I’m one of the few (who’d admit it!) who got a Silver, and I can honestly tell you the whole experience has been great. I was a lapsed STH and couldn’t see a way back in after those who took a break during covid returned. Got lucky in the free for all, 2 adults one junior and put them on pay monthly, then paid up front for the big six games, which I’d put some money aside for…..when added together the price of the tickets was actually lower than the price of the same season tickets from last season, now that maybe an anomaly and not repeated next season. There are also other positives (for me anyway) the direct debit wasn’t so high, access to cup schemes, sitting in different seats for big six games, i.e. we sat in SS1 for the derby & we’re sat in SS2 for Chelsea, last home game. I’ve had no problems with digital ticketing, and purchasing tickets for the big six was so easy, you’ve obviously also got the facility to sell your ticket or pass it on to others with a supporter number. If I was to give you the best advice possible (without wanting to sound patronising) it would be to purchase the memberships, this gives you the option of having the money returned if you’re successful, get on the phone when they go on sale and try for a Silver (if that’s all they offer) get SC’s in the family stand on pay monthly and tuck some funds away for the big six tickets, you can then select those games to suit your budget, preference of where you want to sit and even sit a game out if you want. I’ve never felt like I didn’t have a season ticket, it’s proven cost effective (especially compared to buying match to match) it’s given great flexibility and maybe even access to an upgrade next season.
I hope I’ve given you enough there to chew on, people have obviously had strong feelings about Silvers but I can’t honestly think of one negative, it’s all personal preference of course but I would say look deeper than the surface when thinking about whether to get one
I would also add, tickets for the derby & Liverpool are getting increasingly difficult to obtain, the SSC at least gives you the opportunity