Worst Goalkeeper

[Eccles Blue]

That was and still is amazing!!!


*Tongue in cheek time*
If Pep thought Joe couldn’t come out he obviously never watched that one!!!

 

[ganganvince]

Perry Suckling was shite

 

[xgorton]

Ron Healey.

 

[johnnytapia]

Margetson

Is the correct answer (but possibly incorrect spelling). In which case it’s the wrong answer.

 

[johnnytapia]

Is the correct answer (but possibly incorrect spelling). In which case it’s the wrong answer.

It’s the correct spelling. And answer

 

[Ribble73]

From memory Hart signed his own death certificate in that friendly when he was told to play out from the back and repeatedly lumped it up to Aguero…..

Aguero apparently had his issues with Pep aswell early on, but knuckled down and won him around quite quickly

I reckon the 3-1 Home defeat to Peps Bayern was where Pep decided Joe wasn’t up to it -constantly hoofing it up and giving up possession when we couldn’t get the ball off them all night.

 

[simmo]

Margetson - was poor in goal. He came on as sub one game as an outfield player and was even worse.

Part of Southgate’s back room staff now !!

 

[Corky]

Margetson - was poor in goal. He came on as sub one game as an outfield player and was even worse.

Part of Southgate’s back room staff now !!

Whilst Dibbs is at Accrington Stanley, and doing a good job. The 2 former Welsh internationals.

 

[paulchapo]

Margetson - was poor in goal. He came on as sub one game as an outfield player and was even worse.

Part of Southgate’s back room staff now !!

Worst keeper I've ever seen at City.

 

[sh249]

Hard to pick a standout - Margetson, Immel, Suckling, Siddall, Burridge …
I always thought Tommy Wright was wank as well.
Post-2000: either Bravo for that first season (though redeemed himself as a good cup keeper the season after), or Seaman - very good at his best, dogshit for us.

 

[Sky Blue Thinking]

Martyn Margetson was pretty shocking wasn't he! There was one FA Cup game at Brentford where we won 1:0 and he seemed unbeatable, other than that he really was pretty shit most of the time.
There was a young Danish keeper in our first season at COMS looked petrified on his debut when we lost 3:0 to Leicester (as were the City fans when the ball went anywhere near him) From memory I dont think he played too many more games for us.

Kevin Stuhr Ellegaard. Played a few games between Seaman and James. Apart from being tall can't remember many other attributes.

 

[Sky Blue Thinking]

Martyn margetson.
Now England goalkeeper coach.

Is like being shit at a subject at school then ending up teaching it.

 

[Bluesince1979]

Margetson - was poor in goal. He came on as sub one game as an outfield player and was even worse.

Part of Southgate’s back room staff now !!

Wow totally forgot about that!! League cup game ? Taking a punt v wycombe

 

[Bluesince1979]

(ooh) barry sydall
John (budgie) burridge
Simon (shite) tracey

All those three make immell kook like lev yashin

 

[horlock_was_super]

Never thought much of Carlo Nash to be honest.
There has been some absolute shite down the years though.

 

[markbmcfc]

Always thought Tommy Wright was gash.

Dibble and Margetson were a travesty. Didn't margetson play up front once? Was infinitely better, yet still shite.

 

[Citizen of Legoland]

Andreas Isaakson, signed by Sven, Swedish international. I knew he was shite on the first goal he conceded, he dived ten minutes after the ball went past him*. The dive looked impressive though. Only played 7 games then dropped in favour of two rookies, luckily they were both decent.

*A bit like Onana at the Trafford Red Sox on Saturday.

 

[nicko]

David Seaman was fucking abysmal for us. Hated pretty much all our ‘well pass their heyday signings’ him, Mcpointy, Clough, Fowler etc

 

[mattcity5]

Kevin Stuhr Ellegaard. Played a few games between Seaman and James. Apart from being tall can't remember many other attributes.

Terrified. I remember him as being tall and terrified the one time I saw him play.

 

[mattcity5]

David Seaman was fucking abysmal for us. Hated pretty much all our ‘well pass their heyday signings’ him, Mcpointy, Clough, Fowler etc

Seaman was dogshit. We managed to get a good year out of Schmeichel snr and figured we could do the same with Seaman. Turns out that Arsenal defence must have been even better than everyone thought.