Swings and Roundabouts -Decisions for and Against

Tiatto's Blue Nose said:
Yesterday the officials were Mark Clattenburg, S Beck and J Collin. We conceded 4 goals with 2 of them clearly offside.

In April the officials were Mark Clattenburg, S Beck and J Collin. We conceded 4 goals with 2 of them clearly offside.

I'm sure it'll be a long wait before we get gifted 4 goals from these bent bastards.

Edit:

http://www.premierleague.com/en-gb/referees/appointments/
Click to expand...

This team of officials obviously for me are bent when it comes to doing city games. Twattenberg has an issue with city for years. I remember the Bellamy incident at Bolton.

The guy is a cheat and a **** to boot
 
mrtwiceaseason said:
Just how good is that defensive line ,they must have worked all week to get it that spot on.
Click to expand...

No real surprise that MDM was so annoyed at the half time whistle is it. As you say, you work hard, do your job correctly and then get shafted by the officials, no comebacks on them just a yellow card to add insult to injury.
 
mayo31 said:
This team of officials obviously for me are bent when it comes to doing city games. Twattenberg has an issue with city for years. I remember the Bellamy incident at Bolton.

The guy is a cheat and a **** to boot
Click to expand...
His best performance was the Liverpool Hillsboro anniversary game, if ever an official played the occasion then it was his finest, the handball punch out by skirted near the end with mr battenburg looking straight at it was one of the most blatant I decide games decisions I've seen not forgetting the two penalty calls since mr Wilkie and mr gray graced the top tier football.
 
Bozzie said:
No real surprise that MDM was so annoyed at the half time whistle is it. As you say, you work hard, do your job correctly and then get shafted by the officials, no comebacks on them just a yellow card to add insult to injury.
Click to expand...

That is the worst thing about it, our defensive line is impeccable making it easy for the lino to make a decision. If that doesn't make you angry as a city fan then nothing will.

They might as well call all decisions against us and in the eyes of some 'City' fans it would still be the players and managers fault....
 
Not at all convinced De Bruyne was offside - think he timed it perfectly. Watching on NBC the commentators (one of which was Danny Mills, so no bias there!) both said he was onside on the freeze frame in the first half (with the lines and everything to help judge) then at half time they had another shot a frame or two further on where he looked offside - really did depend where they froze the shot, and I think that means it was too close to call.

Unlike the Spurs disgrace.
 
If you look at the lines on the pitch, DeBruyne isn't offside. It's parallax of the camera angle that made it look different.

Agree with the earlier poster, that our defensive line was brilliant on their first goal. That's MDM's specialty and why he was so incensed at the decision.
 
SalfordCityBlue said:
Not at all convinced De Bruyne was offside - think he timed it perfectly. Watching on NBC the commentators (one of which was Danny Mills, so no bias there!) both said he was onside on the freeze frame in the first half (with the lines and everything to help judge) then at half time they had another shot a frame or two further on where he looked offside - really did depend where they froze the shot, and I think that means it was too close to call.

Unlike the Spurs disgrace.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I was watching the NBC stream as well on my android box - cracking picture by the way so up yours BT, you ain't getting my money you biased twats - and he looked onside going off the pitch lines. Oh, and as bad as Mills has been at times he was ok yesterday. If anything he was going out of his way to point out the decisions that went against us had a huge bearing on the outcome of the match.
 
No matter how hard I try, giving Crappenberg the benefit of the doubt and branding him a thoroughly honest guy, tear-arsing across the pitch for the love of football, I cannot understand, bending over backwards and shoving my head up my arse till I appear out of my own mouth, how a linesman can NOT see something as clear as that first offside! What in the name of universal fuckwittery was he watching. I would love PiGMOL and Old Mother Riley to come out and explain where and how his braincells were focused. A simple explanation from the guy would suffice if Mike R thinks such things are beneath him!
 
Dave Ewing's Back 'eader said:
No matter how hard I try, giving Crappenberg the benefit of the doubt and branding him a thoroughly honest guy, tear-arsing across the pitch for the love of football, I cannot understand, bending over backwards and shoving my head up my arse till I appear out of my own mouth, how a linesman can NOT see something as clear as that first offside! What in the name of universal fuckwittery was he watching. I would love PiGMOL and Old Mother Riley to come out and explain where and how his braincells were focused. A simple explanation from the guy would suffice if Mike R thinks such things are beneath him!
Click to expand...
I've been racking my brain because normally when an official fucks up you can see some sort of reason or mitigating factor that caused the mistake. Was the sun in his eyes? Were there players blocking his view? Was the player too far away? Was he too close? Nope. I'm left with him being abducted by aliens and temporarily replaced by a blind dumb clone, and these aliens operate in a dimension where 2 seconds to us is sufficient time for them to do whatever investigation work they needed to carry out and replace him without anybody noticing. Sorry mate, but it's all I can come up with.
 
It annoys me that a professional game can be decided or influenced by these kind of decisions.

I like many others paid a lot of money to go to watch the game and things like this happen. Disgraceful really.

The linesman should be dropped down a few leagues to learn the rules
 
If this has to be a thread then you can at least try & make it as fair as you claim you're trying to;

"2. De Bruyne offside for City's goal, Demichelis 2nd yellow". Why are the two incidents in our favour combined, whereas any against us have their own line?

Also in CP match they should of had a penalty, if Nasri's was a penalty then Dinho fouled a Palace player with just as much contact.

We've been unlucky so far this season no doubt but this thread is totally pointless if it's just going to be one sided to make it look like we're being shafted even more than we actually are.
 
Bit of a stat here...

Both the lino's in the Spurs match (Beck & Collin) have officiated our matches together 5 times since the beginning of last season. We've only ever won 1 of these matches.
 
steviemc said:
Bit of a stat here...

Both the lino's in the Spurs match (Beck & Collin) have officiated our matches together 5 times since the beginning of last season. We've only ever won 1 of these matches.
Click to expand...

If this had happened at the swamp when whiskey nose was in charge they wouldn't have been there again after the third time.
we need to start making more noise about this. Pellegrini is too nice. He should have come out and said that the fact the linesman is incompetent changed the course of the game. We sit back and take way too much shit but if no one complains about it, it won't change.
 
Blue Mooner said:
No idea how you can genuinely believe this. If two decisions are 'proven' to have been offside how can you claim that the officials had no bearing on the result!!?

Of course you could claim we might have finished better in the first half but we didn't, however, we were still leading the game. You or I have no idea what might have occurred had the correct offside been awarded in the first half, but to deny this had any bearing on the result beggars belief.
Click to expand...
He doesn't believe it, he's just trying to get attention.
 
Don Karleone said:
CP1GMGdWIAQqlCq.jpg


BENT!!
Click to expand...
no other answer.
 
1. We clearly have the offside line down to a tee, especially when MDM is playing. There is little point in training all fucking week if they do it so well but the mistakes of a set of bent bastards ruin all the good work.
2. I have seen a still of the Kane goal. The linesman is watching Erikson take the kick. He isn't even looking across the line. We may as well go fucking Sunday league and give one of the subs the flag!
3. Anyone who says it had no bearing is an imbecile. You go in one up and it's totally different for both sides. We didn't play well in the second half but they cost us big time, no doubt about it.
4. If we are not officially reporting the fucking corrupt tosses then we may as well pack in. I would be insisting they don't come within a mile of us in future. The shite can do it so why not us?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top