joe hart

Status
Not open for further replies.
WNRH said:
Simply not good enough, a keeper should be number one priority in the summer, until then Pantilimon will do.
Summer?

And what? Have Hart cost us even more points? Bid for Casillas and Valdes in January.
 
Northwichdave said:
Kun Aguero said:
kippaxchris said:
Yet again it doesn't matter what he shouted! He should NOT have been coming in the first place.



Nasty should have booted it into row Z long before then, Joe had to come as he thought Torres was getting to the ball first, which he more than likely was. It was a massive blunder by Nastasic but it's his one I can recall, I'm sure he'll bounce back.


Torres clearly getting to the ball, so how does Anastasia head it past Hart then?

Hart's fault, end of.

Nastasic , bloody spellchecker
 
Re: It's Time to Drop Joe

i♥city! said:
Outlaw said:
One of the stupidest decisions I have seen a GK make; and it was not like there was no defender, Nastasic was the one nearer to the ball and he is not to be blamed for his action.

Pellegrini has to make the brave decision of putting Pantilimon in Goal....

Hart was charging out and Nasty saw him coming . Nasty should have obstructed Torres. I wouldn't blame hart for this loss.

Clearly Nastasic did not see him coming too close, there was no communication between them!
 
WNRH said:
Simply not good enough, a keeper should be number one priority in the summer, until then Pantilimon will do.
The thing is though, will he? If we had a keeper of Lopez or Begovic's quality in the squad I have no doubt they would have featured instead of Hart by now. Pants has made mistakes in the small amount of games he's played for us, and he doesn't exactly fill me with confidence when he starts, and clearly doesn't for the manager otherwise we would have seen him play.
 
Hart is not saving us points anymore. He could actually have dived and stopped the cross for the first goal. He stays on his line when he should come for crosses and when there is absolutely no danger comes out and causes a huge mess up. He has become too big for his boots and has to be dropped. I said sometime ago we might be surprised by Pants - we need to find out.
 
Re: It's Time to Drop Joe

i♥city! said:
Outlaw said:
One of the stupidest decisions I have seen a GK make; and it was not like there was no defender, Nastasic was the one nearer to the ball and he is not to be blamed for his action.

Pellegrini has to make the brave decision of putting Pantilimon in Goal....

Hart was charging out and Nasty saw him coming . Nasty should have obstructed Torres. I wouldn't blame hart for this loss.
We all know with nasty on Torres as a goalkeeper you stay at goal and let your defenders defend ..if he had done that nastys header back to the keeper would've looked very calm and tidy
 
pudge said:
cookster said:
pudge said:
the balls coming down then if Nastasic is heading it?

And Joe was coming on to it..... maybe it might have dropped given the laws of physics.

Or even then, keepers have heads too!!

Shocking revelation for you I take it

Having an argument with you is like having an argument with my wife. You're obviously right!
Having an argument would mean there's two contributions towards the point, not nonsensical unfunny quips tbf.

So with that I'm clearly not having an argument with you.

You really are like my wife, sulking now because you're wrong but won't admit it. Diddums.
 
@BluePhil8 said:
WNRH said:
Simply not good enough, a keeper should be number one priority in the summer, until then Pantilimon will do.
Summer?

And what? Have Hart cost us even more points? Bid for Casillas and Valdes in January.
This shows you up for how hell bent you are against Hart, if you read his comment, he said Pants will do until summer not Hart.

Jesus.
 
He´ll get better and better, goalies are at their best in their thirties. But we can't afford to wait for it to happen.

His actions on the second goal was utter shite.
 
BlueTG said:
Shaggy said:
Was it me or was Heart out of his area ? what was he going to do catch it ? the fucking great pork chop !
Or kick it because he has feet.



Would loved to have seen him try and kick it at that height
 
Pants really deserve his chance now, time for Joe to get his act together, and hope that he can regain his place on the merit required by a title challenging team. City need to look to the transfer market to keep all challengers for goalkeeper sharp and keen. This position over the last few years as become too automatic.
 
@BluePhil8 said:
WNRH said:
Simply not good enough, a keeper should be number one priority in the summer, until then Pantilimon will do.
Summer?

And what? Have Hart cost us even more points? Bid for Casillas and Valdes in January.

Did you see Valdes yesterday?
 
You have to be realistic. Joe's form has not been good enough for 18 months. He is a good keeper but not one who can operate at the top level. He makes brilliant reflex saves but he can't pass the ball to a City player. He has saved us in many games, including Moscow last week, but he is just making too many errors and it is costing us points. At least four so far this season. Pellegrini has some big decisions to make. It is obvious to all City fans that we are weak at left back, holding midfield and centre back (too reliant on Vinny) If these issues can be tackled then we will be a fantastic team. The margins between success and failure are so small at the top level. Chelsea were lucky today but we have to face facts. The team is just a bit short to win the Premiership at present. We have still got time to address it..but not much.
 
Re: It's Time to Drop Joe

Joe has become a liabilty. At the moment I would be far more confident with Pantillimon in goal.
 
Re: It's Time to Drop Joe

Sit on his ass the whole game but decided to come out to play high ball outside the box when his pal was nearest to the ball, yeah very clever...
 
BlueTG said:
WNRH said:
Simply not good enough, a keeper should be number one priority in the summer, until then Pantilimon will do.
The thing is though, will he? If we had a keeper of Lopez or Begovic's quality in the squad I have no doubt they would have featured instead of Hart by now. Pants has made mistakes in the small amount of games he's played for us, and he doesn't exactly fill me with confidence when he starts, and clearly doesn't for the manager otherwise we would have seen him play.

Panti will do?? Hes better than that! (for first comment)

Panti is a good keeper he didn't make mistakes against Villa in the league cup like a lot of Hart fans try to say ,he just wasn't very good! He also made a mistake in the semi final against Chelsea but that didn't cost us a goal fortunately, and in that same game he made some match winning saves!

But what you have to understand with Panti he doesn't get regular football like Hart does he only gets a game every couple of months yet he still does good! He has made magnificent saves and has had man of the match performances when he has had a chance. So to say he makes mistakes as well is very very harsh as he has never ever made a proper mistake like Hart constantly does!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top