Southampton (A) - Carabao Cup | Post Match Thread

This season we've gone from being highly consistent in our performances and will to win to being flakey and inconsistent. We now don't know which City is going to turn up from game to game. Brilliant one game, as against Chelsea, to shocking the next as against Southampton. Actually this malaise started towards the end of last season but some individual skill got us through. We were dreadful against Villa the last game until the subs. To the new fan's.....welcome to typical City, us old hands know it well.
I agree. But while winning is great, winning ALL the time isn't good for us as a fanbase. Our humour, our resilience, our attachment to the club was built in tougher times. A bit of Typical City is good for the soul and good for the new fan to know what it's like. Like so many of us I never supported City because they were winning, I supported them because I grew up near the ground and when I went there I felt at home there and the Blues I knew were nice people. A bit of adversity reminds me of the old days - but the advantage we have on the old days is that it doesn't feel terminal, it's nowhere near as bad.

We are in a transitional period. We're adjusting to a post-Haaland style of playing. Some of the guys who have been the bedrock of the team are getting older (Gundo, KDB) or want away (Bernardo). We have no Arteta, Juanma's gone, and I don't know if Enzo Maresca has the relationship with Pep that his predecessors in the assistant role did.

We have made some brilliant signings but we have also made some more questionable signings - and sales - as any club will do. 'Smaller' teams appear to have Pep and us worked out. It isn't just Everton, Brentford, So'ton - Palace and Fulham were threatening, and we allowed Brighton way too much possession...we haven't looked ourselves since United.

But for now I'm relaxed. I'll stay relaxed as long as Pep shows a bit more, dare I say it, humility, or simplicity, in his approach, more willingness to change what isn't working. The earlier substitutions are a sign. But we need fewer experiments in which players are out of position, a bit more trust in the individual creativity of the players and a bit less dependence on a system which is making us predictable to lower ranked sides.

All that said, ALL the top sides are showing vulnerabilities, and ultimately it will come down to competition between the top sides. A win in the derby and all will well be again, just how we felt just last Sunday.
 
Last edited:
I agree. But while winning is great, winning ALL the time isn't good for us as a fanbase. Our humour, our resilience, our attachment to the club was built in tougher times. A bit of Typical City is good for the soul and good for the new fan to know what it's like. Like so many of us I never supported City because they were winning, I supported them because I grew up near the ground and when I went there I felt at home there and the Blues I knew were nice people. A bit of adversity reminds me of the old days - but the advantage we have on the old days is that it doesn't feel terminal, it's nowhere near as bad.

We are in a transitional period. We're adjusting to a post-Haaland style of playing. Some of the guys who have been the bedrock of the team are getting older (Gundo, KDB) or want away (Bernardo). We have no Arteta, Juanma's gone, and I don't know if Enzo Maresca has the relationship with Pep that his predecessors in the assistant role did.

We have made some brilliant signings but we have also made some more questionable signings - and sales - as any club will do. 'Smaller' teams appear to have Pep and us worked out. It isn't just Everton, Brentford, So'ton - Palace and Fulham were threatening, and we allowed Brighton way too much possession...we haven't looked ourselves since United.

But for now I'm relaxed. I'll stay relaxed as long as Pep shows a bit more, dare I say it, humility, or simplicity, in his approach, more willingness to change what isn't working. The earlier substitutions are a sign. But we need fewer experiments in which players are out of position, a bit more trust in the individual creativity of the players and a bit less dependence on a system which is making us predictable to lower ranked sides.

All that said, ALL the top sides are showing vulnerabilities, and ultimately it will come down to competition between the top sides. A win in the derby and all well be again, just how we felt just last Sunday.

Good assesment and given our changes I always thought this season might go a little this way.

Every team has its day at the top, we've had ten good years, we'll see how it goes from here.
 
Laporte?

I'll go with both. A shit performance by an absolute shit line up. But Pep can't really believe a proper line up would not have dispatched of Southampton. That part is pure bullocks. That line up would be fighting relegation in the Prem.
100%, Laporte & Gomez look miles off it, at least 3 times Laporte had to make Wan Bassaka tackles because he just can't get to 50-50 balls

He will be gone if we sign Gvardiol & Ake has been miles better
 
This season we've gone from being highly consistent in our performances and will to win to being flakey and inconsistent. We now don't know which City is going to turn up from game to game. Brilliant one game, as against Chelsea, to shocking the next as against Southampton. Actually this malaise started towards the end of last season but some individual skill got us through. We were dreadful against Villa the last game until the subs. To the new fan's.....welcome to typical City, us old hands know it well.
Exactly mate, which is why I shake my head when people predict we're going to batter teams week after week. As you say, us older heads know City a lot better
 
Palmer gets bigged up massively on Twitter and I've been aboard the hype train but recently I just feel he's not ever going to be at this level. I'd ask how many assists, goals, or assist to an assist he has but I suppose that would be a little unfair as he often comes on late.

I rate the keeper as back up.

When we first got Gomez I was very impressed. I still think he could be decent for us.

Walker just seemed to have an off game, Phillips not played enough to judge him on last night, Foden looking a bit like he wasn't up for it.

Pep rates Gundo, he always proves me wrong but I always feel he's not suited for many of the games he plays.
I think they just weren't up for it. Or that arsed.
Which isn't good enough is it, Pep says not prepared whatever the fuck that means. Sounds like we've not even trained prior to the Southampton game which would explain that abomination
 
I know the performance and result was shit but surprisingly calm today, as long as we equal or better Arsenals result will do me this weekend as we’ve got a really hard schedule coming fast, starting Saturday
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.