You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Samir Nasri
- Thread starter robbieh
- Start date
Re: Nasri
Because the follow through was reckless. Haven't we not had our Kompany shown a red for exactly that. These refs are so fucking inconsistent.
cheddar404 said:andrewmswift said:bassong should have walked for the tackle
Why? It was a cracking tackle. Just like kompany's that led to our second goal.
Nasri did pretty much nothing and didn't deserve to walk. Who remembers when you had to do something pretty bad to get a red card? The sport's far too soft these days.
Because the follow through was reckless. Haven't we not had our Kompany shown a red for exactly that. These refs are so fucking inconsistent.
MSP
Well-Known Member
Re: Nasri
Mancini said in interview that we'll appeal.
SuperSilva said:its official .... we are appealing Nasri's red card
http://www1.skysports.com/football/news/11679/8368988/
However it is SS... so could be full of shit but personally I think Mancini will be appealing
Mancini said in interview that we'll appeal.
cheddar404
Well-Known Member
Re: Nasri
Nothing wrong with it at all. Good old fashioned tackle as was Kompany's. Just because Kompany's was a bad decision doesn't mean this should have been.
alky313 said:cheddar404 said:andrewmswift said:bassong should have walked for the tackle
Why? It was a cracking tackle. Just like kompany's that led to our second goal.
Nasri did pretty much nothing and didn't deserve to walk. Who remembers when you had to do something pretty bad to get a red card? The sport's far too soft these days.
Because the follow through was reckless. Haven't we not had our Kompany shown a red for exactly that. These refs are so fucking inconsistent.
Nothing wrong with it at all. Good old fashioned tackle as was Kompany's. Just because Kompany's was a bad decision doesn't mean this should have been.
Barcon
Well-Known Member
Re: Nasri
Try watching it again, it was a bad tackle and should have been a straight red. Nothing like Vinnies tackle.
cheddar404 said:alky313 said:cheddar404 said:Why? It was a cracking tackle. Just like kompany's that led to our second goal.
Nasri did pretty much nothing and didn't deserve to walk. Who remembers when you had to do something pretty bad to get a red card? The sport's far too soft these days.
Because the follow through was reckless. Haven't we not had our Kompany shown a red for exactly that. These refs are so fucking inconsistent.
Nothing wrong with it at all. Good old fashioned tackle as was Kompany's. Just because Kompany's was a bad decision doesn't mean this should have been.
Try watching it again, it was a bad tackle and should have been a straight red. Nothing like Vinnies tackle.
cheddar404
Well-Known Member
Re: Nasri
I've watched it loads of times. Got the ball and the man. Nothing wrong with that. His momentum took him through Nasri. Not even a foul, never mind a card.
Barcon said:cheddar404 said:alky313 said:Because the follow through was reckless. Haven't we not had our Kompany shown a red for exactly that. These refs are so fucking inconsistent.
Nothing wrong with it at all. Good old fashioned tackle as was Kompany's. Just because Kompany's was a bad decision doesn't mean this should have been.
Try watching it again, it was a bad tackle and should have been a straight red. Nothing like Vinnies tackle.
I've watched it loads of times. Got the ball and the man. Nothing wrong with that. His momentum took him through Nasri. Not even a foul, never mind a card.
Barcon
Well-Known Member
Re: Nasri
What about his trailing leg?
cheddar404 said:Barcon said:cheddar404 said:Nothing wrong with it at all. Good old fashioned tackle as was Kompany's. Just because Kompany's was a bad decision doesn't mean this should have been.
Try watching it again, it was a bad tackle and should have been a straight red. Nothing like Vinnies tackle.
I've watched it loads of times. Got the ball and the man. Nothing wrong with that. His momentum took him through Nasri. Not even a foul, never mind a card.
What about his trailing leg?
cheddar404
Well-Known Member
Re: Nasri
What about it? It's football, not flower arranging.
Barcon said:cheddar404 said:Barcon said:Try watching it again, it was a bad tackle and should have been a straight red. Nothing like Vinnies tackle.
I've watched it loads of times. Got the ball and the man. Nothing wrong with that. His momentum took him through Nasri. Not even a foul, never mind a card.
What about his trailing leg?
What about it? It's football, not flower arranging.
MSP
Well-Known Member
Re: Nasri
It was not for red card for me too. Very solid booking but I'd be mad if City player would be sent off for that tackle.
cheddar404 said:Barcon said:cheddar404 said:Nothing wrong with it at all. Good old fashioned tackle as was Kompany's. Just because Kompany's was a bad decision doesn't mean this should have been.
Try watching it again, it was a bad tackle and should have been a straight red. Nothing like Vinnies tackle.
I've watched it loads of times. Got the ball and the man. Nothing wrong with that. His momentum took him through Nasri. Not even a foul, never mind a card.
It was not for red card for me too. Very solid booking but I'd be mad if City player would be sent off for that tackle.