VAR thread 2022/23

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ric
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Blue Mist said:
As soon as I saw spitty I turned off, what was it about ?
Click to expand...

Neville confirmed that the comms team can hear the conversation between VAR and onfield ref. They also get to see the replays that VAR get to see as they see it.
Carragher said that as the onfield ref is going to the monitor, the VAR is explaining why it should be overturned, and he didn't think it was a good thing to happen.
Neville said he thinks the VAR/ref conversation should be openly broadcast.
 
MillionMilesAway said:
Neville confirmed that the comms team can hear the conversation between VAR and onfield ref. They also get to see the replays that VAR get to see as they see it.
Carragher said that as the onfield ref is going to the monitor, the VAR is explaining why it should be overturned, and he didn't think it was a good thing to happen.
Neville said he thinks the VAR/ref conversation should be openly broadcast.
Click to expand...
Cheers. It explains a lot. The var man is basically telling the ref he is wrong rather than, have another look, we think ***** but your in charge.
 
Blue Mist said:
Cheers. It explains a lot. The var man is basically telling the ref he is wrong rather than, have another look, we think ***** but your in charge.
Click to expand...

Yes, and if it's a more 'senior' ref in VAR, that would potentially pressurise the onfield ref.
I can't imagine that would have gone down well with Mike Dean, so maybe he'll redress it a bit (if he's allowed to).
 
Match day 1 in the PL and:
Non penalty for Leeds
Non Penalty for Brighton
Non sending off for the Rag
Non sending off for the Spurs defender

What on earth do both Var and Assistant Var officials do if they cannot see and overturn such simple decisions
 
MillionMilesAway said:
Neville confirmed that the comms team can hear the conversation between VAR and onfield ref. They also get to see the replays that VAR get to see as they see it.
Carragher said that as the onfield ref is going to the monitor, the VAR is explaining why it should be overturned, and he didn't think it was a good thing to happen.
Neville said he thinks the VAR/ref conversation should be openly broadcast.
Click to expand...
.
'You're telling me you think I've definitely missed something, but I don't think it would be good to review it, because...'???

Because what???

...'because if I did, it would mean that little girl's life support would be switched off...'???

What could possibly be the reason for such a ridiculously inept response?

That is fucking shocking.
 
Blue Mist said:
Ta. I just cannot stand listening to him. I would rather talk to my wife about FFP than listen to him.
Click to expand...
This FFP you speak to your wife about.
Is it financial fair play like the rest of us or your nickname for "fancy frilly panties"
 
hertsblue said:
Match day 1 in the PL and:
Non penalty for Leeds
Non Penalty for Brighton
Non sending off for the Rag
Non sending off for the Spurs defender

What on earth do both Var and Assistant Var officials do if they cannot see and overturn such simple decisions
Click to expand...
How Brighton didn’t get a penalty for that shove in the back of Welbeck I will never know, I thought that’s what VAR should pick out. I’m wasn’t in favour of VAR at the start and still unconvinced.
 
VAR should have been a panacea for many ill's, but i think we all know, the decisions from Stockley park are based on who they want to win rather than interpreting the rules.
 
hertsblue said:
Match day 1 in the PL and:
Non penalty for Leeds
Non Penalty for Brighton
Non sending off for the Rag
Non sending off for the Spurs defender

What on earth do both Var and Assistant Var officials do if they cannot see and overturn such simple decisions
Click to expand...
it's not there to re-ref the game just help the rags out as often as possible
 
Plays By Sense Of Smell said:
.
'You're telling me you think I've definitely missed something, but I don't think it would be good to review it, because...'???

Because what???

...'because if I did, it would mean that little girl's life support would be switched off...'???

What could possibly be the reason for such a ridiculously inept response?

That is fucking shocking.
Click to expand...
Possible misinterpretation?
Carragher said that as the onfield ref is going to the monitor, the VAR is explaining why it should be overturned, and he didn't think it was a good thing to happen.

should be read as

Carragher said that as the onfield ref is going to the monitor, the VAR is explaining why it should be overturned, and he (CARRAGHER) didn't think it was a good thing to happen (i.e. the explanation of why VAR thought it was wrong).
 
The first weekend of the season and already var and the idiots that don't run it, is taking centre stage.
I know we are biaised against the rags and see incidents through blue tinted glasses but var didn't even review 2 of the 3 obvious ones at the Swamp. They must have reviewed the rag goal as supposedly they review every goal so how did they miss the handball ? Monday showed 3 camera angles, the third where the player is facing the camera is as clear as day.
What a complete and utter fucking farce.
 
Blue Mist said:
The first weekend of the season and already var and the idiots that don't run it, is taking centre stage.
I know we are biaised against the rags and see incidents through blue tinted glasses but var didn't even review 2 of the 3 obvious ones at the Swamp. They must have reviewed the rag goal as supposedly they review every goal so how did they miss the handball ? Monday showed 3 camera angles, the third where the player is facing the camera is as clear as day.
What a complete and utter fucking farce.
Click to expand...
That incident where Welbeck was shoved to the ground inside the box, I wonder what the decision would of been if the roles were reversed....
 
There was some strange instant editing the other night in the rags game. The commentators saw what we all saw with the handball goal and one of them thought out loud that’s what VAR was reviewing. As soon as he said that the replay skipped the handball frames and kept showing the ball going into the net and the message they were checking for offside. Nobody anywhere thought offside, everyone thought handball….bent as fuck!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top