Adam Wharton

[Gingers Dad]

So was Kalvin Phillips

True

 

[blueparrot]

Shall we list Scott Carson's medals as well? Grealish has had half a season for us where he has been useful, the rest he has been shite

Only if you want to balance it with games played and contributions. Unless you think we won titles and trebles playing half the season with 10 plus a passenger ?

 

[Cheadle_hulmeBlue]

Grealish? Successful?

He was integral to us winning a treble, particularly in the champions league

 

[TheBlueCat]

Meteoric rise to the Premier League. Taken to the Euros after being at Palace for 5 months

Great at breaking the lines, forward passing, tempo setting. Strong across the midfield

Wharton will be a top player

Get someone slightly more experienced in addition to Wharton and our midfield will have been nicely future proofed

Meteoric? Somewhat exaggerated I think.
Taken to the Euros by Southgate? Not exactly a glowing endorsement.
I have seen no evidence of this ‘great’ breaking of lines.
Wharton may become a top player, who knows? I’m ambivalent I guess.
I just don’t see it. Only my opinion.

 

[Crooked_rain]

He was integral to us winning a treble, particularly in the champions league

Grealish was one of our better players in the last few months of the treble season and Pep had him starting all the big games in that period

 

[Semper aggressus]

Not seen much to suggest he’s the answer to our current problems. He has potential but we need an immediate improvement and energy in our team, not to mention more goal threat from midfield. I don’t think Wharton could be that guy.

 

[Tugay One Cup]

Shall we list Scott Carson's medals as well?

If someone wants to try and argue that Scott Carson hasn't been successful then yeah. Duh.

 

[Kippax Street 1880]

I've not watched a minute of Palace this season but he impressed the hell out of me when I saw him last year and thought he would be perfect for us.

 

[Alexia_Ko]

Only if you want to balance it with games played and contributions. Unless you think we won titles and trebles playing half the season with 10 plus a passenger ?

he was the only LW at the club and the only player that cost £100m, of course he was going to play

 

[blueparrot]

he was the only LW at the club and the only player that cost £100m, of course he was going to play

So you don’t think he played any part in that success orf 3 titles and a treble and we were effectively a team of 10 . Pep must be even more of a genius than we thought. You think his contribution was equal to that of Carson and Phillips? Well it’s an opinion I suppose.