched flag signalling a goal kick.

Obviously doesn't matter in the grand scheme of things, just all signs point to him not being given offside.
 
Last edited:
Hi Blues,
Well, I haven't enjoyed a defeat so much in ages. That was a bloody good game. A proper battle. But not nasty.
Usual low standard of refereeing that we've come to expect in this league (not that I'm complaining too much....)
I thought there'd have been more goals ( at both ends) but congratulations on keeping another clean sheet. If only our opening assault had included an accurate shot or two.
Like a lot on here, I find Nasri's long sojourne on the pitch a bit of a mystery with so much pace available elsewhere.
Good Luck against Juve, this game should have set you up nicely for it.

Well done, no dishonour in losing to the best side in the PL.

Fair play buddy cheers
 
I'm guessing you missed the Watford game then! Mainly because it makes your criticism seem errrm completely wrong I'd say!
You want us to play 1 7 2 do you? Okaaaaaay then. Is that you Louis?
Nah I watched the Watford game mate. I'm not criticising, I'm not saying were shit am I. I am expressing an opinion. And yeah that's what I am suggesting doing something completely different to over run a team who is parking the bus.
 
4-4-2 in tough games like this just doesn't work and i thought the manager had learnt this but oh no he just can't help himself and it could have cost us as it did so often last season. Great win though at the death at a ground and against a team that a lot of teams will struggle with.

Now watch them roll over for the rags and the likes at home
 
5live said is was flagged offside, couldn't tell on the SKY rerun or MoTD.
Cheesy on Radio Manc also said it was offside but the highlights on the OS shows a city player remonstrating towards the liner, which suggests the flag stayed down.
 
My take, for what it's worth.

Now this is getting frightening.

There is a cold determination about this team that we haven't seen for a long, long time, in my opinion. Not since the first half of the 2011-12 season. Perhaps we should partly thank the media for that. I think it got well up the players' noses that nobody in the media — absolutely nobody — was rating us for the title at the beginning of August. So take a bow, Messrs Tyler, Merson, Savage, Carragher, Souness and all the rest of your crew.

Saturday was clearly a test in a way that no match has been so far (although Everton was pretty stern). Let's be honest. For the first half hour or so, they were on top. Especially down their right hand side (so, our left), there was danger virtually every time they broke. And yet… and yet, if you look at it calmly, they weren't actually making much out of it. Although Kolarov was having a poor game, he was being more than competently covered by his defence. That wasn't happening last season. There was panic. There is no more panic. Mangala looks calm, settled. Superbly athletic — we knew that — but not diving in. It looks as though he's found his place. And his timing.

If you look at it, over the whole match, sure, Palace missed a couple of chances that they could have put away. We missed a chance — Navas — that definitely should have been put away. And Joe, in fact, had to pull out one great save, but one only. That, he knows how to do. Five matches in and nobody has found a way through. If we're solid at the back, the goals up front will take care of themselves. Even without Silva, Sterling, and in effect, Aguero, we won the match. We've just got too much quality in midfield, and up front. What amazed me about De Bruyne's debut was how sure he looked, right from the get-go. How much authority he was already playing with, in a team that he basically doesn't know yet. He wasn't faultless, but he was constantly trying things out, with a total absence of fear. No, really, I wonder just how good this can get.

Now this can't go on forever, of course. Somebody will score against us, somebody will take the lead. The next test of this team, then, is how we react to that. Because a team that goes one goal down and goes on to win the game is looking very serious candidates for being champions. Interesting times. Roll on Juventus and West Ham.

Our rivals? I think it's going to take a long, long time for this to sink in for their supporters, but I strongly suspect that it'll be many years before Liverpool are even going to be challenging for top four again. They seem to have a talent for taking good players and then turning them into dross. Without Coutinho, there is nothing in midfield. Mindless. People say that we depend on Silva. Well no, actually. But they do depend on Coutinho. It's not clear that Liverpool are now anybody's rivals, except, I suppose, for Europa League spots.

United? They have flattered to deceive. I'm certain of it. They were a team bereft of ideas for much of that match on Sunday, made to look acceptable by an even more barren team, and a great goal — I admit it — out of virtually nothing, right at the death. But watching that match was like a form of eye torture. And that's the second time I've seen them and thought that, this season.

That leaves Arsenal and Chelsea, unless we consider that an outsider is going to put in a serious challenge. It might happen, who knows? Chelsea have now effectively put themselves in a position where they've got to win this upcoming match against Arsenal, merely to tread water. It seems ridiculous to say it when we're not even into October, but if we beat West Ham, and they lose to Arsenal, then I don't see that there's a way back for them. We'll drop points, but not that many. And they'd have to go on an insane run. If Arsenal win, on the other hand, they are the most credible candidates to stay the pace. But they still don't have much fire power up front, and even with Cech, their defence is suspect. They've got a very skilful midfield. It may be a good thing that we've got Arsenal at the Etihad as our last home fixture.

We're going to be competing in four competitions, and this year, we could go a long, long way in all of them. We've got to be ruthless about the two domestic cups, in this sense: second team, for both of them. I love it when we've won the League Cup, and even more the F.A. Cup, which still holds its magic for me, but been there, done that. Second team, from Caballero up, for both. No question in my mind. Our second team is still pretty bloody good, if it's going to include players like Zab, Demichelis, Nasri, Bony and Delph.

Question: Fernando, so far as I know, is still an employee of MCFC. He's become Mr Invisible. Not even mentioned any more in press conferences. If it is the case that he was carrying a groin injury for all of last season, he may be a better player than we've given him credit for. Let's at least entertain that possibility. I'd want to take a second look at him, at least in that second team.
 
MOTD would appear to be in a parallel universe....

Just watched the highlights on the City website, and they largely supported the statistics from the game - that City created lots more chances, had far more shots than Palace, had the majority of possession.

So what on earth was MOTD showing on Saturday night? Two shots on target each, just to be balanced? Dear oh dear.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top