With guardialo joining Munich,Now Mancini should be backed

[SWP's back]

Do people think Mancini will be here if we win nothing this year. Long way to go so im not saying we wont win anything but it would be ignorant to think that his head wont be on the chopping board if he wins nothing

Why ignorant?

Do you really think that from this day forth we will change manager in any year where we don't win a pot?

I would say that was pathetic from our club if so and that is the reasoning.

 

[BluePurgatory]

Do people think Mancini will be here if we win nothing this year. Long way to go so im not saying we wont win anything but it would be ignorant to think that his head wont be on the chopping board if he wins nothing

I think he will be ... my guess is if the club didn't move for Guardiola, then they won't move for anyone else this summer.

For once Billy I agree with you!

 

[Akira]

Do people think Mancini will be here if we win nothing this year. Long way to go so im not saying we wont win anything but it would be ignorant to think that his head wont be on the chopping board if he wins nothing

I feel the same. Our owners aren't alike a Russian billionaire.

 

[dancity19]

Do people think Mancini will be here if we win nothing this year. Long way to go so im not saying we wont win anything but it would be ignorant to think that his head wont be on the chopping board if he wins nothing

I feel the same. Our owners aren't alike a Russian billionaire.

I think you actually feel very differently...?

 

[stonerblue]

If you are changing managers you do it because you don't believe the existing man can fulfil the club's future objectives. And you replace him with the best available. So I can't answer the question until I know who's available and who would take the job.

I'm not being obtuse, that's just how it is. What I know is that our job has a serious pull and we'd never be short of candidates. Personally, I believe mourinho would love our job.

Funny that as i thought changing a manager was down to their side being shit in previous games.

Maybe if you are Barry Fry firing John Beck that's the case. But with a top club the decision is taken on whether the manager is deemed to be the correct man for the future. Results are obviously part of that but if you are Txiki Begeristain I would hope that you don't sit down a manager and say "we are dismissing you because you were shit in previous games".

The sack isn't a punishment, it's a strategic decision by a club.

Yet you say if Bobby doesn't win the league this season he may be gone. Surely that is getting rid due to past results ?

 

[kevstar]

Guardialo. Who dat den? Does this mean the former Barca manager (Guardiola) is still free to choose a premiership club?

 

[sir baconface]

Do people think Mancini will be here if we win nothing this year. Long way to go so im not saying we wont win anything but it would be ignorant to think that his head wont be on the chopping board if he wins nothing

I think he will be ... my guess is if the club didn't move for Guardiola, then they won't move for anyone else this summer.

You may well be right. While there was frenzied speculation on here, there's a real possibility the owners actually were in for the longer run when they offered RM that 5-year contract. That's not to say they wouldn't keep things under review if progress were seriously de-railed. One disappointing season need not be fatal.<br /><br />-- Thu Jan 17, 2013 1:14 pm --<br /><br />

[
Not sure Phil Neal or Frank Clark will be on ADUG's radar if they sack Mancini tbh.

Admit it, GDM. You are in the know.

 

[GRAHAM mcfc]

Manchini has made some significant errors of judgement tactically and in terms of players. Must win the league and then get to at least champs league semis or should go. Some real misplaced loyalty towards him

THIS

 

[crystal_mais]

I'll back Mancini as long a he is manager of the football team, but I'll also criticise him when I want to.

 

[Danielmanc]

Do people think Mancini will be here if we win nothing this year. Long way to go so im not saying we wont win anything but it would be ignorant to think that his head wont be on the chopping board if he wins nothing

Why ignorant?

Do you really think that from this day forth we will change manager in any year where we don't win a pot?

I would say that was pathetic from our club if so and that is the reasoning.

There will be seasons that we win nothing in the future, for sure - don't think we'll change manager each time.