Rodenberger10 said:
Matt the Giant said:
Genuine questions;
1) Haven't we performed rather well without him when he has been away to the afcon?
2) Didn't Guardiola okay the sale of Yaya at Barcelona?
No we haven't. We are always shaky in jan when he goes and guardiola did not want him to go but yaya wanted a starting place every week and also a pay rise.
Hrm..
Season 11/12, from the mid January (when he left) to the end February, we played 9 games:
7 wins
1 loss
1 draw
Goal difference +13
Not really "shaky" in my book.
Season 12/13, same period, 8 games:
5 wins
1 loss
2 draws
Goal difference +9
Again not that "shaky" in my book.
No one here would ever say Yaya is anything but a really great player, but he has weaknesses which can and should be addressed, and he's not that paramount to our success as some may try to reason.
Further more, it's not disloyal to criticize a player.
Maybe we should all try to establish his strengths and weaknesses, and then figure out what his best position would be and how playing him in that position would effect the team structure.
Personally, as ANY1aBLUE above, I think his best position is as a central attacking mf behind a lone striker. But playing him there would mean one of Nasri, Silva and Jovetic plus two of our three strikers would find themselves on the bench.
-- Wed Sep 04, 2013 5:28 pm --
Vienna_70 said:
YaYa is wasted as a defensive / central midfielder; he should be used much more as he was in the title season, i.e. as an attacking midfielder, scaring opposing defences to death.
Now that Barry has left, Milner or Rodwell should be patrolling in front of the back four.
I agree with everything in this post. The two mentioned above, or one of them two with Fernandinho would make a very tight centre midfield.