shroom
Well-Known Member
edit: whoa, just noticed Manu Garcia starting, too, cool biz ...
He has played once in the cup,throwing him into a difficult away game with no other cb to lead him,really just reallyIt's a long season and Foden literally has to start games during the festive period so I'm calm about his situation. However, there has to be a discussion in regards to Guardiola and youth development; we played two central defensive midfielders at CB instead of Garcia which has to make a statement regarding his own future at the club and how much trust Guardiola has on him and our youth as a whole.
He has played once in the cup,throwing him into a difficult away game with no other cb to lead him,really just really
It's a difficult away game but surely it must be harder to adjust to a new position (Rodri) than to play in your natural position. Regardless, Garcia now knows that he is behind Rodri and Fernandinho in the pecking order so it says everything about Pep's 'trust'.
Don't be a drama queen,he is a wet behind the ears kidIt's a difficult away game but surely it must be harder to adjust to a new position (Rodri) than to play in your natural position. Regardless, Garcia now knows that he is behind Rodri and Fernandinho in the pecking order so it says everything about Pep's 'trust'.
do you honestly believe Garcia is expecting to play premier league at this stage in his career..I’m sure he is more than happy where he is at
So is Stones mate.It's a difficult away game but surely it must be harder to adjust to a new position (Rodri) than to play in your natural position. Regardless, Garcia now knows that he is behind Rodri and Fernandinho in the pecking order so it says everything about Pep's 'trust'.
Can't do any worse than Otamendi. But Ota is probably ahead of him regardless.I rate Garcia, I think he’s a really good footballer. He’s impressed me every time he’s played for us. But in them few games there’s been moments when I’ve thought in the league he’d maybe get caught out for not being physically up to it at this stage in his career.
do you honestly believe Garcia is expecting to play premier league at this stage in his career..I’m sure he is more than happy where he is at
Oh ffs,it was one gameNo not necessarily but it's to do with circumstance. Playing two CDMs instead of him would surely make him question his position in the peaking order. Right now, it appears it's Laporte, Stones, Otamendi, Fernandinho, Rodri then him so being 6th choice CB probably wasn't his hope.
Oh ffs,it was one game
Pep has a history of playing tall DMs into the CB spot, in fact Rodri seems like the more logical choice than Dinho in this regard.And it's the only game we can go off regarding Garcia's position in the pecking order. I'm not even arguing that he's ready but it looks apparent that he's behind Rodri as a CB option which is a tad concerning.
Pep has a history of playing tall DMs into the CB spot, in fact Rodri seems like the more logical choice than Dinho in this regard.
Gonna echo in what others said, he is only 18, Dinho isn't going to be here that long and Otamendi will probably be the same. The lad has time on his side.
Fair enough, but consider last season we had Dinho, Kompany and Otamendi as CB options, and next season may lose all 3, we can't only have 2 senior CBs in Stones and Laporte, a 3rd is a MUST.I agree about Dinho who only has another season after this maximum but we're most likely going to buy a replacement for Otamendi going off reports so the passage to being a first choice CB option doesn't appear clear right now.
Fair enough, but consider last season we had Dinho, Kompany and Otamendi as CB options, and next season may lose all 3, we can't only have 2 senior CBs in Stones and Laporte, a 3rd is a MUST.
I agree but considering we'll most likely purchase a young CB as we usually do our business and the age of Rodri, it doesn't look like Garcia really has much of a shot.