greasedupdeafguy
Well-Known Member
Fern, Gundogan and Sergio will be the first three names on the teamsheet imo with kdb, silva,nolito,navas,sterling,kelechi and sane fighting for the other three places
I see KDB and Silva as CAMs in a 4141 with Gundogan in the pivot.And did KdB play behind the striker so far? Not really. He himself described his current position as some sort of 'free 8 role'. And Gundogan's basically an '8'. You're right in that Dortmund played (possession-based) 4-2-3-1 with Gundogan as part of the double pivot, and of course we might see a change in formation once Ilkay is fit. Not that Pep uses the 4-2-3-1 too much, but he made some exceptions when he had to pick Vidal more often than not at Bayern as he's become very vital to his system.
I don't think this will hapen, though Pep is Pep. :)I see KDB and Silva as CAMs in a 4141 with Gundogan in the pivot.
We'll just have to wait and see I guess.I don't think this will hapen, though Pep is Pep. :)
It would mean Gundogan would drop back to the CBs like Xabi did at Bayern for Pep, and now Fernandinho does, which is unlikely in my opinion. I know Pep is not simulating his Barca side, but you would rather think of Gundogan as a 'new Xavi' than Busquets.
When everyone is fit I think...Fern, Gundogan and Sergio will be the first three names on the teamsheet imo with kdb, silva,nolito,navas,sterling,kelechi and sane fighting for the other three places
When everyone is fit I think...
Bravo (No.1 keeper)
Kompany (Captain)
Aguero (Best striker)
...are the only guaranteed starters and the rest is up for grabs. Obviously there will be some higher up the pecking order such as: Gundogan, Silva, De Bruyne due to their superior quality but I don't think they're guaranteed because of the strength in depth with Fernandinho, Nolito, Sané and Sterling rivalling them for the same position.
Don't get me wrong I think he could be at the heart of our defence for the next decade and possibly even be a future captain. Don't think you can say he is guaranteed if everyone is fit which is what we're talking about. He would be in my first eleven though.John stones likes this....
When everyone is fit I think...
Bravo (No.1 keeper)
Kompany (Captain)
Aguero (Best striker)
...are the only guaranteed starters and the rest is up for grabs. Obviously there will be some higher up the pecking order such as: Gundogan, Silva, De Bruyne due to their superior quality but I don't think they're guaranteed because of the strength in depth with Fernandinho, Nolito, Sané and Sterling rivalling them for the same position.
If he's fit I think he would play him over Otamendi but I guess we'll have to wait and see how he responds to his latest injury.Kompany wont be a guaranteed starter, not under Guardiola.
Don't get me wrong I think he could be at the heart of our defence for the next decade and possibly even be a future captain. Don't think you can say he is guaranteed if everyone is fit which is what we're talking about. He would be in my first eleven though.
If he's fit I think he would play him over Otamendi but I guess we'll have to wait and see how he responds to his latest injury.
I agree that Stones will probably start due to his style of defending which Pep requires.I can indeed say that when fit, he starts... Pep won't mess with the back pairing unless he has to, that's usually enforced by injury..... Kompany will also be used sparingly due to the nature of the injuries, rightly so... If kompany starts another 30/40 games over the next 2 years, I'll be happy!!
If Kompany can no longer be relied on which I fear is probably the case then I think we'll sign another CB in the next year because although Stones and Otamendi will probably be the main partnership this season, I don't think Otamendi is the future. There must be a reason we were looking at Stones and Laporte.Yeah but Pep doesn't want to be caught out when Kompany gets injured again, so he'll want Otamendi-Stones to be a very familiar partnership. Not to mention Vinny will always be getting treated carefully so he'll be rested every few games for the foreseeable future.
People going on about the 4-1-4-1 not suiting Kev or where Gundo will fit into it when he returns etc, are thinking far too rigidly and not seeing the wood for the trees imo.
These are two special players, KdB is pretty much unique in world football in his capacity to see and execute decisive passes in the final third, he's like a killer fucking unicorn !
Gundo is a metronomic pass and move machine who can make any team run more smoothly, particularly in speeding up transition from back to front (which will obviously help Kev who is at his most lethal when breaking against a less 'set' defence)
Guardiola is not married to the two variations of 4-1-4-1 we've seen so far and quite frankly if he can't get the best out of a diamond like KdB, I'd expect him to adjust to a formation that does, or he's not the manager that I expected.
Pep is the brightest tactician in world football currently, IMO. He's creating new formations - or more accurately, new (or at least unseen in recent history) variants on existing formations to get the best out of his sides.People going on about the 4-1-4-1 not suiting Kev or where Gundo will fit into it when he returns etc, are thinking far too rigidly and not seeing the wood for the trees imo.
These are two special players, KdB is pretty much unique in world football in his capacity to see and execute decisive passes in the final third, he's like a killer fucking unicorn !
Gundo is a metronomic pass and move machine who can make any team run more smoothly, particularly in speeding up transition from back to front (which will obviously help Kev who is at his most lethal when breaking against a less 'set' defence)
Guardiola is not married to the two variations of 4-1-4-1 we've seen so far and quite frankly if he can't get the best out of a diamond like KdB, I'd expect him to adjust to a formation that does, or he's not the manager that I expected.