- Joined
- 18 Sep 2009
- Messages
- 15,013
This is why I’m slightly uncomfortable going into the 2 cup finals especially the FA cup you just know they’ll do what they can to stitch us up ..
And the commentary will be that it’s deserved cuz City are cheats.
This is why I’m slightly uncomfortable going into the 2 cup finals especially the FA cup you just know they’ll do what they can to stitch us up ..
If van Hecke held Haaland like that, would it be given a penalty by VAR?Didn’t really see that as double standards any more than the usual between defenders and attackers tbh.
The Silva one wasn’t enough for a penalty, the Haaland one was enough to disallow a goal.
If van Hecke held Haaland like that, would it be given a penalty by VAR?
That's why I think it shouldn't have been disallowed. If you can take away a goal for an attacker pulling a shirt like that, you should get a free shot at goal (i.e. a penalty) for a defender pulling a shirt like that.Probably not, for the reason I said :)
That's why I think it shouldn't have been disallowed. If you can take away a goal for an attacker pulling a shirt like that, you should get a free shot at goal (i.e. a penalty) for a defender pulling a shirt like that.
No, the scenario I'm posing is the exact reverse of what happened (Colwill holding Haaland in the same situation).Ah you’re saying if it was a guaranteed goal? In which case then probably yes. Doesn’t happen that often though.
No, the scenario I'm posing is the exact reverse of what happened (van Hecke holding Haaland in the same situation).
Might be able to buy himself a new suit.
How are they different?Didn’t really see that as double standards any more than the usual between defenders and attackers tbh.
The Silva one wasn’t enough for a penalty, the Haaland one was enough to disallow a goal.
He had to rule them out. One was offside and the other was a clear handball.Don't think the ref was dodgy at all. They were always going to give it as a foul.
Plus, Brighton had two goals of their own ruled out. Ref didn't have to do that.
Soft decision not to give our goal, but I do think this ref was fairly decent, and has been previously
Hooper about the best of a very bad bunch.
He is not the only one who gets in the way!I'm ignoring the var decision for now.
Don't think much of this ref, but most of his decisions were ok. The thing that hindered us most was the amount of passing options he managed to block in midfield. Not sure if he's a bit clueless or it's deliberate.
ermmmm one was clearly offside & the other has handled leading directly to a goal, both these are established rules/laws of football, the officials ‘do’ have to give them, otherwise VAR would intervene under clear & obvious, which I’m sure you’ll agree. Now I’m not saying Hooper was dodgy, but we have to ask how much of the actual incident was played to him on the monitor for a true reflection? If it’s just Haaland pulling his shirt then foul, if it’s the whole play then for me it’s a goal. It’s these minor manipulations that infuriate Pep, to the point of wanting to grip the official, it needs calling out by the club but now is not the time. All season clips of Haaland being aggressive, giving as good as he’s got have been played out on highlight reels on programs like motd, the narrative has been set that he’s a big bully & gets away with being overly aggressive towards defenders, it’ll get a lot worse next seasonDon't think the ref was dodgy at all. They were always going to give it as a foul.
Plus, Brighton had two goals of their own ruled out. Ref didn't have to do that.
How are they different?
'Didn't have to do that'Don't think the ref was dodgy at all. They were always going to give it as a foul.
Plus, Brighton had two goals of their own ruled out. Ref didn't have to do that.