Can you appeal a yellow card?
10 | Jack Grealish - 2024/25
- Thread starter Keeper!
- Start date
- Status
idk...i guess you can but most of time they will support Ref/Var...if it`s possible we should at least try...it was clearly not a dive
johnny crossan
Well-Known Member
Good to see the verdict on today's game from a clearly discerning public audience
WickyWain
Well-Known Member
Brilliant from Grealish today. Easily his best league performance of the season ;)
ninjamonkey
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 5 Jun 2009
- Messages
- 22,281
Any replays of the dive/foul? Couldn't tell from the south stand. There's absolutely no reasoning behind him diving in that situation which makes it hard to believe it was actually a dive. Refs need to be pretty darn sure to be dishing them out nowadays though, var has generally raised the bar for what refs are willing to caution for.
its a ridiculous yellow either way. Either from jack or more likely the ref. Yellow cards should be rescindable like a red card considering the accumulation results in the same consequence. No re-reffing games or analyzing fouls, just a weekly review of obvious errors like false accusation of simulation or mis-identification etc
He got banned last season after picking up 10 yellows without making a single bookable foul which caused him to miss a game exactly when doku got injured and was needed. If that happens again, that card contributes to it when he's potentially done fuck all wrong and it's an easy fix.
its a ridiculous yellow either way. Either from jack or more likely the ref. Yellow cards should be rescindable like a red card considering the accumulation results in the same consequence. No re-reffing games or analyzing fouls, just a weekly review of obvious errors like false accusation of simulation or mis-identification etc
He got banned last season after picking up 10 yellows without making a single bookable foul which caused him to miss a game exactly when doku got injured and was needed. If that happens again, that card contributes to it when he's potentially done fuck all wrong and it's an easy fix.
salfordbluetrue
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 2 Jul 2013
- Messages
- 4,318
No. except where it is the wrong player, i suppose he could say the Ipswich player should have it for fouling him. :) Got to love him i saw some figures from last season, 6 fouls committed, 7 yellow cards, and this one is why.
salfordbluetrue
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 2 Jul 2013
- Messages
- 4,318
Seen some replays the Ipswich player, goes over Grealish`s foot, so it is a foul, but it could still be classed as simulation, i do not think Grealish has made a meal of it. But this is the first yellow i have seen given when there is contact, for example the ref did not book the Ipswich player when he dismissed that penalty claim.
Very much a case of the PL targeting Grealish.
If that is the case, he seriously needs to see a Shrink or a Psychologist. He really needs to get help or else, it would ruin his career. Trauma is not something to ignore or sweep under a rug, it should be dealt with from the root!
Kamaro011
Well-Known Member
It's not Grealish thread without wild speculation and baseless assumption.
I feel at home already.
I feel at home already.
Pep played Grealish in both legs vs Real.
Guess Pep sees that Doku is the future. Hard to disagree on that.
But this season is going to be very long, Grealish will get many chances to show he deserves to play more often. It's up to him ultimately.
"
Still think his hours break in and the trauma of it is still effecting him!"
Come on stop it, that was a long time ago, the excuses have to stop.
I like Doku a lot but I think Jack is definitely more productive with his use of the ball. At the moment Doku jinks about a lot then more often than not, passes backwards.
Jack is a better player IMHO
By the sounds of it, he doesn't!
- Status